Very light with sauce and light in salt. Taste homemade and the crust is chewy yet crispy on the outside. Very willing to do customized orders and very friendly. I've had better pizza but not as healthy and the service was great for a pickup order. Excellent beer choices as well. Got German beers that were excellent and I would not have ever been introduced to otherwise.
Twisted C.
I will give my review of Bluebird Pizzeria in one word--"YUMMY"!!!!!!! Just make sure you get your order in early!!
Robert R.
I think people in the area like the idea of this restaurant and are greatly appreciative of having a different, more modern, diverse, and inclusive pizza place. However, the end result is not all that. The pizza is expensive and after ordering from them many times, just sort of soggy and not very tasty. Cheaper and more run of the mill chain restaurants are more statisfying for solely the pizza. However, every product they sell other than pizza is truly amazing. The cannoli and especially the pistachio cannoli is best I've ever had. This is a must order. Their drink, beer and wine selection is very nice. Service is very pleasant and ordering/pick up is dependable. I don't bother ordering here any longer as I just want classic, not chain restaurant, but good pizza that is not overly pretentious. Which is certainly an element to this venue. Try Rubiano's instead as a nice compromise between chain pizzas and homemade specialty pizzas. Rubiano's is more accessible and a bit more straight forward in their service and product.
Damon Tighe
Excellent pizza, the dough is lite, fluffy and the topping to sauce ratio is just right. Solid beer tap options as well. I was surprised how fast they can crank out a recently ordered pizza. A couple TVs up so could be good place to watch a game, staff was helpful.Wheelchair accessibility: No ramps or stairs, pay counter may be high for some, but staff seems very helpful with any situation
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amelia Johnson-Post
order ahead for carry out for sure. my go to is the cheese pizza with hot honey and ranch ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza
Melissa h.
I have been going to this pizzeria for years now it is my most favorite when it comes to a margarita pizza with pepperoni! If you haven't given this place a try yet you are really missing out! Fran, the owner is a wonderful, kind human being. Her staff is friendly and attentive, but most of all her pizza from the crust to the ingredients is the best. If you love pizza like I love pizza you gotta give this place a shot. You will be so happy you did epic pizzeria!
Jesse D.
Fantastic neighborhood spot. Probably a place you'd think of just for to-go orders but have very much enjoyed a pie in a booth.
Nicole C.
It's a YES for me! I'm from the east coast and pizza isn't CA best attribute! But after a friend took me here, this place hits home, but then again the owner is a female and from NJ! She was loud and served great pizza, couldn't ask for much more!! I left feeling like I was right back on the east coast! If you're looking for a thin, nice fluffy crust, great sauced pizza, don't miss this place!
Laura T
Hubby and I ordered an E Street Combo Pizza with Fresh Mozzarella, Salad and Canoli for our weekly take out lunch.We ordered online for specific pick up time. Website is user friendly.We got the 12 inch E Street Combo with kalamata olives and fresh mozzarella. I highly recommend both. The fresh mozzarella took that already yummy pizza up a level, beautifully. So good!!Their salad is fabulous, and I love the walnuts. The dressing looks and tastes freshly made.The canoli are lovely.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Salad
Jason Kwong
NY-style neighborhood pizza joint. Best in the East Bay. Limited dine-in seating, cozy atmosphere.
A small owner operation with fantastic staff and excellent food! I wanted to try this spot for some time now and my sister's birthday was the perfect excuse. We ordered 2 12 inch pies and were jot disappointed. The dough is delish and the toppings top notch. Order ahead online because they do actually "sell out".
Monica L.
The pizzas here are fantastic! I appreciate that they're not greasy. It almost tastes like a healthier option, allowing me to indulge a bit more than the usual. The one thing lacking would be the amount of sauce on the pizza but still love it.
eric k.
