Home
NY
New York
Custom Cakes

Custom Cakes in New York, NY

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Custom Cakes in New York.

Showing 38 of 38 restaurants

Bakery · $
1 Les Gateaux de Marie

4.8 Superb 224 Reviews

1582 1st Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Chocolate & Vanilla Cupcakes
- Pistachio Raspberry Cake Slice
- Chocolate & Vanilla Cupcakes
- Mango Passion Fruit Mousse
“Marie is the absolute best. I asked her to make a cake for my birthday and my guests and myself have been talking about it ever since! I called Marie to tell her my vision and she helped me through it and made it even better, she's so kind and so open to collaborating. And not only that the flavor was INSANELY DELICIOUS. I am normally not a big cake person but it was the perfect balance of moist and creamy, the way I told her how I wanted it to be. I asked for vanilla frosting with chocolate inside, and a layer of praline cream. Highly recommend ordering from Marie for any occasion. I definitely will be doing that again soon.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
2 Baked Cravings

4.8 Superb 389 Reviews

1673 Lexington Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cheddar Caramel Popcorn 84oz Container
- S'Mores Cookies in a Bakers Bag
- Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Vegan Cinna Crave Cupcake
“Great cupcakes and excellent service!”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
3 Avrilililly's Creamery LLC

4.9 Superb 221 Reviews

1610 Amsterdam Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
- Cookies & Cream Vegan Ice Cream
- Olive Oil and Basil Gelato
- Lemonade Raspberry Sorbet
“I'm here every weekend for the tres leches, tiramisu and chocolate cake! owner of the shop is such a friendly guy, really made both my wife and i want to come back and support a local business like his. great vibes during the world cup, great conversation while ordering, and just a beautiful space. wishing you all of the success bro!”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $$$$
4 Soma Cakes NYC

4.7 Superb 52 Reviews

167 Loisaida Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Birthday Cake
“Amazing customer service, amazing cakes..so happy that we found you.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
5 Huascar & Co. Bakeshop

4.6 Superb 209 Reviews

453 West 54th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Salted Caramel Banana Pudding
- Strawberry Cheesecake Cupcake
- Jumbo Chocolate Chunk Cookie
- Mini-Cupcakes Dozen Box
“I was a bride from a distance and used this bakery for my wedding day, and I’m so glad I did! Their cupcakes were absolutely decadent—so delicious you truly couldn’t stop eating them. The frosting was light and not overly heavy, and the cake itself was hands-down the best. Everything tasted fresh, rich, and perfectly made. I would recommend them to anyone looking for wedding desserts or cupcakes that wow your guests!”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $
6 From Lucie

4.4 Superb 169 Reviews

263 East 10th Street, New York
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Chocolate Chunk Cookie with Sea Salt
- Layered Sponge Cake with Buttercream
- Chocolate Chip Sea Salt Cookie
- Fantastic Carrot Cake
“Beautiful display - but the cake does not taste anything special. Olive oil cake was unique in the sense that you won’t find it in most other bakeries. Also very pricey - I believe the signature cake was $18. Chocolate chip cookie was pretty good though! The chocolate chips were unevenly distributed however”
Menu
Ice Cream Shop · $
7 Carvel

4.7 Superb 341 Reviews

165 West 48th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- The Original Soft Serve Pint & Quart
- Ice Cream Pint - Soft Serve Ice Cream
- Toppings Ice Cream & Sorbet Regular
- Cookie Butter Soft Serve Ice Cream
“tried their pistachio soft serve ice cream. Not overly sweet. They have regular ice cream and other types of soft serve. Lots of toppings to choose from. There are ice cream cakes for sale too. server was friendly mostly a takeout place with a couple of benches to sit outside”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $$$$
8 Creative Cakes

4.9 Superb 13 Reviews

400 East 74th Street, New York
- Delivery
“This review is a long time coming. Bill, made one of the best cakes I've ever seen for the US Open. Such a pleasure to work with and his creation was amazing! Would definitely use his services again.”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $$
9 Cake Designs by Jaclyn, LLC

5.0 Superb 6 Reviews

850 Amsterdam Avenue, New York
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Birthday Cake
“OMG! I am not exaggerating when I say the cake I received was not short of amazing. Chocolate Devil's Food with Raspberry buttercream. Tangy Raspberry preserves made from scratch by Jaclyn as well between the layers. Everyone who ate a piece of my birthday cake could not be more satisfied with the level of artistry in the decoration as well as the execution of the taste of the cake itself. I don't think I can go back to buying store bought cakes. They would just fail in comparison!”
Menu
Bakery · $
10 Red Gate Bakery

