Best pizza in mystic hands down. Pizza’s great service is great. The Sicilian is amazing. My family and I usually get one Sicilian and one round pie.I feel like this place should be way busier, quality of the food is amazing. Sometimes I have to pick up the pizza during boys night with my sons. The woman behind the counter will bring the pizza to my car so I do t have to take the boys out of the car. Which is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael McCarron
Ignazio's is easily the best pizza in Mystic. Highly recommend to anyone; service is great and everything on the menu is fantastic. If you're lucky Valerie will be your server, this place has true Brooklyn charm and pizza quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Wohl
Great pizza fast and friendly order at a reasonable
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Brown
I can't speak to the service/atmosphere because we've only gotten takeout but this has become a regular rotation in our house when we get takeout! The pizza is consistent and the sauce is delicious. They do not skimp on the toppings which I really appreciate as that has been an issue for us at other Mystic pizza establishments.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
Brian Bottini
Had a recent family dinner here with a $50 gift card that I bought a while ago. Food and service were good until they refused to accept the gift card that I bought for my girlfriend's family. The gift card consisted of a menu that they wrote "$50" on which they claimed they could not accept because it didn't have any of the managers' signatures (according to them they double sign every single gift card they give out). I showed the bank statement from when I bought it but they wouldn't budge. These people are running a scam operation, take your business elsewhere (Angie's, Mystic Pizza, or Stonington Pizza Palace are nearby and they won't try to rip you off).
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Maura Faulise
Fantastic pizza! We have been a few times, and each time we bring guests who also end up being impressed. Last time we were there, we happened to sit next some people from New York who frequently travel in Italy. They all agreed that this is top-notch pizza, on-par with some of the best pizzas they’ve had in Italy and NY. We agree!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ben Mahoney
Went in and dined the other day with my family, order a veggie pizza and a caesar salad. The caesar came out fast and was fantastic. The pizza was definitely up to par. Sat next to the oven and it kept us very warm. The wood fired taste really comes through on the pizza to make the flavor stand out. Service was excellent, Our server Valerie was professional, pleasant and accommodating
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
Dave S.
I had a pepperoni pizza at Ignacio's and it was fantastic amazing sauce, perfect herbs, combination, and bits of Ricotta on the pizza was really good.
Jessica Hergert
Best pizza around. “The pizza” and house salad is unmatched to any other spot in New England. We come weekly for our pizza fix. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
Oona Cutrone
Excellent service and food. I highly recommend Ignazio's. Everything was absolutely delicious. Looking forward to going back soon!Thank you Valerie for fantastic service and providing phenomenal food! I truly love your restaurant!
We love the place for their thin crust NY style pizza! We love their regular pizza and also enjoy their Sicilian pizza. We also love their garlic bread with cheese definitely one of the better ones in the area! We had a medium pepperoni and cheese Sicilian and medium pepperoni, sausage and olive pizza. Staff is friendly but it took a long time to receive our drinks which came out after our meal. My husband got the wrong beer he requested and they have a quite limited beer and wine selection & no sangria. There is no changing table in the bathroom but a table you could change your baby on in there. There is a men’s and women’s bathroom in the restaurant as originally I thought there was only one unisex bathroom. They do have Parmesan and crushed red pepper available but I didn’t notice until another table asked for it with their food. Overall, we definitely enjoy their food here and they definitely use good quality ingredients!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
Altena L.
We love the place for their thin crust NY style pizza! We love their regular pizza and also enjoy their Sicilian pizza. We also love their garlic bread with cheese definitely one of the better ones in the area! We had a medium pepperoni and cheese Sicilian and medium pepperoni, sausage and olive pizza. Staff is friendly but it took a long time to receive our drinks which came out after our meal. My husband got the wrong beer he requested and they have a quite limited beer and wine selection & no sangria. There is no changing table in the bathroom but a table you could change your baby on in there. There is a men's and women's bathroom in the restaurant as originally I thought there was only one unisex bathroom. They do have Parmesan and crushed red pepper available but I didn't notice until another table asked for it with their food. Overall, we definitely enjoy their food here and they definitely use good quality ingredients!
Allison K.
What really sticks out about this place is the incredible quality of the ingredients and the caring, friendly demeanor of the staff. Yes it's a cute setting in the heart of a very adorable and historic village. That's just even more reason to visit. The use of fresh mozz on all pies and the simple but amazing crushed tomato sauce. The crust was thin with just enough char & chew. Honestly the best pizza outside New Haven. Try the meatballs!!
