The Fifty-Niner

We visited the Fifty-Niner for the first time this weekend. It was honestly disappointing. It was very dark and very cold. It was hard to see the games because it was so dark and the game selection was limited. I ordered the hot chocolate and the cheese board. The cheese board is pricy but worth it. Everything on it was delicious. The hot chocolate tasted like chocolate water and was not great. The service was ok. The waitress was attentive and nice. I doubt we will be back but if you go I highly recommend the cheese plate.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

Bummer that they allow children in a speakeasy style bar, with sticky hands all over the games, bumping into tables and spilling drinks. Really feel like this BAR would be more successful as an actual bar, rather then allowing small children in, especially after 9pm on a Saturday. Particularly disappointing when you spend a significant amount of money on games in their store, have a reservation to play, and then can't play the game.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

super super nice staff and the drinks were really yummy!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place was pretty cool. There were only 2 other groups there so I can't speak to when it is busy.... drinks were good but a little pricey. I was disappointed in their game selection, but there were a few classics in there we had fun with. Didn't get food but I would probably eat before hand again if we went again. I would also probably bring my own game too lol.

Great service, great atmosphere! Love this little hole-in-the-wall gem!

We had a good time, our waiter was attentive and made good drinks, we enjoyed playing the provided board games.

Laid back atmosphere, great food, and great service. Small place but fit our party of 8 just fine. We had a great time drinking, eating, and playing board games they provided. Highly recommend for anyone looking to have a fun game night with friends and family.

Cool vibe. Good gluten free brownie.

We booked at table this past Saturday and had a nice time playing board games. There is a lot of selection there and all the games were in good condition. The drinks were reasonable priced. I knocked down some stars for the food- the grilled ham and cheese sandwich definitely not the best I've had. The bread was extremely hard and the sandwich itself was sickly sweet and so sticky. Sticky plus games isn't a good combo. The pickles are also super sweet so it doesnt help balance it out at all. We would be back to play games and drinks but head somewhere else for food!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Not what we expected out of a "speakeasy". It was really more of a game room where you can order food and drink in the back of a game store. We had to have reservations though about 3/4 of the tables were empty. The lighting is very bright. I would not describe this as a speakeasy at all.

Drinks were all amazing, and the food was top-notch. There are lots of games to play while you are there as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Charcuterie Board with Cheese Pairing

Eclectic and fun atmosphere. Server was kind and a great mixologist!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

🌟 5 stars! 11/10! 🌟 You must try out the 59’er if you happen to wander into Old CO City. The food is delicious, 😋 the drinks 🍹 are great, and the atmosphere ✨ is the best part! So many awesome people; tons of games and fun. 🎲 🃏 Highly recommend, check it out the next time you’re in the area. 😏 ✨ 🥂 🎉🎊

Inclusive LGBT+ establishment. Cocktail bar.

Prices for the cocktails are fair and the drinks are well made. There's a large variety to choose from. Fabulous conversation with the bartender.

They host events on some weekends that you have to buy tickets to, so don't expect to be able to just walk in and get a drink if you're not there for the event. Check their schedule.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Such a nice atmosphere! Great place to grab dinner and drinks with friends and play some board games. There’s seriously so many to choose from.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5