Pizza Pete's
519 Main St, New Hartford
(860) 738-7378
Customers' Favorites
Pineapple and Bacon Pizza
Sausage Tomato Pizza
Mixed Veggies Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pulled Pork Pizza
Three Toppings
Hamburger
Side Salad
Sausage
Menu
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I’ve always enjoyed PP over the last 20+ yrs and stop in when I’m back in the area. It looks like it’s under new ownership and I’m guessing working out the kinks. I ate there two times during my stay. I’d like to see an actual Greek salad (not the chef’s salad but with feta and a few different olives). The margharetta pizza looked exactly like a regular cheese pizza (and arrived with no fresh basil) just more expensive. The dough was good.
It's changed hands recently but the pizza is mostly the same. It's solid and I have no complaints about the quality of the ingredients, the service nor the cooking. It's more just personal preference on what type of pizza I like. I stop here once in a while when going into Avon is too far for me. One thing I'd like to see is their "weekly special" become weekly. If you can't offer one weekly, then try monthly. When you announce you have a weekly...
Pizza Pete's is inconsistent but when they get it right it's worth repeating. March 2023 was a successful takeout, but prior to this we were unable to get two other choices off of their menu for two different weeks because they did not have the ingredients listed on hand. (Steak and cheese and sausage) But, the hot ham grinder in January was very good and three grinders we had this weekend were all delicious - meatball, sausage and chicken parm. The chicken parm was...
You May Also Like
Parrott Delaney Tavern - 37 Greenwoods Rd
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Vegetarian
Brewery Legitimus - 283 Main St b3
![]()
Brewery, Pet Friendly