Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop
$$ • Bakery, Custom Cakes, Cupcakes
Hours:
5748 S College Ave Unit D, Fort Collins
(720) 229-6494
About Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Cake
Key Lime Pie
Wedding Cake
Recent Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 5PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 3PM |
People in Fort Collins Also Viewed
Fiona's
Caterers, Bakery, Deli
Cold Stone Creamery
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Custom Cakes
Nothing Bundt Cakes
Bakery, Cupcakes
Buttermilk Bakery & Pie Shop in Fort Collins is a hidden gem with a cult following. Known for their tasty custom cakes, home-baked goods, and the best pies in town, this charming bakery is a must-visit. Their cherry pie is a huge hit, with a flaky, buttery crust and perfectly sweet filling. The shop offers a great selection of baked goods, coffee, and a warm atmosphere, making it a favorite spot for many. Customers have praised the Dutch Apple pie and apple turnover, describing them as very good and so delicious that they plan to order more. The bakery's flexibility was highlighted when they quickly made a small 6" cake for a last-minute birthday celebration, which was said to be "soooooo good" and highly recommended. They also crafted a beautiful wedding cake with a mountain motif, featuring a tasty lemon filling that guests are still talking about months later. The owner and team are appreciated for their excellent service and dedication to making special occasions memorable. Don't miss out on this sensational bakery with a kind owner and amazing treats!