The Italian
$$ •About The Italian
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza
The Italian Reviews
55 ratings
Share your opinion about The Italian
Great pasta but stay away for the chicken mine was sogy and taste less not what I expected for the price.owner and staff are excellent out of this world family atmosphere
Excellent dining experience, quaint atmosphere, waitress was amazing, friendly and thoughtful. The dressing and mixed spring greens salad was lovely, dinner rolls were fresh and hot, one of the best Chicken Parmesan I've ever had. Excellent fresh brewed ice tea. No hurry, really enjoyed a great meal.
Thank you.
~Matthew
Thank you.
~Matthew
Funny enough, we discovered The Italian after someone complained in a local Facebook group about the restaurant’s snarky response to a review they had left. IMO, the restaurant was right, and as a NJ transplant living in the West, I LIVE for that level of direct snark. So naturally, we had to check them out.
I’m glad we did because our experience was 10/10!
I called the day before to make a reservation since Escalante Days was going on and I figured they’d...read full review
I’m glad we did because our experience was 10/10!
I called the day before to make a reservation since Escalante Days was going on and I figured they’d...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4:30 - 8PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
The Italian is a charming neighborhood restaurant known for its authentic, homemade Italian food and warm, friendly atmosphere. The owners and staff are praised for their professionalism and kindness, creating an intimate yet welcoming setting that feels like a small-town spot. The menu features a variety of well-made dishes, with standout favorites including Lemon Fettuccini, Lasagna, Polenta Lasagna, and pizza, especially the Detroit style pizza which even appeals to those familiar with Chicago-style pizza. The pasta is often homemade, and the sauce is made from fresh tomatoes, resulting in flavorful, fresh-tasting dishes. Guests frequently mention the high quality of the desserts, particularly the homemade cheesecake and Tiramisu, both of which are highly recommended. The restaurant also offers an excellent selection of sutcliffe wines and a nice glass of chianti, enhancing the dining experience. The cozy decor and historic building add to the restaurant's charm. Overall, The Italian offers delicious, well-prepared food in a friendly setting, making it a perfect place for date nights, family dinners, or a satisfying meal with friends.