Custom Cakes in New York, NY

Customers` Favorites

Triple Chocolate Cake
Baby Shower Cake
Graduation Cake
Strawberry Cake
Raspberry Tart
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Coconut Cake
Croissant
Cake Pop

“We had ordered a baby shower cake. The base was a Jaffa cake with butter cream frosting. The cake was fantastic in the way it looked and the taste. The service was excellent. Ms. Marie is a talented artist. Would highly recommend this place!“

4.8 Superb116 Reviews
Cake Lords Bakery Restaurant Bakery • $
1844 Amsterdam Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Red Velvet Cake
Birthday Cake
Cupcake

“Loved the cake made for my husbands 50th birthday party. I got a two tier cake and two dozen cupcakes. Wonderful customer service and reliable delivery. I was in awe at the ease of how ordering went. I was most impressed that I was able to communicate with a person rather than filling out a form online. I will def order again when I need a cake. All the cupcakes got swooped up so fast I didnt even get a chance to have any.“

4.9 Superb40 Reviews
By the Way Bakery Bakery • $
2440 Broadway, New York

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Gluten Free Brownie
Blueberry Muffin
Pumpkin Bundt
Coconut Cloud
Whoopie Pie
Red Velvet
Pecan Tart
Cupcake

“I wish they would ship items!!! This is the best dairy and gluten-free bakery I have found!!! I have a serve dairy allergy. Their food isn't dry at all very moist. The coconut cake and brownie cookies are the best!!!!Vegetarian options: Dairy and gluten freeDietary restrictions: I have a serve dairy allergy, and it was nice to get really good baked goods!!!“

4.7 Superb61 Reviews
Huascar & Co. Bakeshop Bakery • $
453 W 54th St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Mini-Cupcakes Dozen Box
Creme Brulee Cupcake
Confetti Cupcake
Custom Cakes
Cupcakes
Cookies

“Went and got a few different baked goods. Flan and Chocolate chip cookie was absolutely DELICIOUS, the flan was sweet and smooth and the chocolate chip was soft and not too sweet. Caramel apple cupcake was super cute and tasty. Haven't had the chocolate cupcake yet but it looks absolutely lovely. Only thing was the pistachio macaron was okay, might have just been a bad batch. Overall very tasty and glad I gave it a stop!“

4.7 Superb61 Reviews
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC Ice Cream Shop •
1610 Amsterdam Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie

“This is the top of the ice cream world in Hamilton Heights! Slow churned treats include several dairy and non dairy flavors (on a rotating basis), with just enough flavors to keep your taste buds wanting more. Never have we been disappointed. The staff are always friendly, and there is usually more than enough, even in the smallest sizes, to please your desires. If you have a big appetite (or a hungry partner), the cookie sandwich with freshly baked cookies and a massive helping of ice cream, is a favored order.“

4.6 Superb72 Reviews
Butterly Bakeshop Bakery • $
341 E 78th St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Brooklyn Blackout Cake
Birthday Cake

“Vegan baked goods??!! Let's give it a try. Dulce de leche - not too sweet at all, a good nutty flavor. Buttercream is not sweet and the cupcake itself is very moist Oreo - a bit dry on the outside, the buttercream has mashed up oreos in it, which doesn't make it creamy but with a crunchier texture. There isn't much of a chocolate taste. My least favorite Dark chocolate - the cupcake itself is on the dry side and less chocolate taste. The buttercream is smooth and a rich dark chocolate. Carrot cake - very moist and soft. You can see shaved pieces of carrots. I think it needs a pinch more of cinnamon. The cream cheese buttercream on top is on a sweeter side but really creamy. I didn't like the carrot decorations bc it's too much food coloring in it. Overall, I'm a fan of vegan cupcakes as it's not on the sweet side. There is a balanced ration of buttercream to cupcake. The chocolate cupcakes needs to be baked a bit less and need more chocolate taste.“

4.6 Superb56 Reviews
Bebe Bakes Bakery • $$
939 8th Ave, New York

“Bebe Bakes does it again! Beth Bennett is my go-to gal for custom cakes and cookies. She did not disappoint for the twins’ 17th birthday…a Shiba Inu in a red Formula One Ferrari! Vanilla cake with chocolate mousse filling! Gorgeous and delicious!“

4.9 Superb24 Reviews
Molly's Cupcakes Bakery • $
228 Bleecker St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Dozen Assorted Center-Filled Cupcakes
Our Classic Molly Cupcake
Peach Cobbler Cupcake
Creme Brulee Cupcake
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Decadence
Molly's Cupcakes
Salted Caramel
Ron Bennington
Vegan Cupcake

