Choice City Butcher & Deli

104 W Olive St, Fort Collins
(970) 490-2489

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Julia Ewertz

I took my uncle and Dad here for dinner after not coming here in several years... and boy did they do a rebrand I love it! The menu items were all flavorful and delicious and our waitress was so sweet and helpful. The cocktails were also amazing I will definitely be back!

Victoria

Hadn't been there in a while and was shocked when I went in. No more charm, basic modern decor, 6 to 10 dollars more expensive than I remember and removed my favorite burger. Service was nice and attentive and what I did end up ordering was delicious as usual but not sure if I'll be going back again anytime soon.

Maliha Imami

We had a wonderful experience at Choice City! From start to finish, the service was outstanding—our waiter and waitress were both fantastic: friendly, attentive, and clearly passionate about ensuring a great dining experience. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed yet special evening.

The food and cocktails were absolutely delicious. We especially loved the short rib croquettes—perfectly crispy on the outside and rich, flavorful inside. I also recommend trying the Crimeon Amber cocktail, a beautifully balanced drink that paired well with our meal.

Highly encourage everyone to visit Choice City. It’s a gem with competent staff, excellent drinks, and memorable food!

Korey Shearer

Great food. Portions are kinda small portions, but delicious 😋

Al Judd

We visited choice city recently and were pleasantly surprised to find it remodeled/redecorated. The atmosphere is very nice, clean and tasteful.
The staff were all friendly and attentive,
all in a very pleasant manner.
The food was served promptly, hot and very tasty. We had the best reuben (we chose corned beef) that we’ve had in a very long time.
The rosemary chips were quite tasty.
We highly recommend Choice City and will return again and again.

Brendan

Absolutely fantastic after the remodel. The horse tooth burger and tamarind carrots are some of the best food in old town .

Tatum Cochran

If you haven't been to Choice City recently, you haven't been! Their new menu and owners are both fabulous - DO NOT MISS the pork shank with mashed potatoes, the cheese curd appetizer, the duck wings (omg so good), the tamarind carrots, and the plain ol cheeseburger. Every bite was delish! Our group had an amazing time with local beers, beautiful cocktails, and attentive and positive service. Highly recommend!

Carol Cochran

Amazing food and wonderful people. One of the best meals we’ve had in FoCo. Lovi also makes custom cocktails. (And, natch, we loved the local craft beer options too!)

Nicole Hicks

It's been a little while since we've eaten here. The food is still exceptional, the service is still phenomenal. And it has a great vibe inside! We sat out on the patio and someone came to check on us often to see if we needed anything - GREAT service. I got the steak Philly and it was absolutely delish! So glad we revisited and we'll definitely be back again soon!

Daniel Boyce

Favorite burger and craft beer joint in FoCo. Down to earth chill but dignified atmosphere. Alpine burger is my go to. Steak crepes on a bed of arugula is my other favorite (dinner only).
Anybody who disses this place must of had a rare bad experience or it’s just not their type of thing. Hand made burgers and bourbon barrel-aged craft beer ain’t for everyone I guess? I’ve eaten here 50+ times and have always been pleased.

Proud American

Best ruben in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brianna Reichling

We split a Reuben and choice city burger. Easily one of the best Reuben’s I’ve had. Sandwich was well toasted, packed with meat and truly excellent! $15 for a sandwich loaded with meat is well worth it!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Choice City Burger, Ruben

Fadelly Happi

Good food and good deals. On Wednesday nights it’s packed 5-8pm due to the BOGO burgers and cocktails deals.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Choice City Burger

Chip Edwards

My black-n-blue burger was really good (interestingly sweet). The service was good (order at the counter and they brought the food to us). Several other items on the menu that I want to try, so we'll be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacob Davis

Wheelchair accessibility: They have a ramp that leads down to main area. Bathrooms are accessible through back hallway

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Loading...