Windsor Mill Tavern

301 Main St unit c, Windsor
(970) 833-5124

Recent Reviews

Sort by
HaLee Badger

The drinks and food are amazing! I particularly liked the wedge and bread pudding. Shout out to Eryka for providing amazing service. You can tell she really cares about the people she serves.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

joey taylor

Great hang out👍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Hatton

Great food and ambiance, but they did not have a high chair or seating for my friends baby. Should be standard.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

dave denu

8 of us had a great time tonight and our server, Sophia, was awesome! Will definitely go again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ruth Gomez

This was my 3rd time coming to this restaurant, the first time was exceptionally good, second time not so good...I spoke with the manager about my dinner, the manager was great and made everything right I was very appreciative for how he handled it...3rd time was awesome, the food and the service was exceptional...Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Takisha Ibarra

We went for Valentine's Day Dinner and ate off their Valentine's couples menu. The oyster appetizer was delicious. Our plates came out on the cold side of warm and the waitress was attentive enough to notice I was not happy about it and sent the manager over to fix my plate. My husband did not want to also mention his plate. The food returned well done, vegetables heated, and the crab and lobster mashed potatoes were warmed up a bit more. Dessert was also good.

The atmosphere was nice, the waitress was great, the manager was respectful and even took some money off the bill, the food was good but we both felt it was not worth the special menu price.

I would return again for a drink and to eat off the regular menu, which would have been more variety and cheaper.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

SA B

This place is not worth your time or money, especially your money. When you arrive they ask if you have a reservation as if they're a Micheline Star restaurant and act as if they're doing you a big favor by checking for an availability. Parking is not easy to get. Most of it is street parking and you pay for it. There's parking behind the building where the restaurant is housed but in the evening and towards the weekend it becomes parking wars reminiscent of Christmas shopping. Once you finally park and walk in you are met with an air of arrogance and frigidity. Not exactly an inviting atmosphere. But that's not even the worst part. They are expensive. Unjustifiably expensive. And the only reason we decided to dine there was because we had a coupon - buy one burger, get second burger for free coupon. They had a very limited selection of burgers, all priced $20 and above. $20 for one burger! Our burgers looked like regular burgers. There's nothing special about them or the presentation/plating, but they tasted funny. My husband kept saying that something was off about his burger, that it didn't taste right, and as hungry as he was he only ate half of it and tossed the rest. My burger wasn't any better. We had this feeling that both of them were pre-made, prefrozen and prepackaged, and all the kitchen staff did was nuke them in a microwave. They tasted off, bland and even somewhat plasticky and made us wonder what kind of meat was used to make the patties. I also ordered a cappuchino. Our total before taxes and tips came out to be about $32, and that's including the coupon for a free burger. When we were done with our meal our server brought the portable POS device with our bill on it with a minimum suggested tip of 18% for a good service. Mind you, our service wasn't anything special and average at best. And with insane increase in prices across all food establishments even a 15% tip on food now is a lot more than what it used to be even a few years ago, let alone 18%. The tipflation is insane. Overall, it was an unpleasant and expensive experience even with the coupon and we're not going back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Tyler Fowler

Wonderful service and a fun atmosphere! My husband and I went there the other night to try a new place for dinner and we are so glad we found this place. Our waiter was extremely friendly when we first sat down. The crab cakes, pretzel, and Spedini were absolutely amazing! We will definitely be coming back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary E. Gibson

One of the best happy hours in the area, and daily specials M-Th. Generally great food and atmosphere. Love the Kyoda shrimp app (big enough for a meal IMO), cheese curds, and brussels sprouts.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jen Niswender

Great environment, good food. Take out a small loan though to eat. 1 app and 1 beer was $28 plus tip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kenneth Miles

The best cheese curds outside of Wisconsin might be here but the music selection is even better. I usually stop here when in Windsor.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Teresa Rodriguez

Wanted to love this place but ordered the Brussels sprouts which weren’t cooked at all. Sent them back and them brought them back burnt. Ordered the steak and it was tough. My husband ordered the chicken Marsala and he said it was good. Will try again for lunch and basic food. Wouldn’t recommend for dinner.

Orange Gecko

All the food is excellent, it just might have the best chicken fried steak I've ever had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Spomer

Great spot. Cool atmosphere. Recommend to take guests or clients

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brittney Sampedro

Absolutely recommend!! We typically go to Fort Collins for date night but decided to stay local this time. Very happy we did! The food was outstanding and drinks were delicious. I had the Japanese scallops risotto and my husband had the steak and cake. The crab cake was delicious and the steak was so tender. The risotto was perfectly cooked and the scallops were the perfect texture and delicious! Definitely get the Brussel sprouts and cheese curds. You won't regret it! Owner was so nice and took his time to talk to us. Support this local gem!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...