“It's my favorite cupcake shop. The cupcakes are very delicious. There are many flavors to choose from. If you are someone who doesn't like too sweet flavors. I think you will like this shop. I will recommend this shop to my friends. There aren't many seats in the shop. But the atmosphere in the shop is cute. The service staff is very good.“

4.4 Superb93 Reviews
Baked Cravings Bakery • $
1673 Lexington Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookies
Birthday Cake
Cupcake

“I have nut allergies and am so so happy to have Baked Cravings!! The grab and go cake was perfect!! I waited too long to place a custom order and needed something that day. I added the option of birthday candles and then bought some strawberries to decorate it a bit. The flavor was rich but not too sweet. I think I actually prefer the taste of the cake not being completely iced and decorated!! It was a big hit with the party too. $60 for the cake and was able to get about 16 slices/servings from it. I will definitely be making the trip up from Brooklyn again in the future :)Dietary restrictions: Perfect for nut allergies!!“

4.5 Superb45 Reviews
Red Gate Bakery Bakery • $
68 E 1st St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Pumpkin Olive Oil Cake
Midnight Banana Bread
Toasted Carrot Loaf
Cannibal Cookie
Malty Lime Bars
PB Miso Cookie
Cardamodoodle
Cookies
Oreos

“Red Gate Bakery is an experience that brings me back to loving life when it gets me down, when a hangover breaks me and/or when i want to experience heaven on earth. These unique concoctions are a once in a lifetime experience, unless you visit them weekly, which is recommended. While other bakeries get a lot of fame, these desserts are perfectly balanced so that you can eat them without feeling over-sugared. Go here. Be happy. You're welcome.“

4.4 Superb58 Reviews
Rebecca's cake pops Bakery • $$
115 Delancey St, New York

“Cutest cake pops around!!! Every time I see these cake pops I'm so wowed by them. Serious artistry. And to make it even better, they taste super good!!A little on the pricey side, but considering the details and the fact that it's a small business I say it's worth it. The staff is always very nice and happy to help. The cake pops themselves are in a cute little stall. It has other food halls around it so you can get a meal and have a delicious and cute cake pop for dessert!“

4.9 Superb11 Reviews
Bleu Neige Vegan Patisserie ~ONLINE ORDER ONLY~ Bakery • $$
2191 3rd Ave, New York

Customers` Favorites

Vegan Carrot Cake
Vegan Cake

“Love this place ! Wish I knew about this place sooner honestly. The communication is 10/10 and the cakes were sooooo good, so soft and moist ! I'm a vegan and been a vegan my whole life and my family is really used to buying cakes from the same places and the cakes are never fancy looking, no designs nothing really with character, also sometimes very dry or hard or just straight up bland ! But this place omg !! Great all around love how they have different designs for vegan cakes and not just 1 ! I feel so inclusive for once by having a nice looking cake for my birthday & the pricing wasn't bad at all !!! I got a vintage pink heart cake for my birthday on January 19th and my lil sisters birthday was on the 23rd so we also got her a cake but it was a Valentine's Day cake turned into a birthday cake ! And my family loved both cakes !! Thank you for making our birthdays extra special this year !Vegetarian options: The website has all the vegan options !“

4.4 Superb36 Reviews
Lady M Cake Boutique - NY Custom Cakes • $$
101 Liberty St Suite 1415, New York

Customers` Favorites

Signature Mille Crepes
Green Tea Crepe Cake
Strawberry
Pistachio

“Lady M Cake Boutique in NY nails it with their signature and pistachio crepe cakes. Their signature crepe cake is a classic – it's got this smooth, creamy taste that's just right. And the pistachio? It's a unique twist, with that nutty flavor really shining through in each delicate, perfectly thin layer. Every visit, I'm torn between these two because they're both that good. The way the flavors come alive in these cakes makes them absolutely unforgettable. Whether you're a first-timer or a regular, trying the signature or pistachio crepe cake at Lady M is a must when you're in New York. It's like a special treat you'll crave long after you've left!“

4.3 Superb54 Reviews
Lady M Cake Boutique - New York City Custom Cakes • $$
36 W 40th St, New York

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Swirl Mille Crêpes
lg Green Tea Mille Crepes
Chocolate Mille Crepes
Signature Mille Crepes
Pistachio Mille Crepes
Strawberry Shortcake
Pistachio Crepe Cake
Green Tea Crepe
Checkers Cake
Crepe Cakes

“If we could, we would try everything :) The cakes look attractive. We had green tea and tiramisu: light yet filling. The extremely thin pancakes that make up the layers fascinated me. The espresso was strong and sour, the way I like it - but it's not to everyone's taste :) Thank you!“

4.2 Good110 Reviews
Loading...
map Map