4.2 Good 216 Reviews

68 East 1st Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Salted Caramel Brownie
- Pumpkin Olive Oil Cake
- Brown Butter Blondies
- Midnight Banana Bread
“Red Gate Bakery is an experience that brings me back to loving life when it gets me down, when a hangover breaks me and/or when i want to experience heaven on earth. These unique concoctions are a once in a lifetime experience, unless you visit them weekly, which is recommended. While other bakeries get a lot of fame, these desserts are perfectly balanced so that you can eat them without feeling over-sugared. Go here. Be happy. You're welcome.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
11 By the Way Bakery

4.6 Superb 227 Reviews

2440 Broadway, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Chocolate Chip Cookie
- Gluten Free Brownie
- Donut Cream Puff
- Blueberry Muffin
“I ordered a cake as someone not on a GF, dairy free or kosher diet. The cake tasted amazing. And the staff were able to make my cake kosher wrapped in short notice. On top of kind staff the $80 cake to serve 18-24 people is fantastic value for money in NYC. I will definitely order here again. Strawberry shortcake pictured below”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
12 NY Bakery and Desserts Times Square

4.5 Superb 348 Reviews

1580 Broadway, New York
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- New Birthday Cake in a Glass Jar with Handmade Buttercream
- X-Large Strawberry Shortcake Slice with Whip Cream
- Fresh Handmade Strawberry Filled Croissant
- Fresh Special Whole 10 Red Velvet Cake
“These desserts were scrumptious!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
13 Molly's Cupcakes

4.5 Superb 424 Reviews

228 Bleecker Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Dozen Assorted Center-Filled Cupcakes
- Cupcake de Blueberry E de Chocolate
- Our Classic Molly Cupcake
- Crème Brûlée Cupcake
“looove her cupcakes so full of flavor and moist our new spot for cupcakes I highly recommend Molly's Cupcake”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
14 Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC

4.9 Superb 66 Reviews

2289 5th Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- The Ultimate Butter Pecan Pound Cake
- The Ultimate Honey Bun Pound Cake
- The Ultimate Classic Yellow Cake
- Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cake
“Besides the beautiful presentation, these cakes taste amazing!! They are moist, fluffy and the perfect amount of sweetness. I ordered the yellow cake, triple chocolate and the strawberry swirl and I am in love!! I really appreciate that Gardner's Gourtment clearly makes completely homemade cakes and luscious frosting.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$
15 Bebe Bakes

4.8 Superb 57 Reviews

939 8th Avenue, New York
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Birthday Cake
- Wedding Cake
- Knight Cakes
- Cupcake
“Everything offered is delicious and beautiful”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
16 L.A Sweets

4.3 Superb 196 Reviews

219 West 125th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Frosting
- Red Velvet Slice Cake
- Turtle Cinnamon Roll
- Red Velvet Cup Cake
“My absolute favorite yellow cake 🎂 with chocolate 🍫 frosting taste homemade and made with love. Definitely, will be ordering from LaSweetsNY for my next celebration. Support small business and I enjoy buying Black. (A+). Met the owner yesterday. Though the store hours have changed to opening at 11am, she permitted to make my purchase. Ms. L, was welcoming, sincere and a precious soul. Thank you Ms. L. Verrie”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
17 Butterly Bakeshop

4.6 Superb 87 Reviews

341 East 78th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Brooklyn Blackout Cake
- Printed Birthday Cake
- Lemon Blueberry Cake
- Apple Pie Cheesecake
“Have been meaning to try this place out and it was great. Tried four different cupcakes, mini carrot loaf and two cookies. My family loved it all. So pretty too. Can’t wait to go back.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
18 NY Bakery and Desserts Midtown

4.4 Superb 532 Reviews

512 7th Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Fresh Organic 100 Belgian Chocolate Covered Strawberries
- Special Heart Shaped Chocolate Mousse Cake with Love You
- Organic Belgian Chocolate Covered Strawberries
- Fresh Handmade Peanut Butter Chocolate Cupcake
“These desserts were scrumptious!”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $
19 Bake Culture

