Custom Cakes near Mt Vernon, NY

“They are a gem of a bakery. The staff is super friendly and professional. Very willing to help you. The cake we picked was for my daughter's birthday on Kentucky Derby day. They showed us so many options. The cake was a strawberry 🍓 shortcake, super delicious. This is now my favorite bakery. Thank you for a beautiful cake to make the party special.“

“This is a cute spot in the neighborhood. They have everything from cakes, cookies, cupcakes, ice cream and coffee. I love the atmosphere in here and I’m always happy to support a small business.

Also looks like they’re expanding their footprint for some private events and lessons, which is very exciting !“

“My daughter loved the cupcakes, and i loved their price as well as the decor and feel of the bakery. Home has changed lots since ive moved. The only thing that could be better was the person at the register, he was highly engaged in his phone so his responses/interaction was quick short, kind of like he didnt want to be bothered. Overall the place the is 😍“

“This review is a long time coming. Bill, made one of the best cakes I've ever seen for the US Open. Such a pleasure to work with and his creation was amazing! Would definitely use his services again.“

“Great cupcakes and excellent service!“

“OMG! I am not exaggerating when I say the cake I received was not short of amazing. Chocolate Devil's Food with Raspberry buttercream. Tangy Raspberry preserves made from scratch by Jaclyn as well between the layers. Everyone who ate a piece of my birthday cake could not be more satisfied with the level of artistry in the decoration as well as the execution of the taste of the cake itself. I don't think I can go back to buying store bought cakes. They would just fail in comparison!“

“I met her in 2014 and ever since then she makes every cake for any and every event. Not only are they welcoming, professional, lovable, and friendly their cakes are AhMayZinnnnn!! I can say she can literally do anything 🙌🏾🙌🏾“

“Delicious Caesar salad, chicken pot pie (and chocolate donut). Coffee was really good too.“

“Maria makes the best carrot cake, red velvet, trees leches, plain and almond croissants I’ve ever tasted. Her passion for pastry is simply unbeatable. This isn’t because I provide her with same day delivery service, but I’m speaking as her customer as well. Her pastries are crafted with arts and the taste speaks for itself. I’m very familiar with French pastries for far too many years, so mark my words, if you’re looking for authentic French pastries, Les Gateaux De Marie is the place to go.“

“I have used Nerwan for a couple of specialty cakes. Very talented, very accommodating, very delicious, and spot on service. This young entrepreneur went from working from home to a beautiful little location. It is a pleasure to contribute to her rise in this field, so give her a shot for your baking needs or just stop by and try her products you certainly will be pleasantly surprised and pleasantly satisfied.“

“Capy’s cakes and desserts are absolutely stunning and delicious! I work with Uber Eats, and I can’t help but wonder — have you thought about offering delivery through the app? I’d love for the owner to reach out, as I think Capy would be a perfect fit and a huge hit with customers.“

“Besides the beautiful presentation, these cakes taste amazing!! They are moist, fluffy and the perfect amount of sweetness. I ordered the yellow cake, triple chocolate and the strawberry swirl and I am in love!! I really appreciate that Gardner's Gourtment clearly makes completely homemade cakes and luscious frosting.“

“Let me start with I am not one to write reviews however this one is worth the occasion. It was an absolute pleasure working with Wildly Cakes to get a cake for my bridal shower. We had a traveling themed bridal shower and Wildly Cakes was able to make this beautiful world map on the side. But it doesn’t just end there the cake itself tasted delicious. We got a vanilla cake with cookie butter filling and all my guests ranted and raved on how good it was. We actually have our wedding cake being made by them too and we cannot wait to see and taste it especially after this great first impression.“

“The owner Erika was a pleasure to work with. Super helpful with choosing the right size cake. Designed the cake better than the picture I sent. The cross and rosary were so realistic it’s hard to believe it’s sugar. Not only was it a gorgeous cake but so fresh and delicious!“

“Don’t be fooled by the smallness of the place. The breakfast sandwiches are some of the tastiest I’ve ever had. I was looking to order a cake for a birthday, and I was impressed by their photos on Instagram as well as the flavor of the slices they had for sale (one of which I received as a gift). I provided a picture of what I wanted and they did not disappoint! Besides looking beautiful, the cake was moist and flavorful, even days later. Highly recommended!“

