Recommended dishes: The Mountain Goat Pizza, Willy's Each Wing, Thai Pie, The Aegean, Pesto, Taco Pizza, Pepperoni Jalapenos Pizza, Smoked Pearl Pizza, Wing, Pizza
Molly M.
Their shop is adorable and the food is amazing (it's stayed the same since I can remember). They treat everyone like family and I always come get pizza when I come home to visit.
Ariana Perez
Food here is good and service is really nice 100% recommend ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Molly K.
We have loved Nick & Willy's for over 20 years. The Aegean and Santorini are solid favorites - piled high with fresh ingredients. No lie on the advertising there! Yea - it isn't cheap, but good food seldom is. It is worth it to have it freshly made by hand. We love the down to earth staff, always incredibly friendly. Still our favorite for great pizza. (I am a long time Boulder resident - not from SF by the way.)
Christina Rand
Daniel is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sietske
We started and ended our vacation in Boulder with a pizza from Nick N Willy's, and both times they where delicious. Great guys working there. Very friendly and the second time they even recognized us (and remembered my order). Worth a visit!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shayna Macklin
$4.50 for a slice of what looks like .99 cent pizza? NY would never have the audacity.
Kyle Castleberry
He looked baked. No offense if that wasn’t the case. Anyway I was ignored amongst them helping two sets of folks before me when I was ready before both sets and was there before one set. I didn’t have time to deal with whatever was going on there. Bummer y’all. I like the pizza though.
Amanda H.
Holy JEEZ the prices went up. I ordered one single extra large Penny Lane pie - a vegetarian pizza, nothing else - and before tax it was $30. I would normally come here if I'm on this side of Boulder, which I'm not often, but for $35 after tax for a pizza with no meat that's not happening anymore. Beware that the prices in the pictures on Yelp are absolutely not accurate anymore and they don't tell you your total when you order on the phone unless you ask.
Craig A.
Meh. Stopped in for a snack and purchased a cookie. It was $3.71 and not good. A lack of chocolate chips and very crumbly. Seemed a bit stale.
We purchased a take-and-bake on Friday night, and I have gotta say it was delicious. The ingredients were fresh and piled high. We ordered The Aegean and would absolutely order it again. With that being said, the cost of the pizza was a bit of a turn off. I'm all about paying for quality, but this felt exorbitant for a take-and-bake pizza. I also will say the inside didn't feel incredibly clean when we arrived, but perhaps I judged too quickly and it was just bad timing. We would definitely go back again.
Dwayne
Honestly, I was tired of walking /shopping and had gotten hangry, so as we sat on the wooden picnic table in the best sunlight and Boulder warmth I gazed upon the corner establishment emanating fresh baked dough and cheese and wings. It was Nick-N-Willy’s. The pizza slice is built right before you and the wings are roasted to perfection almost indistinguishable from the fried version. The sauces are in bottles in the condiment section. The prices were fair and my spouse and I shared the single portion size. Also they do take-and-bake as well. The perfect hangry on the go food item.
MSteffen 411
Some of the best pizza I have ever had. They make the pizza right in front of you and it’s amazing. Fun talking to the workers as well.
jacob smith
SAVE YOUR MONEY!! Among the worst pizza I've ever had. Better pizza could be acquired cheaper whole, frozen or not, than I paid for one slice. Even the salad was terrible. My first bite of the pizza was just a mouthful of burnt, the dough was dry and hard all over, the toppings overly salty and rubbery. The tomatos in my salad were way under ripe, and the onions on top were cut in rounds, forcing me to pluck them out and cut them up and put them back on so I could eat it correctly. The lettuce leaves were humongous, forcing me to slurp it up like some sort of salad speggetti. Overall poor eatability. I feel pretty cheated. The sign inside probably proclaiming this to be the best pizza in Boulder as voted over 25 times tells me I'll have to leave town to get pizza.I only ate as much as I did of it because i paid so much for it. (sunk cost fallacy I know). I don't feel so well. Good luck?Service was great however, and a quaint building too.
Ann F.
Not only is this pizza top notch, but so is there service. I ordered a pie with goat cheese, but instead it came with mozzarella. They weren't able to deliver a replacement and I wasn't able to pick one up. So George arranged for a new pie to be cooked up for me today. Is was so so good! I inhaled half in a sitting. :) Gluten Free crust! Goat cheese! Awesome topping options. I'll definitely be back!
