Custom Cakes near New Haven, CT

“We ordered cupcakes for two different parties in one weekend and Sweet Mary’s did not disappoint. Great, yummy, moist cupcakes and terrific service. Sweet Mary’s is the best for cupcakes hands down!!!“

“omg, I love your "pudding pies" I don't know how to spell the name you call them when I lived in Norwich we would always go for a ride to New Haven and get them !!! my brother still goes when he's in New Haven can't resist !!! Best Bakery“

“Delicious ice cream and milkshakes!“

“I ordered a few trays of cookies for a party I was hosting. I called, a little flustered because I was feeling very last minute. I explained how many people I was hosting and that I didn’t know what or how many to order. They were unbelievably patient with me and told me they would take care of it. And did they ever!!!! Freshly baked, beautifully presented, and SO DELICIOUS! I was thrilled. Guests impressed. Delightful variety. I will be back and I highly recommend you check them out!!!“

“Angelica is a magician with her work! I was introduced to her a few years back and haven’t gone elsewhere since. From graduation parties, baby showers and even engagement desserts. I can’t imagine a party without her sweets. Her treats are always the talk of the party!“

“We had such a great experience with this team! The cookies were beautiful, tasted AMAZING, and were such a great wedding favor. The communication was clear and efficent and they were packed and wrapped beautifully. I have guests still talking about these 2 months later. Thank you!“

“I got a cake from here 2 years and it was exactly what I wanted (the heart cake). My husband loved the taste and kept mentioning it when it got closer to his birthday this year so I, of course, had to get another one. It was AMAZING! Everyone loved it and a few said it was the best cake they’d ever had. Yellow cake with cheesecake filling and buttercream- highly recommend. Steve was also great with communicating and working through my indecisiveness about the design.“

“La atención es excelente y los postres son deliciosos ! 100 % recomendado 👌“