Sicily Coal Fired Pizza
412 Main St, Middletown
(860) 788-2237
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Food was decent but not worth the price. If I’m going to pay $40+ for an entree I expect it to be fantastic but our dishes could have used more flavor. The lobster gnocchi did have real chunks of lobster but the sauce the was bland and extremely oily. One of the servers asked if we wanted Parmesan and then handed us a shaker like we were at a cheap pizza joint. I will say the truffle fries were excellent. Overall disappointed as I had heard good things.
No one came to the hostess stand and give us no attention! Has been waiting for 20 - 30 mins. We just want some nice good pizza.. bad services! My bf and I won’t go there ever again.
I hadn’t been in in a while my favorite server Lauren left, and the owner seemed very volatile. Food was nothing special, but I couldn’t believe the way they were treating their employees. It’s been a Few weeks since I’ve been in and I went back-and-forth with writing this post, but I feel like I had to say something for the people that work for them. They are not nice people!!!!
Every time I come by here, I order the ham calzone. It is amazing and they use the freshest ricotta and mozzarella. The buttery flavor is amazing. Coming from NJ, this is my go-to stop on the way to Mass/RI area.
Great drinks and food. If. You sit by the front door, you can feel the cold weather. I would suggest the opposite side of the bar or a table near the back. The upstairs lounge area is pretty cool.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan
The only issue we were told we only a hour to eat. Was put in down stairs we had 2 people with walking issues & had problems with stairs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries, Margherita Pizza, Burger
Unprofessional management.
The customer service here is shameful and they’re racist on top of it.
This is the NASTIEST place in Middletown. Pizza NASTY! And I mean NASTY! Service is TERRIBLE! They’re prejudice against black people. Take your money somewhere else, it’s not worth it.
Staff is rude. Prices are high.
Restaurantji Recommends
I like this place. My issue is with the service. My friends and I went for happy hour. I was late and got to the restaurant at 5:59. Hh ends at 6. I asked if I could order one drink and the earlier said no. This is fine but the drinks are at least $12 to $18 and they way I was treated makes me feel like you don't want my business. Afterwards the waiter almost got the orders wrong. However they did come back to the table to check on us. I have mixed feelings so just make sure you're on time and if you have issues they may not be amendable to making adjustments.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
This place is cancelled af, I’m just here for the tea 😂
Delicious pizza! We sat at the wine bar and the ambience was great, there was even live music with a pianist. Certainly will be coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Appetizer and the restaurant were great. Unfortunately, their Sicilian pizza was just bread that was separately baked with cheese and sauce on top. Maybe that’s the norm here, but the cheese literally peeled back to reveal a fully crusted bread. It was obvious that the sauce and cheese were topped after the fact and the bread was just reheated.
Chicken parm cigar appetizer was good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
We have been twice now. Dinner both times. Mashed potatoe pizza, beer and sangria. To start a bread with pepper salsa was brought to the table. The pizza was great. We were outside and service was phenomenal, waitstaff really hustle. Sorry no pics. Last inside Dinner, app was pretzel as big as my head with 3 dipping cheeses..beer/sangria..Harvest Apple salad with grilled chicken for me and porchetta grinder for him..bread and salsa given again..waitstaff attention was top notch..the food is diversified..NOT just typical Italian pasta, they have that too, but you want a pork chop, Okey dokey, haddock, it's there..burgers, and pretzels as big as my head..only thing I would complain about and it's just personal preference is the amount of salt on the pretzel, but it was easily rubbed off..if you haven't tried it stop in..they even advertise other local restaurants on the stair risers for the 2nd Floor, I told you waitstaff has to hustle..go ahead grab some pizza you won't be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...