Casey's Pizza

1170 4th St, San Francisco
(415) 814-2482

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Baby Lettuce Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Fennel Sausage
Lil' Gem Ceasar
East Coast Pie
Caesar Salad
Funghi Pizza
Arugula Pie
Baby Salad
Margherita

Menu

SALADS
Burrata Salad
Fresh burrata with arugula, cracked black pepper, lemon juice, Maldon sea salt, house-made crostini, extra virgin olive oil.
Baby Lettuce Salad
Organic local baby lettuces, red grapes, toasted almonds, house made sherry vinaigrette, shaved grana padano Serves 2
Little Gem Ceasar
Little Gem lettuces, grana padano, house made dressing and croutons. Super bright, refreshing and lemony. (Dressing contains a touch of anchovy) Serves 2
Marinated Olives
Mixed Italian olives 🫒
Jersey Salad
A zesty take on a classic Italian salad served back East. Romaine lettuce, portobello mushroom, Mama Lil's Sweet Hot Peppers, red onion, DiStefano burrata, Zoe's spicy salami, aged balsamic/extra virgin dressing, grana padano Serves 2

PIZZA
Margherita
The classic pie: red sauce, basil, mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil
East Coast Pie
A pie inspired from growing up near NYC and eating some of the classics. Red sauce, Ezzo cupping pepperoni, fresh and aged mozzarella, grana padano, basil
Arugula Pie
Wild arugula, red onion, mozzarella, grana padano, lemon juice, extra virgin, chili flakes
Hot Pie
A very zesty pie with a bit of heat to say the least. Zoe's pepperoni, red sauce, garlic, mozzarella, feta, hot cherry peppers
Fennel Sausage
North Beach's Molinari sausage, mozzarella, red sauce, red onion, garlic, fennel seed, anise, topped with fresh arugula
Hot Bianca
Mozzarella, ricotta, Zoe's bacon, basil, red onion, cherry peppers, garlic.
Bianca
The classic white and green pie of Italy. mozzarella, ricotta, fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil
Popeye
Roasted baby spinach, red onion, mozzarella, finished with goat cheese, balsamic, and extra virgin olive oil
Spicy Pie
Zoe's spicy salami, mozzarella, onion, garlic, post oven ricotta, Mike's Hot Honey drizzle, fresh basil.
Funghi
Portobello mushroom, mozzarella, garlic, thyme, red onion

DESSERT
Casey's Sundae
Vanilla ice cream, toasted almonds, Bariani Extra Virgin olive oil, Luxardo maraschino cherries, Maldon sea salt - decadent! Serves 2

SIDES
Mike's Hot Honey
Great for dipping and drizzling on our entire menu. 2 oz. portion

BEER
Russian River - Pliny The Elder
1
Mixed Hoppy - 4 Pack
Super local, hoppy and fresh 4-pack from the Bay's best craft breweries. Four 16 oz cans. Cellarmaker, Fieldwork, Alvarado, and others.
Local Craft IPA - 16oz Can
Dealer's choice from our IPA inventory. Could be Cellarmaker, Alvarado, or Fieldwork. Will be fresh and hoppy.
Cellarmaker Brewing - 4 Pack
Each year's hop harvest is often thought of as a linear progression: present becomes the past all the while moving into the future. Unbeknownst to most of us, Turok: Mosaic Hunter, exists within a pseudo-Pacific Northwest – hop farms of the now, the past & those that have yet to come – traveling between periods of time seeking out the best Turok: Mosaic Hunter West Coast IPA • 7% ABV Mosaic for your IPA. Here at Cellarmaker we relate to Turok. Our satisfaction comes from finding the best hops no matter where or which crop year they are, as long as they are FIRE.
Best Day - Kolsch (Non-Alcoholic)
A very tasty and local NA Kolsch
Solid Ground Brewing - Dry Cider
Arkansas Black apple hard cider. Amazing cider, crafted like wine. 16oz
Fieldwork - Headliner (NA West Coast IPA)
Simply one of the best NA IPA's available right now. And of course that is because it comes from the king of all things hoppy, Fieldwork Brewing. This NA is super dank and delicious courtesy of both hops and hop oil (terpenes) additions. It almost has a hoppy, black tea like quality. And a beautiful fresh hop aroma on the nose, very rare for NA's. Enjoy!

