Custom Cakes near Lynbrook, NY

The Sweet Peace Bakery • $$
26A Atlantic Ave, Lynbrook

Customers` Favorites

Full Size Cupcakes
Smores Truffle
Mini Cupcakes
Wedding Cake

“This is a must try for all those with a bit of a sweet tooth. Their cupcakes are soooo good. The owner is such a nice person, and you can taste the love put into the food. Thank you for your generosity and kind spirit.Friendly neighborhood amazon delivery driver ?“

5 Superb35 Reviews
Cakes By Renee J Bakery • $$
6 Glover Cir, Lynbrook

“Allison baked and decorated the most beautiful birthday Cake for my daughters underwater / mermaid themed birthday party. This was a pull apart cupcake with yummy delicious flavors and just as tasty as it was beautiful. In my heart I didn't want anyone to eat it - it was so beautiful lol. The cupcakes had various flavors- they give you many options. Check them out. This will forever be my go to place for delicious cakes and desserts.“

5 Superb9 Reviews
Sweet Serindipty Bakery • $$
Online, Lynbrook

“I came across this bakery by accident and it is in fact a serendipity. I ordered cupcakes for my daughter birthday and they were every bit delicious as they were adorably decorated. The cupcakes were light fluffy and the frosting was perfect and not ultra sweet. I am definitely going to come back.“

4.1 Good46 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
6 Broadway, Lynbrook

“THIS HAS TO BE THE FLAGSHIP. I caught a late night movies at Regal theater, directly across the street, and my friend and I decided to get a sweet treat. Now I’ve been to many of cold stone before , in and out of town, BUT! This has to be the flagship store! The amount of flavors and topping is INSANE!!!!!!! Upon order at 11pm at night, I counted 40 different flavors of ice cream. To add to our heart attack there was a PLETHORA OF TOPPINGS and Bowls I haven’t seen anywhere else. Now I was in the mood for chocolate and cherry and asked for cherry toppings. Just when I thought I was in cold stone ice cream heaven, I was granted access to the upper echelon of experiences when the cashier asked if I wanted cherries OR CHERRY PIE FILLING!!! (my eyes widened, I know they widened lol). So along with all those toppings you never see stacked at most cold stones, they have a nerve to have a secret menu of toppings (please ask) . I had cheesecake ice cream, chocolate brownie, cherry pie filling, with graham cracker crust ( A GOD DAMN DREAM!) . The pie filling was soo good, a must try!! The service was great, they store is open late, and located conveniently at five corners in Lynbrook. This place is absolutely amazing and an ice cream lovers dream. 10/10“

3 Average29 Reviews
Sweet Cats Cafe Dessert • $
168-17 Union Tpke, Fresh Meadows

Customers` Favorites

House Special Pop Corn Chicken
Rainbow Crepes Cake
Molten Lava Cake
Chocolate Mousse
French Fries
Bubble Treat
Strawberry
Mango

“What a nice little snack shop hidden on 164th street between the 7-11 and pizza place. Recommended for kids. Got some super sweet strawberry bubble tea. And cake. And a macaroon. They also have some real food snack options like French fries and chicken bites. Didn’t try the stuffed animal vending machines this time.Kid-friendliness: Stuffed animals on the wall for the kiddies to look at. And sweet dessert foods.“

4.6 Superb99 Reviews
Chillato Ice Cream Shop • $$
17-16 154th St, Whitestone

Customers` Favorites

Gelato Float

“Place is new. We checked it out. Clean place. Excited to have a new gelato place in the neighborhood. I had the Ferraro rocher and it was delicious. My husband had the coffee and lemon flavor and we both ate it all. I'll definitely go again.“

4.8 Superb41 Reviews
Nita's Pastries Inc Bakery •
Holly Ave, Hempstead

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake Chocolate Chip Cookie

“Anita is exceptional. Her cakes and desserts were delicious and a highlight of my sister’s baby shower. She’s professional, thorough and attentive. Anita’s email and number have a permanent home in my contacts. Do yourself a favor and book with her.“

4.9 Superb31 Reviews
Rockaway Beach Bakery Bakery • $
87-10 Rockaway Beach Blvd, Queens

Customers` Favorites

Savory Danish
Pastries

“We are new to the area and wanted to try it. We came in January but they were closed for the month! Today they were open and I ordered 2 chocolate croissants before I found out they only take Venmo or cash. They were kind enough to take my $7 and and a IOU. The chocolate croissant was good although the only other time I had one was in Paris, the one in Paris was better. But I will be back to pay what I owe and try what the reviewers recommend!“

4.5 Superb34 Reviews
Agrigento Bakery Bakery • $$
4032 Austin Blvd, Island Park

Customers` Favorites

Sfogliatella and Cannolis

“Best pastries, friendly owners & staff, have been getting my cookies, pastry, from them for years. Oh,! And they sell their delicious ricotta cheese cake by the slice.Parking: ConvenientWheelchair accessibility: Accessible from the street no stairs“

4.6 Superb46 Reviews
Layers Bakeshop Bakery •
20 Meacham Ave suite g, Elmont

Customers` Favorites

3 Milk Sundae Tres Leche
Lotus Biscoff Sundae
Strawberry Cupcake
Cadbury Brownie
Nutella Sundae
Milk Chocolate
Ferrero Rocher
Galaxy Sundae
Birthday Cake
Oreo Cookie

“One of the best places for cakes and muffins. We were big fan of this place since a long time and glad to come to this new store. The cakes are full of buttercream and just the right amount of sweetness.The ingredients are Halal, so quite a relief for the Muslims to eat the Mousse. Also, appreciate the blend of flavors available.I didn't like the slice of brownie as I found it very dry inside.“

4.4 Superb103 Reviews
Loading...
map Map