Cool pizza spot with really good NY-style slices. They’re truly huge slices, I was full after 1.5 slices and a soda.
Felicia Davidson
The pizza here is amazing! We got the pepperoni, garlic and basil. The flavor is amazing and the crust was cooked perfectly! Definitely will be ordering here again!!
Zach
Always great food, great service, and I also recently was hired by them for some electrical work and the owner was easy to work with and clearly cares about his business! 10/10
Bill Bethell
Pizza tasted good but I'm not sure if it's worth what I paid for. Our BLT had rotten lettuce on it. The service was good, the crust is thin so if you like New York style pizza then give it a try.
Nik Helgeson
Best slice in FoCo, small seating quarters but again, the best slice in FoCo. True new York style pizza
Pizzuh
Best pizza in FC! Great service! So flavor!
Max Brown
Hands down the best NYC pizza in town and probably all of northern CO. The owner makes sure the pizza is always on point and delicious, especially when he's there. I always see him in the back on the front lines doing the dirty work and prepping pizzas, his employees always have good things to say about him too. Yesterday, I went in to try the Tuesday deal of 2 slices and a drink for $5, and I also ordered a big slice extra crispy. I received my big slice first and it was exactly how I ordered it. The deal is great too! One of the new toy machines took a dollar from my daughter, and even though they don't own the machines, the owner made it right. Beyond exceptional service, and the atmosphere fits a NYC pizza joint to boot!
M C
This place usually has a good hit, but not tonight :( Cheese was non-existent, sauce too. Whatever.
Calypso The Fat Racoon
You could tell everyone who worked there wanted to be there. Which is the best! The atmosphere was wonderfully vintage and included arcade games! The pizza was to die for! Wowie! 10/10 would come back!
I've ordered at least half dozen time in last two months. Major problem with one order; it was quickly resolved. Tonight, I ordered ($30+) with a mention about a quality control issue I worried about. Item delivered had exactly that problem; so frustrating! Called and response was indifferent at best. "Sorry; bye". Anyway, I won't order that item and maybe just need to stop altogether. There are lots of other places in town. Being told the owner had made the item that totally ignored by specific request was hardly encouraging.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
abe jadidian
This review is a long time coming as they have been serving me great pizza for years now. They’re always kind, have quick service and not to mention they brought back $1 slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Avarose2019
This place has gone down hill so much. It’s still good if you go in for a slice but I keep telling myself stop placing an order for delivery, and or stop ordering a full pizza it’s a waste of money, buuut I did again and I went with a Sicilian because every time I order a regular one it’s paper thin, falling apart, barely edible, so I figured thick crust would help and the bottom is completely black and burnt. Officially done, there’s much better places in this town anymore.
James Jaramillo
My experience with this restaurant was amazing great staff and great food
Cool pizza spot with really good NY-style slices. They’re truly huge slices, I was full after 1.5 slices and a soda.
The pizza here is amazing! We got the pepperoni, garlic and basil. The flavor is amazing and the crust was cooked perfectly! Definitely will be ordering here again!!
Always great food, great service, and I also recently was hired by them for some electrical work and the owner was easy to work with and clearly cares about his business! 10/10
Pizza tasted good but I'm not sure if it's worth what I paid for. Our BLT had rotten lettuce on it. The service was good, the crust is thin so if you like New York style pizza then give it a try.
Best slice in FoCo, small seating quarters but again, the best slice in FoCo. True new York style pizza
Best pizza in FC! Great service! So flavor!
Hands down the best NYC pizza in town and probably all of northern CO. The owner makes sure the pizza is always on point and delicious, especially when he's there. I always see him in the back on the front lines doing the dirty work and prepping pizzas, his employees always have good things to say about him too. Yesterday, I went in to try the Tuesday deal of 2 slices and a drink for $5, and I also ordered a big slice extra crispy. I received my big slice first and it was exactly how I ordered it. The deal is great too! One of the new toy machines took a dollar from my daughter, and even though they don't own the machines, the owner made it right. Beyond exceptional service, and the atmosphere fits a NYC pizza joint to boot!
This place usually has a good hit, but not tonight :(
Cheese was non-existent, sauce too.
Whatever.
You could tell everyone who worked there wanted to be there. Which is the best! The atmosphere was wonderfully vintage and included arcade games! The pizza was to die for! Wowie! 10/10 would come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our favorite local pizza place. Try the Sicilian!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I've ordered at least half dozen time in last two months. Major problem with one order; it was quickly resolved. Tonight, I ordered ($30+) with a mention about a quality control issue I worried about. Item delivered had exactly that problem; so frustrating! Called and response was indifferent at best. "Sorry; bye". Anyway, I won't order that item and maybe just need to stop altogether. There are lots of other places in town. Being told the owner had made the item that totally ignored by specific request was hardly encouraging.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
This review is a long time coming as they have been serving me great pizza for years now. They’re always kind, have quick service and not to mention they brought back $1 slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
This place has gone down hill so much. It’s still good if you go in for a slice but I keep telling myself stop placing an order for delivery, and or stop ordering a full pizza it’s a waste of money, buuut I did again and I went with a Sicilian because every time I order a regular one it’s paper thin, falling apart, barely edible, so I figured thick crust would help and the bottom is completely black and burnt. Officially done, there’s much better places in this town anymore.
My experience with this restaurant was amazing great staff and great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Parking: Good luck.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Garlic Knots
Loading...