Tall Man’s Homemade Ice Cream
564 Main St, Cromwell
(860) 635-8000
Customers' Favorites
Homemade Ice Cream Flight
Cherry Vanilla Ice Cream
Strawberry Sundae
Small Italian Ice
Small Soft Serve
Large Soft Serve
Salted Caramel
Whipped Cream
Small Homemade
Coffee Toffee
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Tall Man’s Ice Cream is truly the heart of CT 🍦❤️
I was so surprised (and a little emotional!) seeing their new mobile truck show up at my kids’ 5th grade picnic—my hometown favorite from Cromwell now serving scoops in Old Lyme too!
I’ve loved teaming up with Tall Man’s over the years for our Giveback Santa Sessions alongside Karen Ambler, my son’s kindergarten teacher. Their focus on community is what makes them so special—always showing up for families,...
The yummiest creamiest cookie dough ever! We love that they don't add mini chocolate chips--just delicious ice cream with fresh cookie dough pieces throughout. The way it should be!
Homemade ice cream with 16% butterfat is hard to find in CT, highly recommend Tall Man's!!
Pros: multiple flavors. Games on tables to play.
Cons: attitude from server. No waffle bowls. Not able to sample flavors. Large soft serve on cone looks like a kiddie size.
Ice cream not very impressive. Overall won’t come back. Rather go to Woody’s I’ve Cream Shop
Cons: attitude from server. No waffle bowls. Not able to sample flavors. Large soft serve on cone looks like a kiddie size.
Ice cream not very impressive. Overall won’t come back. Rather go to Woody’s I’ve Cream Shop
You May Also Like
Picnic Basket Catering - 554 Main St
![]()
Caterers
Hideaway Pub & Grill - 546 Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Pubs, Cheesesteaks, Burgers
China Dragon - 544 Main St
![]()
Chinese, Vegan