Snowyte Np
Waited over 40 minutes for 1 pizza, a salad, and wings to go. Food was good. Price reasonable. Server pleasant. Just slow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings, The Pizza
ned j
Everything was great :) The pizza was absolutely money , waitress made my sons and I laugh and feel at home. So good. Plain cheese…”the pizza “
Best pizza in mystic hands down. Pizza’s great service is great. The Sicilian is amazing. My family and I usually get one Sicilian and one round pie.I feel like this place should be way busier, quality of the food is amazing. Sometimes I have to pick up the pizza during boys night with my sons. The woman behind the counter will bring the pizza to my car so I do t have to take the boys out of the car. Which is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ignazio's is easily the best pizza in Mystic. Highly recommend to anyone; service is great and everything on the menu is fantastic. If you're lucky Valerie will be your server, this place has true Brooklyn charm and pizza quality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza fast and friendly order at a reasonable
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can't speak to the service/atmosphere because we've only gotten takeout but this has become a regular rotation in our house when we get takeout! The pizza is consistent and the sauce is delicious. They do not skimp on the toppings which I really appreciate as that has been an issue for us at other Mystic pizza establishments.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
Had a recent family dinner here with a $50 gift card that I bought a while ago. Food and service were good until they refused to accept the gift card that I bought for my girlfriend's family. The gift card consisted of a menu that they wrote "$50" on which they claimed they could not accept because it didn't have any of the managers' signatures (according to them they double sign every single gift card they give out). I showed the bank statement from when I bought it but they wouldn't budge. These people are running a scam operation, take your business elsewhere (Angie's, Mystic Pizza, or Stonington Pizza Palace are nearby and they won't try to rip you off).
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Fantastic pizza! We have been a few times, and each time we bring guests who also end up being impressed. Last time we were there, we happened to sit next some people from New York who frequently travel in Italy. They all agreed that this is top-notch pizza, on-par with some of the best pizzas they’ve had in Italy and NY. We agree!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in and dined the other day with my family, order a veggie pizza and a caesar salad. The caesar came out fast and was fantastic. The pizza was definitely up to par. Sat next to the oven and it kept us very warm. The wood fired taste really comes through on the pizza to make the flavor stand out. Service was excellent, Our server Valerie was professional, pleasant and accommodating
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
I had a pepperoni pizza at Ignacio's and it was fantastic amazing sauce, perfect herbs, combination, and bits of Ricotta on the pizza was really good.
Best pizza around. “The pizza” and house salad is unmatched to any other spot in New England. We come weekly for our pizza fix. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
Excellent service and food. I highly recommend Ignazio's. Everything was absolutely delicious. Looking forward to going back soon!Thank you Valerie for fantastic service and providing phenomenal food! I truly love your restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball, The Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
We love the place for their thin crust NY style pizza! We love their regular pizza and also enjoy their Sicilian pizza. We also love their garlic bread with cheese definitely one of the better ones in the area! We had a medium pepperoni and cheese Sicilian and medium pepperoni, sausage and olive pizza. Staff is friendly but it took a long time to receive our drinks which came out after our meal. My husband got the wrong beer he requested and they have a quite limited beer and wine selection & no sangria. There is no changing table in the bathroom but a table you could change your baby on in there. There is a men’s and women’s bathroom in the restaurant as originally I thought there was only one unisex bathroom. They do have Parmesan and crushed red pepper available but I didn’t notice until another table asked for it with their food. Overall, we definitely enjoy their food here and they definitely use good quality ingredients!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: The Pizza
We love the place for their thin crust NY style pizza! We love their regular pizza and also enjoy their Sicilian pizza. We also love their garlic bread with cheese definitely one of the better ones in the area! We had a medium pepperoni and cheese Sicilian and medium pepperoni, sausage and olive pizza. Staff is friendly but it took a long time to receive our drinks which came out after our meal. My husband got the wrong beer he requested and they have a quite limited beer and wine selection & no sangria. There is no changing table in the bathroom but a table you could change your baby on in there. There is a men's and women's bathroom in the restaurant as originally I thought there was only one unisex bathroom. They do have Parmesan and crushed red pepper available but I didn't notice until another table asked for it with their food. Overall, we definitely enjoy their food here and they definitely use good quality ingredients!
What really sticks out about this place is the incredible quality of the ingredients and the caring, friendly demeanor of the staff. Yes it's a cute setting in the heart of a very adorable and historic village. That's just even more reason to visit. The use of fresh mozz on all pies and the simple but amazing crushed tomato sauce. The crust was thin with just enough char & chew. Honestly the best pizza outside New Haven. Try the meatballs!!
Waited over 40 minutes for 1 pizza, a salad, and wings to go. Food was good. Price reasonable. Server pleasant. Just slow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wings, The Pizza
Everything was great :) The pizza was absolutely money , waitress made my sons and I laugh and feel at home. So good. Plain cheese…”the pizza “