You need to absolutely try this new place. Timothy and George make you feel so welcome and their drinks are prepared with so much care that you can really taste the difference and quality compared to other average bars. Great and lovely atmosphere. You will not regret it. And they even have an outdoor seating area you can use when the weather is nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Never Bend Never Fold
No one in New England is doing what these guys are doing. I like to come down from Boston now & then. You think, who goes to Mystic to party? Well, the bar hopping is top tier, & it's pretty much all right there so you can stumble from one place to the next. This is owned & seems like entirely run by a couple, & there name's escape me right now. But they HUSTLE. They have all things I like and respect: work ethic, passion for hosting a great time, & seem like good guys. & pissah music. I texted another bartender friend. These guys got it: cozy, underground (literally), high tops, fireplace, lights, music, beer & shots. The recipe is old as time. It's simple, but rare.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Rachel
Stumbled upon this place on BINGO night. Very lively group, extremely welcoming, the owners were great.
Draft beer and pre mixed cocktails, wine.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Kirsten Fountain
THIS BAR WAS AMAZING!!!! The owners are wonderful and we had so much fun. 10000000000/10 recommendation.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Britany Barrow
Absolutely amazing fun little “speak easy”type atmosphere to get out of the sun after a hot day walking around downtown. The owners/bartenders are incredible sweet, funny, genuinely kind people and made our visit SO fun! 100% recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Local Everyday
You know how anticipation for an experience can make or break the satisfaction for the actual experience? Well let me tell you my 6+ month anticipation for the Misfit experience was definitely satisfied and I’ll bet yours will be as well. The proprietors and the clientele were all just magically wonderful. I love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Lynn Krogseng
Ever walked into a room and felt loved, safe, happy? You may have walked in to Misfit Club. The physical space is beguiling. The emotional space is unicorns and rainbows. I was drinking beer on this visit but the wine, cocktail, cider options are considerable. But let’s talk about the feels - I’m going again.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Cajetan D'C
Loved the place—great energy and vibe! Stopped by for a quick drink on my way from Boston to Philly but ended up staying longer. Definitely a safe and welcoming space for LGBTQ+ folks.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Nicholas Rivard
This bar is exceptional. The vibes 🔥, the people 🔥🔥, the drinks 🔥🔥🔥. Just come here. Classic european underground bar with such great vibes and drink options. Loved it! Will be back! Thank you G&T ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
ChubbaMumma
My hubby and I just happened to discover this gem of a bar while vacationing in Mystic. We were instantly welcomed by George and immediately invited to sit at the bar. It was such a great time - everyone there was so friendly, it was like we knew them all more than one night!. Timothy also invited me to ring the last call bell - I was honored! I absolutely cannot wait to return. We are already planning on a trip back to Mystic!!
The most friendly staff and best service! Their house beer, locally brewed, was delicious! Super fun vibe!
Colleen Chase
It takes all kinds of kinds to make this world go round, and the folks over at the Misfit Club have gone out of their way to create a wonderfully warm and welcoming atmosphere for all kinds. Looking for a place to just be yourself while having a couple of fabulous drinks? Misfit Club is the place go.
John Anthony
The Misfit Club is pure magic. From the moment you walk in, you can feel it—it’s more than just a bar, it’s a safe haven where everyone is embraced exactly as they are. The space is gorgeous, the energy is vibrant, and the people absolutely unforgettable!
George and Timothy have created something truly special. Their warmth, sincerity, and infectious joy set the tone for an atmosphere that’s welcoming, inclusive, and full of life. The staff carries that same spirit, making you feel like part of something bigger—a community that celebrates individuality and connection.
This place fills your cup in more ways than one. I can’t wait to go back!!!
John Rainone
If I could give The Misfit Club 100 stars, I would in a heartbeat. This isn’t just a bar—it’s a beautifully curated space full of heart, soul, and acceptance. The decor is stunning, the vibe is electric, and the atmosphere is unlike anything else in Mystic... or anyplace else for that matter! It’s clear that George, Timothy, and their incredible team have poured love and intention into every detail.
What truly sets The Misfit Club apart is the community they’ve created. Everyone is welcomed exactly as they are—celebrated, respected, and made to feel at home. George and Timothy greet you with warmth and genuine kindness that radiates throughout the space. The staff mirrors that same spirit, creating an environment that's inclusive, uplifting, and unforgettable.