Incredible place everything is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Mountain Goat Pizza, Willy's Each Wing, Thai Pie, The Aegean, Pesto, Taco Pizza, Pepperoni Jalapenos Pizza, Smoked Pearl Pizza, Wing, Pizza
Their shop is adorable and the food is amazing (it's stayed the same since I can remember). They treat everyone like family and I always come get pizza when I come home to visit.
Food here is good and service is really nice 100% recommend ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have loved Nick & Willy's for over 20 years. The Aegean and Santorini are solid favorites - piled high with fresh ingredients. No lie on the advertising there! Yea - it isn't cheap, but good food seldom is. It is worth it to have it freshly made by hand. We love the down to earth staff, always incredibly friendly. Still our favorite for great pizza. (I am a long time Boulder resident - not from SF by the way.)
Daniel is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We started and ended our vacation in Boulder with a pizza from Nick N Willy's, and both times they where delicious. Great guys working there. Very friendly and the second time they even recognized us (and remembered my order). Worth a visit!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
$4.50 for a slice of what looks like .99 cent pizza? NY would never have the audacity.
He looked baked. No offense if that wasn’t the case. Anyway I was ignored amongst them helping two sets of folks before me when I was ready before both sets and was there before one set. I didn’t have time to deal with whatever was going on there. Bummer y’all. I like the pizza though.
Holy JEEZ the prices went up. I ordered one single extra large Penny Lane pie - a vegetarian pizza, nothing else - and before tax it was $30. I would normally come here if I'm on this side of Boulder, which I'm not often, but for $35 after tax for a pizza with no meat that's not happening anymore. Beware that the prices in the pictures on Yelp are absolutely not accurate anymore and they don't tell you your total when you order on the phone unless you ask.
Meh. Stopped in for a snack and purchased a cookie. It was $3.71 and not good. A lack of chocolate chips and very crumbly. Seemed a bit stale.
Restaurantji Recommends
We purchased a take-and-bake on Friday night, and I have gotta say it was delicious. The ingredients were fresh and piled high. We ordered The Aegean and would absolutely order it again. With that being said, the cost of the pizza was a bit of a turn off. I'm all about paying for quality, but this felt exorbitant for a take-and-bake pizza. I also will say the inside didn't feel incredibly clean when we arrived, but perhaps I judged too quickly and it was just bad timing. We would definitely go back again.
Honestly, I was tired of walking /shopping and had gotten hangry, so as we sat on the wooden picnic table in the best sunlight and Boulder warmth I gazed upon the corner establishment emanating fresh baked dough and cheese and wings. It was Nick-N-Willy’s. The pizza slice is built right before you and the wings are roasted to perfection almost indistinguishable from the fried version. The sauces are in bottles in the condiment section. The prices were fair and my spouse and I shared the single portion size. Also they do take-and-bake as well. The perfect hangry on the go food item.
Some of the best pizza I have ever had. They make the pizza right in front of you and it’s amazing. Fun talking to the workers as well.
SAVE YOUR MONEY!! Among the worst pizza I've ever had. Better pizza could be acquired cheaper whole, frozen or not, than I paid for one slice. Even the salad was terrible. My first bite of the pizza was just a mouthful of burnt, the dough was dry and hard all over, the toppings overly salty and rubbery. The tomatos in my salad were way under ripe, and the onions on top were cut in rounds, forcing me to pluck them out and cut them up and put them back on so I could eat it correctly. The lettuce leaves were humongous, forcing me to slurp it up like some sort of salad speggetti. Overall poor eatability. I feel pretty cheated. The sign inside probably proclaiming this to be the best pizza in Boulder as voted over 25 times tells me I'll have to leave town to get pizza.I only ate as much as I did of it because i paid so much for it. (sunk cost fallacy I know). I don't feel so well. Good luck?Service was great however, and a quaint building too.
Not only is this pizza top notch, but so is there service. I ordered a pie with goat cheese, but instead it came with mozzarella. They weren't able to deliver a replacement and I wasn't able to pick one up. So George arranged for a new pie to be cooked up for me today. Is was so so good! I inhaled half in a sitting. :) Gluten Free crust! Goat cheese! Awesome topping options. I'll definitely be back!