Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta
$ • Pizza, Italian, Burgers
Hours:
664 Plumas St, Yuba City
(530) 443-2908
About Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta
Customers' Favorites
Recent Reviews
Share your opinion about Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta
If you’re in the Yuba City area and haven’t tried Celestino's Pizza, let me save you some time — just go. 🍕
We ordered two pizzas — one giant regular crust, and one gluten-free — and both were absolute perfection. The crust was cooked just right: crisp on the bottom, soft on the inside, and not too thick or too thin. That magical “just right” balance. The toppings? Loaded. Not skimpy. Not scattered. LOADED. Every bite had melty, gooey cheese and generous...read full review
100/10 haven’t found pizza like this since I’ve been from back east. so happy you guys are in Yuba now.
My wife and I have been in CA for about 8 months, searching for pizza reminiscent of the east coast, and we finally found it!! Highly recommended! They even do pizza by the slice!!! :)
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9:30PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9:30PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Yuba City Also Viewed
Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta is considered a great and reliable go-to spot in Yuba City for authentic New York style pizza and comfort food done right. Reviewers consistently praise the excellent food, calling it the best in Yuba City. The pizza earns high marks for its fresh, flavorful, and crisp quality, with a crust that is fantastic. Specific praised menu items include great cheese pizzas, the Oscar’s Spicy Luau, the Louie De Palma, and perfect meatball subs. The food tastes homemade, well-balanced, and is noted for not being overly greasy. People recommend the chicken wings as well.
The service is generally described as great, with staff and management noted as being super nice and apologetic when resolving rare order mistakes. The seating area is clean and nice. While the wait can be quick, some note a consistent wait time when ordering by the slice. The pricing is viewed as solid for the current normal. Overall, it is a place many would drive past competitors for and will definitely return to, with some joking it could put other pizza places out of business.