4.2 Good 148 Reviews

48 Bowery, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- ham egg sandwich 火腿芝士三文治
- chicken sandwich 鸡柳三明治
- Strawberry Cream Cake 6
- taro toast 香芋吐司
“Great place for filled rolls at breakfast. Super, friendly, helpful staff who can make a great cup of tea.”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $
20 Lady M Cake Boutique - Bryant Park

4.3 Superb 386 Reviews

36 West 40th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Assorted Cakes and Pastries Display
- Strawberry Swirl Mille Crêpes
- Dubai Chocolate Mille Crêpes
- lg Green Tea Mille Crepes
“Always the best Mille crepe ❤️❤️❤️”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
21 Rebecca's cake pops

4.4 Superb 40 Reviews

115 Delancey Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“Siiii!!! Me encanta lo que hacen!! Sigan asi!! Saludos desde ARGENTINA!! 😃😃”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
22 Lady M Cake Boutique - Upper East Side

3.9 Good 282 Reviews

41 East 78th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Black Forest Cake Green Tea Crepe Cake
- MD Green Tea Mille Crepes
- lg Green Tea Mille Crepes
- Popcorn Mille Crepe Cake
“Adult bakery. Snooty atmosphere. Staff nicer in recent years”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$
23 Aromas Boutique Bakery

5.0 Superb 5 Reviews

By Appointment, 8 West 126th Street, New York
- Delivery
“Amazing, Always Ready for Anything and Delicious Cakes!”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
24 Ben & Jerry’s

4.3 Superb 169 Reviews

2722 Broadway, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Coffee Coffee Buzzbuzzbuzz
- Cookie Cookie Sundae
- Waffle Cone Sundae
- Brownie Sundae
“I had my first experience in Ben and Jerry’s at 102 st, the staff were very friendly and helpful, recommended lots of flavors and gave me to taste ,it was amazing ♥️♥️♥️ definitely coming back to this place. Highly recommended.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$$
25 Bleu Neige Vegan Patisserie ~ONLINE PRE-ORDERS ONLY~

4.2 Good 48 Reviews

2191 3rd Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Vegan Pistachio Lemon Cake
- Vegan Carrot Cake
- Birthday Cake
- Vegan Cake
“I had a wonderful experience with Bleu Neige Vegan Patisserie! I ordered a custom Kingdom Hearts cake for my wife’s birthday, and it came out exactly how I requested. The attention to detail was amazing, and most importantly, the cake was absolutely delicious! Communication throughout the whole process via WhatsApp was excellent. She was friendly, responsive, and made everything so easy from start to finish. My wife loved the cake, and it made her birthday even more special. I would definitely recommend Bleu Neige to anyone looking for a beautiful and delicious custom cake. Thank you so much! 🎂❤”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $$
26 Lady M Cake Boutique - NoMad

4.2 Good 269 Reviews

1178 Broadway, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Passion Fruit Mille Crepes - Slice
- Tiramisu & Green Tea
- lg Pistachio Mille Crpes
- Signature Mille Crepes
“Absolutely phenomenal! The signature mille crepes are great, as well as the tiramisu! However, if you’re reading this, GET THE CHEESECAKE! I just so happened to try it on a whim when I saw it as an option and I’m beyond glad that I did! So decadent and rich, but also has this way of melting in your mouth. Hands down some of the best cheesecake I’ve ever had in the city. Highly recommend this place and will absolutely be back!”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $
27 Baskin-Robbins

3.6 Good 13 Reviews

542 East 14th Street, New York
- Delivery
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $
28 Carvel Express

4.0 Good 63 Reviews

112 John Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cake
“I recently went to this Subway and Carvel and had a great time. The staff were super friendly, and the sandwiches were fresh and tasty. The Carvel side had delicious ice cream and awesome customized cakes. The place was clean and inviting after the remodeling.”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $
29 Lady M Cake Boutique - World Trade Center

3.9 Good 144 Reviews

101 Liberty Street Ste 1415, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Signature Mille Crepes
- Green Tea Crepe Cake
- Banana Mille Feuille
- Strawberry
“It was a bit hard to find at first since it’s located in the Oculus. I placed the order online and the pickup was pretty smooth. The passion fruit crepe cake was tasty. It’s a bit strong in the passion fruit taste but if you like passion fruit it should be fine. It had an interesting sweet and tart taste. It was $70 for a 6”.”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
30 Ben & Jerry’s

