Nick-N-Willy's Pizza

277 Summit Pl, Silverthorne
(970) 262-1111

Recent Reviews

Roman Villarreal II

This was a great idea to stop here after snowboarding all day! I ate about half of my personal pie before I remembered to tell people about it? we got our food so quickly and it was remarkable! I ordered the garden veggie and was extremely delighted to see there were a ton of vegetarian options our chef was so friendly and warm, we’ll definitely be back!

Bruce Workman

5 stars for a superior pie and service with a smile. Perfect thin crust with unique delicious taste. We will definitely be back on the next trip to the area. Employees were all pleasant and were happy in their work. We had a 1/2 margarita and 1/2 sausage/pep. Woofed it all down. Good thing I didn’t order an XL for my tummy’s sake. Highly recommend !Parking: Parking immediately in front of entrance.


I had the best pizza ever at this place. It was truly good. My friends and I got two large and I basically ate 1 by myself, it was sooo good. I recommend if you are craving pizza.

Stefan Loncar

The Mediterranean pizza was bearable. They were very skimpy on the toppings, and the pizza was cold when I picked it up in the 15 minutes like they said. The cherry on top was that they did not honor their Yelp advertisement, so I paid an extra $8 for a already ridiculously expensive 16” “family size” pizza.

Maurizio Acquavella

The best pizza in the area! Great staff!!! And amazing food!!Food: 5/5

Gloria Lizbeth Pech Cervantes

Great pizza and great service!! It’s the best pizza in the town :) since the new owners this place has become delicious

Luis Barnett

The side/ house salad was awesome. Ate it before I could take a pic. Mushrooms, tomatoes, olives, cheese. Tasty and fresh. The pizza was really crispy. Had an 8" and some wings

Diana Medina

Some of the best pizza we've had in awhile. It was fast and the service was great. We plan on stopping by there again next time we are in the area!

Evan Fleming

Pizza was good.Good service.Just got a simple cheese&pepperoni to share.Limited indoor seating. We sat outside at a picnic table. Loud next to the parking lot.Kid-friendliness: Yes, kid friendly. Took my 10 yr old.Parking: Strip mall parking

Anthony Verderaime

We ordered for nick n Willy’s after our wedding as our honeymoon dinner and I have a feeling these slices aren’t all from one freshly baked pizza.

jessica orta

Favorite pizza place! Loved every bite?❤️‍?

Matt Burns

Pizza is great but don't trust the app for when your pizza is ready. Twice now my pizzas haven't been ready when the app said it was. I just showed up 5 min after it said it was ready and they told me it will be about 40 minutes. Here I sit... Waiting....


We stopped here on our way to the Denver airport. We just got the lunch special of a drink and a personal pizza. We both got sausage and it was very good!

Iriis B.

Wow The new owners are incredible! Love that they keep the good quality for everything, from the ingredients for the pizza, the place is small but impeccable and the tables outside are perfect, the service is exceptional. No matter how busy they are they always have an exceptional customer service. Hard working women. This is the type of attention, attitude and work ethic this county needs. All my best wishes for this place. Hope they keep growing and growing.

Kimberly P

Read about the two amazing entrepreneurs who recently purchased Nick-N-WIlly's and just had to give it a try. My husband had the Nick & Willy’s Classic Pizza while I had the Roman Feta Pest Pizza. Both choices were a win. The crust was perfect and the toppings generous.

Load More