Goodie Shoppe

$ • Bakery, Ice Cream

About Goodie Shoppe

Goodie Shoppe is a beloved bakery, coffee shop, and gathering place in New Fairfield. Known for its consistently delicious baked goods, including famous black and white cookies, cakes, and cupcakes. The restaurant also serves high-quality pizza, with a hidden gem being its daily-baked pies. With a huge free parking lot, wheelchair accessibility, and an in-house ice cream man, Goodie Shoppe is a family-friendly destination. Customers praise the selection of sweet and savory baked items, such as pastries, cookies, and breakfast options like bagels. The place is often busy on weekends, especially with regulars, and seating can be a challenge. Recently, visitors enjoyed a fabulous chocolate decadence cake, which was a delightful surprise and highly recommended. The bakery is the perfect small-town spot to stop for coffee or order a delicious cake for any occasion, including special events like weddings.

Customers' Favorites

Raspberry Crumb Cake

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Goodie Shoppe Reviews

4.6

141 ratings

76%

10%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Goodie Shoppe

Write a review

Shout out to the Goodie Shop!

Mark created the most incredible coffee themed cake for my daughter’s bridal shower. It was beautiful, delicious, and unforgettable! Guests couldn’t stop raving!

Thank you, Mark for the amazing job on a very special cake!

I recommend a Mark in the goodie shop for those special treats for your special day!

October 2025

this place is fantastic.They have a great bakery and the people that work there are soooo sweet. Yummmm!!

October 2025

Highly recommend! Marc and staff are fantastic, and everything is great.

July 2024

Read All Reviews(141)