Best New York style pizza in the east bay. Order early as they do run out. Cannoli for dessert. They need to open one in Castro Valley :)
Edmund Tran
Picked up the first slice and all the toppings slid right off. Still pretty tasty, but just means they were skimping on
Very light with sauce and light in salt. Taste homemade and the crust is chewy yet crispy on the outside. Very willing to do customized orders and very friendly. I've had better pizza but not as healthy and the service was great for a pickup order. Excellent beer choices as well. Got German beers that were excellent and I would not have ever been introduced to otherwise.
I will give my review of Bluebird Pizzeria in one word--"YUMMY"!!!!!!! Just make sure you get your order in early!!
I think people in the area like the idea of this restaurant and are greatly appreciative of having a different, more modern, diverse, and inclusive pizza place. However, the end result is not all that. The pizza is expensive and after ordering from them many times, just sort of soggy and not very tasty. Cheaper and more run of the mill chain restaurants are more statisfying for solely the pizza. However, every product they sell other than pizza is truly amazing. The cannoli and especially the pistachio cannoli is best I've ever had. This is a must order. Their drink, beer and wine selection is very nice. Service is very pleasant and ordering/pick up is dependable. I don't bother ordering here any longer as I just want classic, not chain restaurant, but good pizza that is not overly pretentious. Which is certainly an element to this venue. Try Rubiano's instead as a nice compromise between chain pizzas and homemade specialty pizzas. Rubiano's is more accessible and a bit more straight forward in their service and product.
Excellent pizza, the dough is lite, fluffy and the topping to sauce ratio is just right. Solid beer tap options as well. I was surprised how fast they can crank out a recently ordered pizza. A couple TVs up so could be good place to watch a game, staff was helpful.Wheelchair accessibility: No ramps or stairs, pay counter may be high for some, but staff seems very helpful with any situation
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
order ahead for carry out for sure. my go to is the cheese pizza with hot honey and ranch ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza
I have been going to this pizzeria for years now it is my most favorite when it comes to a margarita pizza with pepperoni! If you haven't given this place a try yet you are really missing out! Fran, the owner is a wonderful, kind human being. Her staff is friendly and attentive, but most of all her pizza from the crust to the ingredients is the best. If you love pizza like I love pizza you gotta give this place a shot. You will be so happy you did epic pizzeria!
Fantastic neighborhood spot. Probably a place you'd think of just for to-go orders but have very much enjoyed a pie in a booth.
It's a YES for me! I'm from the east coast and pizza isn't CA best attribute! But after a friend took me here, this place hits home, but then again the owner is a female and from NJ! She was loud and served great pizza, couldn't ask for much more!! I left feeling like I was right back on the east coast! If you're looking for a thin, nice fluffy crust, great sauced pizza, don't miss this place!
Hubby and I ordered an E Street Combo Pizza with Fresh Mozzarella, Salad and Canoli for our weekly take out lunch.We ordered online for specific pick up time. Website is user friendly.We got the 12 inch E Street Combo with kalamata olives and fresh mozzarella. I highly recommend both. The fresh mozzarella took that already yummy pizza up a level, beautifully. So good!!Their salad is fabulous, and I love the walnuts. The dressing looks and tastes freshly made.The canoli are lovely.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Salad
NY-style neighborhood pizza joint. Best in the East Bay. Limited dine-in seating, cozy atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious
A small owner operation with fantastic staff and excellent food! I wanted to try this spot for some time now and my sister's birthday was the perfect excuse. We ordered 2 12 inch pies and were jot disappointed. The dough is delish and the toppings top notch. Order ahead online because they do actually "sell out".
The pizzas here are fantastic! I appreciate that they're not greasy. It almost tastes like a healthier option, allowing me to indulge a bit more than the usual. The one thing lacking would be the amount of sauce on the pizza but still love it.
Best New York style pizza in the east bay. Order early as they do run out. Cannoli for dessert. They need to open one in Castro Valley :)
Picked up the first slice and all the toppings slid right off. Still pretty tasty, but just means they were skimping on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4