Good place for a quick bite. Pizza is tasty, but can vary in crust thickness and amount of sause from time to time. Not an issue for me but some may not like it. In general it is a thin crust light pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Matthew Luft
A great neighborhood pizza place! Pizza is always great and the calzones are AMAZING!!
Edward Theilgard
THIS IS WHAT I DIDNT GET? GOT CHICKEN AND SPAGHETTI AND SAUCE WHAT HAPPEN FORGOT TO MILK THE COW!! Chicken parmesan or chicken parmigiana (Italian: pollo alla parmigiana) is a dish that consists of breaded chicken breast covered in tomato sauce and mozzarella, Parmesan, or provolone.NEVER WILL BE
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Mike Dinuzzo
It’s a total shame because the pizza is not bad at all!!!! I been buying pizza from them for a while now and I spend the average of $70/80 per week in this place, every time I call I have to ask for them to please clean the oven because every time I found lots of burned corn meal in my box!!!! I guess they don’t need my money i will never go back!!!!!
Angie Beltran
It was my first time here at Paul& eddy’s, and im sorry horrible experience, i got home i opened my plate of spaghetti with sausages’ and it was no sausage’s at all and hardly no sauce and the spaghetti was so soggy , sorry but never again, i just wanted to try, because Saporty is closed on Monday’s ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
John Battista
Asked for my pizza to be cooked well done and when I got it it was very doughy. People were very nice
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Michael Walker
O...M...G... worst pizza ever. My wife ordered this from uber eats the other day and it came burnt.. as in it was pure black on the bottom. The pineapple, ham and cheese used were of lower quality. We will make sure to order from our regular place from now on... only reason we didnt this time was due to the wait time... we were hungry and didnt want to wait. We have no clue how this place is rated above a 4 star... oh and the salad she ordered as well.. she said that it was not that great, that the salad tasted old..
Food: 1
T. S. Collins
Great local pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
43rdblock
The pizza gave me and my son food poisoning. We’ve been throwing up all weekend.
Food: 1
Tyler Kryzanowski
BEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA IN NEW HAVEN.The regular pies are also amazing. My favorite was the chicken fra diavolo.
I have been a fan of Paul & Eddy's for quite some time. It is our go to pizza delivery in Hamden, through the Slice app. But last night...was BAD. Ordered and paid (as we always do) via Slice at 5:30PM. App showed 6:20PM delivery. About right. 7:10PM, pizza still not here. Contacted Slice customer support, via their app, they stated the shop wasn't answering the phone. 10 minutes later (7:20PM, one hour later than stated, and almost TWO hours since ordering), our 2 pizzas arrived. Those pizzas were barely (and I mean BARELY) warm, room temp at best. Both crusts were completely charred - BLACK, all the way around. (I am a fan of an overdone crust, but this wasn't over done, this was BURNT.) And because they were more cold than hot, VERY chewy, and not at all enjoyable. The large mozzarella cheese, half sausage - barely any cheese on it, and a light sprinkling of sausage, maybe a dozen or so small sausage crumbles. Very disappointing. My wife and son both stated, we may have to try other local pizza places in Slice in the future.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ray Crisco
The food is great and love the turnovers. But the pizza is a 3 atbest for me. I'm old school this wasn't myvstyle of pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Turnover, Special Pizza, Italian Combo
Chris Urban
I've been here in Hamden almost 5 years now.....what an absolute shame I didn't find these guys sooner!! Nobody has better pizza in this town and it's not even close!! Ordered white brocolli pizza and a regular cheese pizza and my son and I are in heaven watching football with this. Great job guys!
Good place for a quick bite. Pizza is tasty, but can vary in crust thickness and amount of sause from time to time. Not an issue for me but some may not like it. In general it is a thin crust light pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
A great neighborhood pizza place! Pizza is always great and the calzones are AMAZING!!
THIS IS WHAT I DIDNT GET? GOT CHICKEN AND SPAGHETTI AND SAUCE WHAT HAPPEN FORGOT TO MILK THE COW!! Chicken parmesan or chicken parmigiana (Italian: pollo alla parmigiana) is a dish that consists of breaded chicken breast covered in tomato sauce and mozzarella, Parmesan, or provolone.NEVER WILL BE
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
It’s a total shame because the pizza is not bad at all!!!! I been buying pizza from them for a while now and I spend the average of $70/80 per week in this place, every time I call I have to ask for them to please clean the oven because every time I found lots of burned corn meal in my box!!!! I guess they don’t need my money i will never go back!!!!!
It was my first time here at Paul& eddy’s, and im sorry horrible experience, i got home i opened my plate of spaghetti with sausages’ and it was no sausage’s at all and hardly no sauce and the spaghetti was so soggy , sorry but never again, i just wanted to try, because Saporty is closed on Monday’s ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Asked for my pizza to be cooked well done and when I got it it was very doughy. People were very nice
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
O...M...G... worst pizza ever. My wife ordered this from uber eats the other day and it came burnt.. as in it was pure black on the bottom. The pineapple, ham and cheese used were of lower quality. We will make sure to order from our regular place from now on... only reason we didnt this time was due to the wait time... we were hungry and didnt want to wait. We have no clue how this place is rated above a 4 star... oh and the salad she ordered as well.. she said that it was not that great, that the salad tasted old..
Food: 1
Great local pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The pizza gave me and my son food poisoning. We’ve been throwing up all weekend.
Food: 1
BEST GLUTEN FREE PIZZA IN NEW HAVEN.The regular pies are also amazing. My favorite was the chicken fra diavolo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely delicious. Best pizza in Hamden.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great space, delicious pizza, friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been a fan of Paul & Eddy's for quite some time. It is our go to pizza delivery in Hamden, through the Slice app. But last night...was BAD. Ordered and paid (as we always do) via Slice at 5:30PM. App showed 6:20PM delivery. About right. 7:10PM, pizza still not here. Contacted Slice customer support, via their app, they stated the shop wasn't answering the phone. 10 minutes later (7:20PM, one hour later than stated, and almost TWO hours since ordering), our 2 pizzas arrived. Those pizzas were barely (and I mean BARELY) warm, room temp at best. Both crusts were completely charred - BLACK, all the way around. (I am a fan of an overdone crust, but this wasn't over done, this was BURNT.) And because they were more cold than hot, VERY chewy, and not at all enjoyable. The large mozzarella cheese, half sausage - barely any cheese on it, and a light sprinkling of sausage, maybe a dozen or so small sausage crumbles. Very disappointing. My wife and son both stated, we may have to try other local pizza places in Slice in the future.
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food is great and love the turnovers. But the pizza is a 3 atbest for me. I'm old school this wasn't myvstyle of pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Turnover, Special Pizza, Italian Combo
I've been here in Hamden almost 5 years now.....what an absolute shame I didn't find these guys sooner!! Nobody has better pizza in this town and it's not even close!! Ordered white brocolli pizza and a regular cheese pizza and my son and I are in heaven watching football with this. Great job guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...