3.9 Good 179 Reviews

30 Rockefeller Center Concourse Level, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- New York Super Fudge Chunk
- Chocolate Fudge Brownie
- Brownie Special Sundae
- Strawberry Cheesecake
“OMG What can I say, for someone who loves ice cream I felt I had died and gone to heaven.”
Menu Order
Custom Cakes · $
31 The Original Cake Man Raven

3.4 Good 128 Reviews

201 West 135th Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Red Velvet Cake Slice
- Cupcake Tower
- Coconut Cake
- Wedding Cake
“This is by far the best cake that I have had in New York City since moving here a decade ago and I’ve had them all….trust me. The flavors are real and authentic and not played up like most of the bakeries in New York.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
32 5 Estrellas Bakery Corporation

3.9 Good 171 Reviews

3861 Broadway, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cafe Con Leche Pastelitos and Pastry
- Dulce De Leche Cheesecake
- Birthday Party Cake
- Tres Leches Cake
“I had been craving a Cuban sandwich and a fresh-squeezed orange juice for a while. After finishing my overnight shift, I decided to take a walk and stop by this bakery for breakfast. The place was clean, reasonably priced, and had a small seating area. Instead of heading straight home, I decided to sit and enjoy my breakfast there. The Cuban sandwich and fresh orange juice hit the spot! My only advice is to be patient, as the place can get busy. However, the ladies behind the counter are friendly, efficient, and keep the line moving quickly. Even during the rush, you’ll be in and out before you know it. Highly recommend! 😊🍊🥪”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
33 Lady M Cake Boutique - Rockefeller

3.8 Good 136 Reviews

30 Rockefeller Plaza Ste U, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Earl Grey Mille Crepes Regular Price
- Chocolate Crêpe Biscuits Bon Bon
- Sesame Ti Kuan Yin Mille Crêpes
- Jasmine Calamansi Mille Crêpes
“Loved the crepe cake!!! Amazing!!”
Menu Order
Ice Cream Shop · $$
34 Cold Stone Creamery

3.7 Good 191 Reviews

350 West 42nd Street, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip
- Gelato
“Delicious ice cream and milkshakes, with a wide variety of options, there isn’t really sitting area and even at 8pm it can have a long line. I ordered a small dubai chocolate cone and a oreo and dark chocolate ice cream with fudge mixed in milkshake, I used the app and got buy one get one free on the cone”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$$$
35 Betel Party Supply

3.6 Good 124 Reviews

74 Sherman Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Bizcocho De Cocol Coconut Cake
- Tiktok Birthday Cake
- Bochenta Plain Cake
- Chocolate Cupcakes
“Although the presentation only looks good from one angle (bald spot in the back etc. SMH) the cake taste delicious not too sweet just right the blue frosting had everyone’s lips blue tho it didn’t taste like dye the guava filling was on point we truly enjoyed it. The total for the cake was $80 and it was ready on the date and time I requested. Would recommend just don’t get any pictures on your cake they need to get their skills up. The passion fruit dessert is a go as well.”
Menu
Bakery · $
36 D’Maritza's Cake

3.4 Good 96 Reviews

2153 Amsterdam Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- 8'' Dominican Cake
- Maritza's Cake
- Birthday Cake
- Wedding Cake
“I haven’t visited this bakery since 2011 was told its ran by new people. only went there before for the 3 leches cake. Passed by today for one got home ate a lil and was mind blown 🤯 I’m surprised to see bad reviews 😵‍💫 once I googled to leave review. Barely do this. Lady was really welcoming and nice. Thank you.”
Menu Order
Bakery · $
37 William Greenberg Desserts

3.4 Good 243 Reviews

1100 Madison Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Large Black and White Cookie
- Black & White Cookie
- Brownies and Blondies
- Black & White Cookie
“BEST black and whites anywhere!”
Menu Order
Bakery · $$
38 Angela's Cake

3.1 Average 192 Reviews

2220 Amsterdam Avenue, New York
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Dominican Cake with Caramel Filling
- Bizcocho Dominicano De Caramelo
- Guava Dominican Cake
- Pineapple Filling
“es una d las Bakerys q más se aproxima a la calidad d cakes,d mi amada patria Honduras”
Menu Order

Custom Cakes Nearby