WINE
Howard Park - Estate Chardonnay 2022
Our Estate Chardonnay is the quintessential expression of Talley Vineyards, representing the cool climate and hillside topography of our home on the San Luis Obispo Coast. The refreshing complexity of the 2021 vintage is placed with hints of apple and caramel accents. VINTAGE 2021 VARIETAL Chardonnay APPELLATION San Luis Obispo Coast VINEYARD DESIGNATION Various, San Luis Obispo Coast HARVEST DATE Hand-harvested, August 2022 AGING Aged 11 Months in 20% new French oak barrels , 3 months in tank BOTTLING DATE January 2023 ALCOHOL % 13.5 TASTING NOTES Aromas of Asian pear, peach nectar, lemon rind, citrus blossom with flavors of Golden Delicious apple, crushed rocks, pear, flint, caramel with a refreshingly complex finish.
Yalumba - Y Series Shiraz-Viognier 2020
Bright crimson in color. Luscious and exotic aromas and flavors of Turkish delight, red cherries and boysenberry with hints of white pepper and violets. Enjoyable velvety tannins provide a perfect complement to the cherry and chocolate finish which shows the synergy between these two grape varietals.
JAX - Y3 Cabernet Sauvignon 2021
1
Malene - Central Coast Rose 2023
Bright and fresh with notes of melon, watermelon, grapefruit, and stone fruit balanced by a vibrant acidity leading to a clean and refreshing finish. Malene Rosé is crafted with a focus on quality, featuring a crisp, textured, and complex profile. Sourced from prime vineyards renowned for Provencal varieties along the central coast, the wine is produced in harmony with sustainable practices. Produced and bottled in San Luis Obispo, California.

DRINKS
San Pellegrino - sparkling mineral water 750ML
Maine Root - Root Beer
The one that started it all. Handcrafted root beer made with extracts of wintergreen, clove and anise. All our recipes are sweetened with Fair Trade Certified Organic sugar, so you can feel good about it! Ingredients. Carbonated pure water, Fair Trade Certified organic cane sugar, spices. Caffeine Free.
Fieldwork Craft Sodas - Ginger Ale
Fieldwork Craft Sodas! This is not your grandmother's Ginger Ale. Naturally flavored, this big and spicy ginger soda delivers intense flavors without the sugar content of mainstream sodas.
Diet Coke
Coke

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+77 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+76 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

My wife and I often walk our dog past Casey’s Pizza, but we had never stopped in because it always seemed busy. We finally decided to give it a try last night, and I can honestly say we had been missing out. The pizza was absolutely outstanding—fresh, perfectly crisp, and made with dough that has incredible flavor.

We also had the pleasure of meeting the owner, whose customer service was exceptional. Since it was our first visit, we asked for his recommendation,...
February 2026
Best east coast style pizza on the west coast. Our favorites are the Bianca, hot pie & caesar salad but honestly you can't go wrong here. They use high quality ingredients and put real care into every order.
February 2026
We’ve been going to Casey’s for several years, and we’re both serious pizza snobs. I can say unequivocally that Casey’s is our absolute favorite pizza in San Francisco and beyond.

The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and filled with a genuine sense of community and goodness. And the pizza? Simply outstanding. The crust is perfection, the sauce is unreal, and whatever magic Casey puts into it makes it hands-down the best we’ve ever had.
Casey’s...
February 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Cafe Réveille - 610 Long Bridge Street
Cafe, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
House of Tadu Ethiopian Kitchen - 1130 4th St
Ethiopian, Vegan, Vegetarian
JOE & THE JUICE - 1155 4th St
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Coffee & Tea, Acai Bowls, Vegan

Casey's Pizza

1170 4th St, San Francisco, CA 94158
(415) 814-2482