Mikey's Pizza
$ • Pizza, SaladAbout Mikey's Pizza
Customers' Favorites
The Cheesesteak Extreme
Shell Pasta w Marinara
Large Slice of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Roll
Garden Salad
Greek Salad
Mikey's Pizza Reviews
147 ratings
Share your opinion about Mikey's Pizza
I been eating pizza at Mikeys since the first day it opened and when we’re in town it’s our go to for pizza. Another thing I like about it is no gimmicks and hard working crews. Thanks Mikey.
The OG and always comes through. Order a fresh pizza for pickup or takeout and one will never look back. The hot sandwiches/subs are delicious and the pasta salad is a fresh-cool sensation. Real people tossing real pizza pies!
Single slice is the way to go for quick lunch with a drink
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
Mikey's Pizza, located in Crested Butte, is known for its New York-style crust and reasonable prices. The restaurant allows customers to customize their pizzas with unique toppings such as pickles, vinegar chips, and cream cheese. A single slice of pizza is large and filling, priced at only $4. Mikey's Pizza has garnered praise for its delicious, thin crust and affordable cost, making it a standout in the area.
The restaurant offers a variety of options, including the ability to buy a single slice or a whole pizza. Customers can enjoy the cozy outdoor seating, which features ski-themed furniture, creating a relaxed atmosphere. The menu includes generously sized calzones, fresh salads, and a selection of subs, with the pizza consistently praised for its great taste. While there is limited indoor seating, the restaurant is an excellent choice for those who want to take their pizza to go.
Recent reviews highlight the incredible pizza slices and unique offerings like the pepperoni pizza roll. However, some customers noted that the chicken parm sandwich was relatively pricey and lacked sufficient chicken. Despite this, Mikey's Pizza remains a popular choice among locals and visitors alike, especially for its gluten-free crust and quick service. The restaurant is a great spot for those looking to enjoy homemade pizza in a relaxed setting.