Fire Island Grill

$ • Hawaiian, Salad

About Fire Island Grill

Fire Island Grill is a welcoming restaurant known for its fresh and delicious food. Guests often enjoy the variety of bowls, with popular choices being chicken and steak bowls, served with vegetables and a variety of sauces. The menu features daily specials, including a great $7.99 chicken bowl, which many recommend. The food is generally fresh, and customers appreciate the option of different sauces and the option of extra meat, though some find the portions or extra charges disappointing. The staff is friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable, making it easy for first-time visitors to understand the menu and choose their meals. The restaurant offers a comfortable atmosphere, and many visitors plan to return for the good food and friendly service. Overall, Fire Island Grill is a great spot for tasty bowls and a pleasant dining experience.

Customers' Favorites

Volcano Salad

Chicken Bowl

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Fire Island Grill Reviews

4.3

28 ratings

71%

11%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Fire Island Grill

Write a review

Food was very delicious! A special thanks for Nicolas for making my first trip an amazing experience I will for sure be back!

August 2026

Really delicious food, fresh, filling, good portions and great price!

I'm certain we'll be back! They'll give you extra veggies if you're not able to have the rice or noodles.

Chicken and jerk sauce were my favorite!

August 2026

Lots of options and affordable for the portion sizes and how fresh it is. I liked how there was a hefty vegetable serving! The plate portions are huge. Mac salad was peppery but it was still tasty! Service was quick and friendly, clean tables and seating area. No major constructive criticism or negative comments to say. I’ll come back for a quick, affordable and healthy bite in the future :)

May 2026

Read All Reviews(28)