“Soo hyped to have found a great gluten free & dairy free bakery. It has classic items like cookies & brownies and more interesting ones like cream puff and mini Bundt cakes. It was reasonably priced too. My favorite has been the cream puff by far, got the chocolate mini Bundt cake (I think it was called a schnibble?) And it was super crumbly, not a huge fan. The lemon poppyseed mini Bundt was better, texture wise and flavor. Will be coming back to try more!! It seems to be a popular spot for cakes and they sell individual slices.“

“Thank you Again Tee. The cake was delicious , I loved the design and coloring. Got 6-7 more orders I’ll be placing very soon. Thanks again sis your the Goat.“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“Experience was great!“

“Have been meaning to try this place out and it was great. Tried four different cupcakes, mini carrot loaf and two cookies. My family loved it all. So pretty too. Can’t wait to go back.“

“I can’t say enough good things about One the Cake. After an order error left me scrambling last minute, the owner went above and beyond to accommodate me and completely saved the day.

The cake was absolutely beautiful and unbelievably delicious — truly the first time ever that an entire cake was finished at a birthday dinner. Not a single slice left. We even shared it with the restaurant staff, and they were so impressed they asked where the cake was from because they couldn’t believe how good it was.

I live almost an hour away, but it is 100% worth the drive. I’ll be ordering from here for all upcoming birthdays without hesitation. Incredible service, stunning work, and amazing flavor. Highly recommend!“

“Amazing birthday cake for my 2-year old princess. Delicious and fun. Well priced for the quality. Definitely would recommend!! Also extra large chocolate chip cookies were incredible. Big hit in my house. Yummy!“

“De Lillo—Celebrating 100 Years of Sugar, Butter, and a Lot of Bronx Pride

I never miss an opportunity to stop by De Lillo…where delectable delights drive me into a delirium driven by a desire for delicious danishes and divinely dark-roasted coffee. 🤓

You don’t survive a century in the Bronx without earning it, one pastry at a time.

The cappuccino was a little piece of heaven, the desserts were just a tad sinful, and the whole experience felt like a visit to the Holy Chapel of buttercream and chocolate.

If you find yourself anywhere near Arthur Ave., De Lillo is an essential pilgrimage.

Highly recommend!“

“It’s incredibly difficult to find a bakery that can make a delicious gluten-free free cake, but Sisters has not only nailed the recipe they have also set a very high standard! Those of us who have to be GF constantly lower our expectations. That’s just how it is! My birthday cake was the most delicious cake I’ve ever had and it was gorgeous! Thank you so much for the attention to detail and for being such amazing bakers! ???“

“The atmosphere was really nice and there were a lot of seating (even though it was filled up because it was very busy). The girls at the counter were so efficient and kind.
The coffee was very good and the donut was absolutely delicious! The donut was the perfect size and the perfect treat if you're craving something small but sweet!
I also got a chocolate cake slice (not sure what it was called exactly) and two Italian rainbow cookies. Everything was incredible and very affordable!“

“I've always loved Carvel. This location everybody is pretty cool. Always great times when I go there. My only problem with Carvel is that they STILL DON'T HAVE rewards points. Everybody wants rewards points, COME ON ALREADY CARVEL!! WE WANT REWARDS!!“

“End of an era. I used to love going to this Carvel as it’s right in the neighborhood. I tried going today 2/16/2026, only to find out it’s another ice cream shop and Carvel, no longer. This Carvel had been in the neighborhood for as long as I can remember. It will be missed.“

“The service is exceptional - when choosing ice cream cakes, always willing to provide advice and take the time to personalize and make each one special. The ice cream cakes are freshly made here and by far the best. Ice cream and shakes are also great at this location. Finally, the equipment is well maintained and sanitary. Carvel does one thing - ice cream - and at Webster Ave it is done right!“

“Delicious ice cream!!🍦🍨🍧😊“

“Outstanding products and an exceptional company! We ordered the 18-piece brownie and cookie sampler as a corporate gift for the 2025 holiday season, and it was a huge success. The recipients—and our team—were absolutely delighted. The treats were delicious, beautifully presented, and truly memorable.

