Insomnia Cookies

647 Cherry St, Terre Haute
(812) 618-1746

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jessica padgett

In the box of my cookies there was a gnat. And my ice cream had multiple hairs in it. Super overpriced.

Stacia McKeever

Delicious cookies!

MaryAles Mason

It is just insane to spend so much on these cookies for them to be so mediocre, with terrible service to go along with it. I had placed an order for delivery, and it ended up being over $30 for 6 cookies. The chocolate chunk cookie was so small and misshapen, it looks like they just slapped it on their. And then the snicker doodle cookies was extremely doughy in the middle. Don’t make the same mistake I did with ordering here, especially if it’s a delivery, they will just refuse to help you.

Keeley D

literally waited an hour for a delivery order when we were a 2 minute walk away. I was working so I could not come pick it up otherwise I would have.

Ian “NL” Wallace

Can't recommend them enough. 10/10

Rebecca Lodell

Got our order wrong , and we had the receipt for proof. So we tried calling and they proceeded to answer then hang up on us. So I called again a second time and they never answered. Horrible service. If you mess up an order and then decided to hang up , you obviously knowingly messed up the order and decided if was okay to ignore the call. , is just rude and horrible service. 100 out of 10 won't buy from again at this location

Lisa Wenzel

I remember when Insomnia Cookies first came to town a few years ago and I wanted to see what all the hype was about. Very first time I had ordered from them they were wonderful, warm, hot and still gooey! Let's just to most recently been back in town and ordered these cookies are none of the above. I'm not sure what happened, new management or different cook times or something. When I say the cookies in the store are softer then the last two order I've gotten, my kids didn't really even eat them. Good cookies, but not the warm hot and gooey that's advertised.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Emily Johnson

Placed cookie order 24 hours in advance, for 12pm the next day. At midnight, I received a text asking if I wanted my order then or later in the day. (I guess I assumed that by selecting 12pm that everyone knew it was noon) However, when they didn't show up by 12:20pm, I started calling. I sat on hold for 5 minutes each time before being hung up on. I drove over to the store (It's 4 minutes from where they were to be delivered) and was told they left the store at 12, so they should have been delivered shortly after. The employee told me the order was delivered at 12:07pm. However, I left the location at 12:35pm and there were still no cookies there. Then, he finally called the driver and she said she's "on her way" with them. I got a text at 12:55pm that they were delivered. AN ENTIRE HOUR after the requested delivery time. 100% unacceptable. 100% disappointing. 100% the worst customer service I've ever experienced, EVER.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Lisa Cutter

The cookies came promptly and were warm. We tried the S'More cookie and it was ooey, gooey delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Morgan

I placed an order for delivery well over an hour ago. Called about 30 minutes ago and my order was about to leave the store. Still waiting for said order an hour and 10 minutes later. Irritated is an understatement.

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cookies

DENIS MCNEILL

Placed an order and they didn’t even bother to make it had to call before they even noticed. This is not the first issue with this place would not go there unless you wanna wait

Service: 1

Valerie Griffin

Needed the trash taken out but other than that was a nice place. The gentleman was polite. Had to wait on my cookies and pleasantly surprised a bonus extra cookie for my wait. Would recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kerrie York

Cookies were amazing as usual but the service was ridiculous! As a retail manager of 25 yrs, I'm not sure how this employees has a job. The whole time we were ordering he was texting on his phone, then when we were finished, he asked us if that was all we wanted which was completely wrong. I then recited our order again because he missed it the first time when he was not at all paying attention to the only customer in his store. Then, on the way home while opening the box to enjoy, we had 2 of the 8 cookies wrong! How can you not give me 5 mins of your time to make me feel like a valued customer and get the order correct. Do better!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Kermit Hermit

Absolutely the worst staff I've ever seen. Management doesn't care one bit and they refuse to fix the situation. Don't go here unless you want mediocre service and disgusting cookies.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maddie Kolman

Went there to get some cookies and waited for a whopping 20 minutes and then left. It was made clear the man working there could see us and just kept doing his thing. Eventually we left annoyed at the whole situation and had no cookies

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Loading...