Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, Hot DogsAbout Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
The Soprano
Cupcake
Pizza
Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria Reviews
99 ratings
Share your opinion about Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria
Placed an order with Fat Tony’s in bethel for my husband’s birthday party. I worked with Tony in deciding what to order and on his recommendations I went with 2 sandwich platters with a variety of sandwiches…..all delicious. Also an order of chicken nuggets for the kids. Everyone enjoyed the sandwiches and most tried more than one. Tony was a pleasure to work with and we will definitely be back. Highly recommend
First class operation ~ recently had an issue with an order and they immediately took care of it. Great food and service ~ 5 stars!
Best pizza ever!!!!! I ordered the Sicilian pizza and it was amazing
Hours
| Monday | 6AM - 7PM |
| Tuesday | 6AM - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 6AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 7PM |
Fat Tony's Deli & Pizzeria is a family-friendly restaurant offering New York-style pizza and other Italian dishes. Customers frequently praise the quality of the pizza, with many stating that all slices they tried were fantastic. The cheese pizza is well-liked, and the restaurant also serves popular items like the mozzarella cheese bites, jalapeño poppers, and the "Lil’ Bit O Lemon" pizza. The East Coast-style pizza sauce is also appreciated. The restaurant provides catering with sandwich platters that receive high praise, including the "Dat Sticky Chicky" sandwich on sourdough, which is called "phenomenal," and the Carbivore sandwich, described as "increíble." Kids can enjoy chicken nuggets, and the mozzarella bites are described as yummy. Customers also enjoy the rare treat of cream soda.
The staff is friendly and welcoming, often checking in to ensure customers are helped. One memorable experience involved an owner who quickly came to assist after a child's dropped pizza, offering a new pizza in 10 minutes at no charge and giving the child a cookie. This act of kindness has left a lasting impression on customers, who plan to return and try other locations like Notch 8 and Shakedown Street Eat's. Prices are considered reasonable, and the overall atmosphere is positive, with many recommending Fat Tony's highly.