From our very first point of contact through ordering, delivery, and follow-up, the service exceeded our expectations at every step. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. I highly recommend Greyston Bakery for personal enjoyment or as a thoughtful, high-quality gift.“

“Absolutely loved the custom Minecraft cake we ordered for our son’s 5th birthday! The design was flawless, the image quality was excellent, and the cake itself was delicious and moist. Great customer service and a beautiful result. Highly recommend!“

“one of the best coffee I had.. if I have to compare it's better than dunkin donut“

“I can’t say enough about Baked with Love by Abigail. The cupcakes and cookies were amazing if I could give you 10 stars I would. Thank you so much for making this day even more special.“

“Donna made my engagement cookies and brownies for our engagement party. The brownies were sooo delicious and the cookies came out so cute!“

“Demi held it down at this Carvel location with superb service. She was the only staff there that day where there was 7+ customers and still went well and beyond for me when I was pre-ordering a birthday cake. The boss over the phone was also very kind with going through the ordering process and Demi made sure we get everything accurate and helped tailored what flavors, layers, size, designs, and so forth that was recommended. Demi made it super seamless and made sure I was satisfied with my order.
Medium square cake $32~ with edible image print out $4 with free writing and custom crunch toppings as well as border designs was such a great deal here.“

“Amazing cakes filled with lots of flavor !!! Will 100% be coming back“

“Amazing, Always Ready for Anything and Delicious Cakes!“

“They thick shakes aren't thick... That was very disappointing. I wanted a milk shake not flavored milk. Besides that everything else we've gotten there was decent“

“Traveleld From Boston To celebrate my 39 aniversary with Husband in the big apple 🍎 and On Saturday we End up at The Pastora bakery to grab some traditional Sweets pastry felt like home🇵🇷 Athmosphere was Warm♥️ the pastries 🥐 were fresh and the breakfast sandwich was Delicious! Thank you for the good service“

“Cakes are just as delicious as always !! So grateful for the Valencia Crew for organizing a trip to multiple cities in Florida !! So many Boricuas showing up at all locations ! Truly special ! Valencia is #1 ….. not hurry up and open up in Palm Beach !“

“The service is satisfactory. Plenty of flavors and toppings to choose from.“

“Angela is immeasurably talented and the cake she made for my daughter's birthday was truly exceptional - both in design and taste. As a bonus, Angela was delightful to work with and helped bring my daughter's dream cake to fruition. If you're looking for a custom cake, I couldn't recommend Flowerbake more highly!“

“Amazing cake and the owner is so nice! I ordered a fresh mango cream cake and requested lemon be added to the middle. The only suggestion I have is that cream be added to the middle layer as well, which I assumed would be the case as is are most layered cream cakes.“

“I had my first experience in Ben and Jerry’s at 102 st, the staff were very friendly and helpful, recommended lots of flavors and gave me to taste ,it was amazing ♥️♥️♥️ definitely coming back to this place.
Highly recommended.“

“I can see why people complain about the service but I’m literally just here for ice cream since it’s close to home. Parking is right outside. Freezer selection is poor but again, not what I’m here for. Just know what you’re looking for in a business when you walk in“

“Longed for my egg nog n rum raisin ice-cream! N Carvel is the only place i can get them! Also, my children loves it! Who can say no to ice-cream!�“

“Can you consider using actual strawberry puree, or whatever of fresh strawberries on top of your cheesecake? I don't like the artificial strawberry flavor jelly type thing on your cheesecake sold in Bainbridge. Also have bread pudding with and without carmel sauce. Puerto Ricans like myself, and other Hispanics do like with carmel sauce. I don't know who of Mexican background told the woman working there that Hispanic don't like with sauce. Maybe that particular person, or Mexicans but not all Hispanics. Can you also make scones, lobster tail pastry, muffins, stuff you can have for breakfast on the go? The store mostly just has desserts for later in the day(cookies,cakes).“

“Adult bakery. Snooty atmosphere. Staff nicer in recent years“