I had the Soprano and a side of cajun fries. The food was okay, the sandwich was a little bland but the fries were good and the portion sizes are generous. Would definitely try them again, as I gather from other reviews that there are better options on the menu.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Sarah Birdsall
My family and I decided to try Fat Tonys tonight. I have been in search of a good NY style pizza since moving to CT and I may have found it. The pepperoni pizza was great. Also ordered mozz drops, little sack and a margherita pizza.The only thing I wasn’t impressed by was the margherita pizza. The flavor was there, but it was a bit too much sauce for my taste. The crust was also soggy which was disappointing.Overall it was a satisfying meal and we will order again. We will just steer clear of the margherita pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Madeleine Monaghan
best chicken parm. penne vodka..YUM. delish.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla Jesser
The Hot Honey chicken sandwich is a MUST!!! Honestly my favorite sandwich I’ve ever had. Their salads are all great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Braker
We have been in town for a family wedding, and as I was looking through reviews for places to try, I was intrigued by Fat Tony’s menu. We decided to have lunch there today based on reviews and we were not disappointed! My husband had the Soprano on a hard roll, and our daughter got the Fat Tony grinder. We shared some Mozz Drops and also got a Lil’ Bit O Lemon pizza… and ohhh my goodness. Yes. I would eat that pizza every week from now until my earthly exit!!The service was great- they have wonderful attitudes and are so helpful, and even gave me an extra pizza sauce to go, because I haven’t had a good East Coast pizza sauce since moving. Well done, Fat Tony’s! We hope you have many successful years!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chance H.
Just another lunch spot that doesn't deliver on flavor or originality. Mediocre at best. Good location that is being wasted on this joint.
Judy K.
Pizza was just eh. I've had better & after seeing all the reviews expected much better.
Tracy E.
I guess they don't have a lot of people dining in because it felt like we were bothering them. The staff was nice, but busy, after we got our pizza, no one came back to see if we needed anything. The pizza was good and the prices reasonable.
c roy
Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria is a great place for lunch or dinner with its extensive menu of delicious Italian dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic New York style pizza or a hearty plate of pasta, Fat Tony's has something for everyone. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff make it the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with family or friends. Don't forget to save room for dessert, as their homemade tiramisu is simply divine.
Only tried the pizza so far, but was very happy with it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Rube Goldberg
Waited almost 20 minutes for two slices to go. While the to-go slices are quite large, there are two reasons I won't be returning to this pizzeria. One, the pizza tasted rather bland and two, the amount of salt on these slices was actually well beyond even "acceptable." All my wife and I could taste was salt. There are many other pizza places in Bethel and a couple are rather good. Just thought we'd try Fat Tony's as it's relatively new. My opinion --- eat elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Sarah J.
I ordered take out, one veggie pizza. The pizza was super bland, crust undercooked, the veg were undercooked and there was barely any eggplant. 100% do not recommend.
Jean L.
The dining room needs work. It was nice and air conditioned in the place where you order, but the dining room was incredibly hot and uncomfortable. I would suggest trying to get the dining room air conditioned. I had to leave. I wasn’t happy but the food was good and pretty decent.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 2
Austin Albert
I came to this restaurant because of the banter between the owner and some of the folks who gave bad reviews, and wanted to experience this for myself. I was seriously hoping this food was as bad as described so that I could pile in, but I had no such luck. Despite some of the reviews here, the service was incredible, and Thomas working behind the counter had a great attitude and even better recommendations for food. The pizza was a great take on "New York style" pizza, great thin crust structure, clean cut slices, and creative topping combinations. Do yourself a favor and give this place a try, it's worth it.
They suck! Bring pack Salz!!
I had the Soprano and a side of cajun fries. The food was okay, the sandwich was a little bland but the fries were good and the portion sizes are generous. Would definitely try them again, as I gather from other reviews that there are better options on the menu.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
My family and I decided to try Fat Tonys tonight. I have been in search of a good NY style pizza since moving to CT and I may have found it. The pepperoni pizza was great. Also ordered mozz drops, little sack and a margherita pizza.The only thing I wasn’t impressed by was the margherita pizza. The flavor was there, but it was a bit too much sauce for my taste. The crust was also soggy which was disappointing.Overall it was a satisfying meal and we will order again. We will just steer clear of the margherita pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
best chicken parm. penne vodka..YUM. delish.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Hot Honey chicken sandwich is a MUST!!! Honestly my favorite sandwich I’ve ever had. Their salads are all great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been in town for a family wedding, and as I was looking through reviews for places to try, I was intrigued by Fat Tony’s menu. We decided to have lunch there today based on reviews and we were not disappointed! My husband had the Soprano on a hard roll, and our daughter got the Fat Tony grinder. We shared some Mozz Drops and also got a Lil’ Bit O Lemon pizza… and ohhh my goodness. Yes. I would eat that pizza every week from now until my earthly exit!!The service was great- they have wonderful attitudes and are so helpful, and even gave me an extra pizza sauce to go, because I haven’t had a good East Coast pizza sauce since moving. Well done, Fat Tony’s! We hope you have many successful years!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just another lunch spot that doesn't deliver on flavor or originality. Mediocre at best. Good location that is being wasted on this joint.
Pizza was just eh. I've had better & after seeing all the reviews expected much better.
I guess they don't have a lot of people dining in because it felt like we were bothering them. The staff was nice, but busy, after we got our pizza, no one came back to see if we needed anything. The pizza was good and the prices reasonable.
Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria is a great place for lunch or dinner with its extensive menu of delicious Italian dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic New York style pizza or a hearty plate of pasta, Fat Tony's has something for everyone. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff make it the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with family or friends. Don't forget to save room for dessert, as their homemade tiramisu is simply divine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Only tried the pizza so far, but was very happy with it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Waited almost 20 minutes for two slices to go. While the to-go slices are quite large, there are two reasons I won't be returning to this pizzeria. One, the pizza tasted rather bland and two, the amount of salt on these slices was actually well beyond even "acceptable." All my wife and I could taste was salt. There are many other pizza places in Bethel and a couple are rather good. Just thought we'd try Fat Tony's as it's relatively new. My opinion --- eat elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
I ordered take out, one veggie pizza. The pizza was super bland, crust undercooked, the veg were undercooked and there was barely any eggplant. 100% do not recommend.
The dining room needs work. It was nice and air conditioned in the place where you order, but the dining room was incredibly hot and uncomfortable. I would suggest trying to get the dining room air conditioned. I had to leave. I wasn’t happy but the food was good and pretty decent.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 2
I came to this restaurant because of the banter between the owner and some of the folks who gave bad reviews, and wanted to experience this for myself. I was seriously hoping this food was as bad as described so that I could pile in, but I had no such luck. Despite some of the reviews here, the service was incredible, and Thomas working behind the counter had a great attitude and even better recommendations for food. The pizza was a great take on "New York style" pizza, great thin crust structure, clean cut slices, and creative topping combinations. Do yourself a favor and give this place a try, it's worth it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5