This place is absolute MAGIC. I can’t wait to return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Reddish
It’s a bar that when you go in the first time you feel like you’ve been part of their family forever they’re very welcoming.
You need to absolutely try this new place. Timothy and George make you feel so welcome and their drinks are prepared with so much care that you can really taste the difference and quality compared to other average bars. Great and lovely atmosphere. You will not regret it. And they even have an outdoor seating area you can use when the weather is nice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
No one in New England is doing what these guys are doing. I like to come down from Boston now & then. You think, who goes to Mystic to party? Well, the bar hopping is top tier, & it's pretty much all right there so you can stumble from one place to the next.
This is owned & seems like entirely run by a couple, & there name's escape me right now. But they HUSTLE. They have all things I like and respect: work ethic, passion for hosting a great time, & seem like good guys. & pissah music.
I texted another bartender friend. These guys got it: cozy, underground (literally), high tops, fireplace, lights, music, beer & shots. The recipe is old as time. It's simple, but rare.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Stumbled upon this place on BINGO night. Very lively group, extremely welcoming, the owners were great.
Draft beer and pre mixed cocktails, wine.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
THIS BAR WAS AMAZING!!!! The owners are wonderful and we had so much fun. 10000000000/10 recommendation.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely amazing fun little “speak easy”type atmosphere to get out of the sun after a hot day walking around downtown. The owners/bartenders are incredible sweet, funny, genuinely kind people and made our visit SO fun! 100% recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
You know how anticipation for an experience can make or break the satisfaction for the actual experience? Well let me tell you my 6+ month anticipation for the Misfit experience was definitely satisfied and I’ll bet yours will be as well. The proprietors and the clientele were all just magically wonderful. I love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Ever walked into a room and felt loved, safe, happy? You may have walked in to Misfit Club. The physical space is beguiling. The emotional space is unicorns and rainbows. I was drinking beer on this visit but the wine, cocktail, cider options are considerable. But let’s talk about the feels - I’m going again.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Loved the place—great energy and vibe! Stopped by for a quick drink on my way from Boston to Philly but ended up staying longer. Definitely a safe and welcoming space for LGBTQ+ folks.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
This bar is exceptional. The vibes 🔥, the people 🔥🔥, the drinks 🔥🔥🔥. Just come here. Classic european underground bar with such great vibes and drink options. Loved it! Will be back! Thank you G&T ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
My hubby and I just happened to discover this gem of a bar while vacationing in Mystic. We were instantly welcomed by George and immediately invited to sit at the bar. It was such a great time - everyone there was so friendly, it was like we knew them all more than one night!. Timothy also invited me to ring the last call bell - I was honored! I absolutely cannot wait to return. We are already planning on a trip back to Mystic!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The most friendly staff and best service! Their house beer, locally brewed, was delicious! Super fun vibe!
It takes all kinds of kinds to make this world go round, and the folks over at the Misfit Club have gone out of their way to create a wonderfully warm and welcoming atmosphere for all kinds. Looking for a place to just be yourself while having a couple of fabulous drinks? Misfit Club is the place go.
The Misfit Club is pure magic. From the moment you walk in, you can feel it—it’s more than just a bar, it’s a safe haven where everyone is embraced exactly as they are. The space is gorgeous, the energy is vibrant, and the people absolutely unforgettable! George and Timothy have created something truly special. Their warmth, sincerity, and infectious joy set the tone for an atmosphere that’s welcoming, inclusive, and full of life. The staff carries that same spirit, making you feel like part of something bigger—a community that celebrates individuality and connection. This place fills your cup in more ways than one. I can’t wait to go back!!!
If I could give The Misfit Club 100 stars, I would in a heartbeat. This isn’t just a bar—it’s a beautifully curated space full of heart, soul, and acceptance. The decor is stunning, the vibe is electric, and the atmosphere is unlike anything else in Mystic... or anyplace else for that matter! It’s clear that George, Timothy, and their incredible team have poured love and intention into every detail.
What truly sets The Misfit Club apart is the community they’ve created. Everyone is welcomed exactly as they are—celebrated, respected, and made to feel at home. George and Timothy greet you with warmth and genuine kindness that radiates throughout the space. The staff mirrors that same spirit, creating an environment that's inclusive, uplifting, and unforgettable.
This place is absolute MAGIC. I can’t wait to return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s a bar that when you go in the first time you feel like you’ve been part of their family forever they’re very welcoming.
Loading...