Choice City Butcher & Deli

Such a lovely place! The food is amazing! The popcorn that is set on the table when you’re first seated really sets the tone for how delicious everything else will be! We had the burrata appetizer and the olives, both were great! The owner stopped by to ask how we were enjoying the food and we had questions about the menu. She answered, made suggestions and even sent a sample of the carrot side dish(delicious) Everything was so yummy. This will be our new go to restaurant!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great atmosphere, food and drinks! This was the first time we have visited in years and we'll be back!

They changed the menu and the inside. I was a little disappointed with the dinner choices and the prices. I was expecting how things used to be.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Seriously, what happened to this place (in the BEST way possible)?! I hadn't been back in like two years, and I honestly thought it was still just the butcher shop. I was totally wrong. They've clearly finished a huge remodel and flipped this place into a genuinely high-end, upscale dining spot. Easily one of the most phenomenal dining experiences I’ve had in Fort Collins lately.

The staff were rockstars. Seriously, top-notch service all night—they were friendly and attentive and made the evening special.

But the food, wow. You must get the appetizers, especially those cheese curds! They fry them in this unbelievable orange-flavored oil; it’s an absolute game-changer, nothing like you've ever tasted. And the main event, the truffle burger, was beyond phenomenal. We had great cocktails, too, and finishing with the pumpkin coconut cake was perfection.

The whole night was exceptional. No question, this is my new regular spot. I'm already planning to be back in the next couple of weeks. It's that good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered a little ‘spoil myself Birthday lunch’. Buffalo Ruben with awesome Jojos, Arugula/couscous salad with fantastic Pesto and a Salted Carmel Cheesecake. Mind blown; everything was amazing! But the cheesecake took me to another realm. Well done New Choice City! Well done!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don't try to use a gift card!!! Can say if the food was any good I have a gift card but apparently they don't honor them anymore. Smelled good, don't know that I will try them if thats how they operate.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 1

We really enjoyed everything we had and the service was exceptional!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The service at Choice City is outstanding. Kai took such good care of me; it was a pleasure to dine there. The dishes are original and unique and a good value.

If I could give a 10 star review for Choice City I'd do it. Not only is the staff wonderful (Ky was our server, Lavi was managing and making cocktails), the food and drinks are superb! We enjoyed a dirty chai martini, tandoori cheesesteak, buffalo reuben, and proscuitto burrata, and because we have gluten and dairy allergies, they made modifications to each dish to make sure we were able to enjoy them safely, including a custom made dressing and vegan cheese. And because it was our anniversary, everyone working that night signed a congratulatory card for us and made the whole evening feel special. I can't wait to go back and will be bringing friends and family with me, A+++ experience overall!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is a must visit when coming to Fort Collins! The inside of the restaurant is super nice, and they have a cute little patio area too. It is order at the front, then they bring everything to you. The staff were so kind and on top of it! The food was outstanding. We compared the buffalo Reuben and the regular corned beef Reuben. We enjoyed the regular corned beef Reuben better; it is fattier and had a more juicy flavor. If you prefer a meat that is leaner, go with the buffalo. Their potato wedges are one of a kind! Most restaurants don’t have perfectly thick, crispy, and fluffy wedges like here. The potato wedges are gluten free since no flour is used in them, but they do share a fryer for those who are celiac. The gluten free bread was delicious, and I appreciate them not skimping on the meat like restaurants usually do with gf bread. The price was way cheaper than expected given the quality of the restaurant and compared to other sandwich shops. We will definitely be back, and I will be thinking about our meals for a while!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent experience! All the staff is phenomenal and the food is amazing. We had the filet and the steak frites. We will definitely be back.

New owners, new menu, food is ok, but definitely not as good as it used to be before management change :(

Prices on par with other nice restaurants in the area! Food was really good-great filets-tender and yummy! Great ambience for conversation-nice music in the background. Service was excellent-always making sure you had what you needed and that you were satisfied with your dinner. An enjoyable evening!

I took my uncle and Dad here for dinner after not coming here in several years... and boy did they do a rebrand I love it! The menu items were all flavorful and delicious and our waitress was so sweet and helpful. The cocktails were also amazing I will definitely be back!

Hadn't been there in a while and was shocked when I went in. No more charm, basic modern decor, 6 to 10 dollars more expensive than I remember and removed my favorite burger. Service was nice and attentive and what I did end up ordering was delicious as usual but not sure if I'll be going back again anytime soon.