Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

Name: Sicily Coal Fired Pizza
Address: 412 Main St, Middletown, Connecticut, 06457, US
Telephone: (860) 788-2237
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.3

$$ • Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian

Hours:
412 Main St, Middletown
(860) 788-2237

Menu Order Online

About Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

Sicily Coal Fired Pizza in Middletown offers a unique dining experience with a variety of outstanding food like the Bianco. The restaurant has a beautiful, cool-looking space with lots of different seating options. Customers can enjoy fun cocktails like the key lime martini, huge salads, and a wide range of exquisite dishes, including the popular Calabrian-Buffalo wings and tasty pepperoni pizza. The menu also features a ham calzone that customers describe as amazing, made with the freshest ricotta and mozzarella with a buttery flavor. The restaurant offers a variety of sandwiches, such as the hot honey chicken sandwich, meatball, muffuletta, and chicken parm, which are often so large that customers can only finish half. The fig pizza is a customer favorite, and the whipped ricotta toast changes its toppings seasonally. The restaurant has a fun, large beer menu, making it a great spot for porter drinkers.

Recent reviews highlight the restaurant's appeal for takeout and family favorites like cheese pizza and chicken cutlet pizza with bacon. Many customers appreciate the modern, clean space with a sophisticated vibe, especially in the rear area near the open kitchen, which provides a quieter setting for conversations. The menu features many interesting and unique salad options, with a wide selection of entrees and both GF and standard pizza choices. One customer enjoyed lamb chops with a frisée and fennel salad topped with pomegranate and radish, served with a sriracha aioli, though they felt it was good but not great. Another praised the harvest salad with grilled shrimp, noting the shrimp were crisp and flavorful, and the salad was large enough to take home half. For dessert, deconstructed cannoli with delicious filling and biscotti bits on the side are a popular treat, especially accommodating GF needs. Although cocktails are not always ordered, the table next to a reviewer enjoyed an espresso martini that was described as insane. Service is generally good, and the atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for many locals. The staff is helpful, even for special occasions like engagement celebrations and surprise announcements. Overall, Sicily is considered a favorite in Middletown for its environment, food, drinks, and friendly staff.