Custom Cakes in Brooklyn, NY

ByClio Bakery Bakery • $
400 3rd Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Pumpkin Hojicha Cake with Kinako
Cheddar Jalapeño Biscuit
Cookies Cake and Other
Slice of Carrot Cake
Thai Tea Passion
Matcha Rose
Brownies

“Can a slice of cake be life changing? I'm literally in the middle of eating a slice of their strawberry sumac cake and I'm definitely feeling that way. It's so dense and moist but still also fluffy and refreshing? The flavor is deep and complex but still accessible and it has a rich level of sweetness without being cloying. It's a slice of cake that can't be consumed mindlessly - it stops you in your tracks when you take a bite because it's THAT good. I'm being long-winded but as someone who has eaten more cake than advisable in their lifetime, I am grateful to have ByClio in my neighborhood as a place that not only delights but excites with every new flavor offered. Also they have excellent coffee!“

4.9 Superb88 Reviews
Ten Cake Studio Patisserie/Cake Shop •
8617 3rd Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

cappuccino hot medium 卡布奇诺 热 中杯
oreo cream cake 奥利奥奶油蛋糕
matcha tiramisu 抹茶提拉米苏
Strawberry Shortcake
Birthday Cake
Lemon Macaron

“I used them for my son’s first party and the cakes they provided were beautiful and tasted delicious. I got so many compliments! The funfetti flavor was everyone’s favorite! They were more than willing to work with my price range and delivered a product that exceeded our expectations.“

4.9 Superb50 Reviews
EATGOODNYC presents Saint Michel: Cafe and Bakery Bakery • $
462 Irving Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“A cute and cozy cafe that makes the best croissants and matcha lates.This place is beautifully decorated, great customer service and their cookies and cupcakes are pieces of art.The building address is on Irving Ave but the entrance is by Jefferson Ave. ?I highly recomend it!P.S.: I would like to see a bigger sign that stand up and make the business a little more visible for public. ?“

5 Superb36 Reviews
Moco Choco Bakery •
7711 15th Ave, Brooklyn

“I love Moco Choco! They make the best cakes in Brooklyn. My wife got me a cake from Moco Choco with a photo of me on it a couple years ago and we have since ordered custom cookies and chocolates for gifts. I would definitely recommend them!“

5 Superb22 Reviews

5
Baked

Baked Bakery • $
359 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Cheddar and Chive Scone
Red Velvet Cupcake
Coffee Cake
Bakery

“Our wedding guests continue to tell us how great our desserts were—even many months later! So we had to make sure to send our thanks to Baked!We had a cutting cake with two different flavors: Oopsy Daisy on the top, Sweet and Salty on the bottom. Then we sent out platters of cupcakes to our tables of those flavors, plus a mix of others. Additionally, we were able to serve some gluten-free and vegan options for guests with dietary restrictions. Annemarie really helped us work through all the details beforehand, and everything turned out perfect on the day of. Again, we cannot thank them enough!Expect us to come back often, and especially on our anniversary, to pick up some treats!“

4.7 Superb39 Reviews
L'esti's Desserts Bakery •
180 27th St, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“As an essential centerpiece of any wedding reception, the wedding cake from L'esti's Desserts exceeded all expectations. From its elegant design to its delightful taste, every aspect of this confectionary masterpiece was simply exquisite.“

5 Superb28 Reviews
JM Cake Boutique Custom Cakes
7211 18th Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Mango Pomelo Sago
Custom Cake
Cupcake

“First and foremost I want to thank this bakery for getting my order in last minute. I order a unicorn cake 3 DAYS before the event, and they did an amazing job! Great customer service the moment I came in to pick up the cake. On the side my sibling and I got a brown bear chocolate cake which we loved, we also got mix fruit mango sago which was refreshing and tasty. The seating area is very clean and cute. Thank you so much JM Cake boutique, I will definitely be coming back for future orders !!!“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Blueberry Bakery •
1849 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn

“The 4 by 12 tacos have really disappointed me. Why do they put oil in it? That was very unpleasant in the mouth. Please don't do it, the meats already have fat and they add more, I don't like hearing people say that all Mexican food is greasy that's why we're fat, stop putting oil on everything, ask instead please.The breads are very delicious, the service is super courteous and the prices vary, some are worth it but others are exaggerated.“

4.8 Superb35 Reviews
byPensa Dessert •
214 Humboldt St, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“Nikki's cakes, cookies, decor everything is all so amazing. We got our wedding cake from her in addition to various celebration cakes past couple of years and could not recommend her enough. Her flavors are so unique and tasty - everyone complimented us on our cake at the wedding!“

5 Superb17 Reviews
Luckybird Bakery Bakery • $$
163 Montrose Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Rose Cake
Wedding Cake
Bakery

“It has been four weeks since our wedding and my mom is STILL talking about the cake. She stole three extra slices from the venue and had cake for breakfast three days in a row. I think she’ll be talking about this cake for the rest of my life. She might drive me crazy but…she’s right. The cake Luckybird made for our wedding was the best cake I’ve ever had. That’s not an exaggeration. It really was next level. We ordered a fully frosted chocolate cake with seasonal berries and crème fraiche, and it was simply divine. Sweet but not too sweet, decadent but still light, and totally addicting. I cannot tell you how many people have reached out to me specifically to compliment the cake!Besides her incredible skills as a baker, Amy is also a lovely person to work with. Throughout the entire process, she was friendly, communicative, and kind. She was quick to answer my questions and super professional. If we ever throw another special event and need a cake, I will 100% reach out to Luckybird! In fact, I’m really trying to find a reason to order a second wedding cake, just for myself  THANK YOU SO MUCH!!“

4.6 Superb23 Reviews
DoughGirl Cupcakes Bakery • $
Kings Plz, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Butter Pecan and Salted Caramel Cupcakes
Triple Chocolate Cupcake
Classic Vanilla Cupcake
Carrot Cupcake
Banana Pudding
Carrot Cake

“Oh my goodness!!! I won’t say I’m a cake snob (some might say that, but I won’t)…I just hate blah cakes. The strawberry shortcake that I had for my birthday was ev-a-ree-thang!!! Gotta tell you I was beyond hesitant to spend that much money on a cake, but I figured, “What the heck? It’s once a year and I’m more than worth it.” I’m so glad I did (actually, my mother did as a gift to me). Every crumb was worth every penny!!! The cake was.moist, fresh and flavorful!! Every strawberry was fresh and flavorful as well. Tanika delivered on the day and time as promised. It was a completely wonderful experience!!! Thank you, Tanika (and Anthony for helping my mom home with the cake) for lending to the “happy” in my very happy birthday!!“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
Everybody Eats Bakery • $$
294 3rd Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Sticky Buns
Gluten Free Cookie
Crusty Baguette
Banana Bread
Cupcakes

“Visited this bakery in 2022 so sorry for delay in the review. Incredibly good gluten free baked goods. Don't let the outside confuse you - my wife and I thought it was perhaps closed down at first! But have confidence and you will earn your baked reward - and what a reward! We chose the cinnamon buns which were perfection. I should note that this bakery is more of a "buy a loaf of bread or a tray of cakes and take them home" rather than a "grab a singular bun and eat it there and then" place (although the baker kindly prepared a couple of buns from our tray of buns for us to enjoy right away). Overall score: The bakery - 5/5; The baker - 6/5!“

4.8 Superb24 Reviews
Kaffeine 231 - cafe on Brighton Beach Cafe • $
231 Brighton Beach Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Плов По-узбекски
Cappuccino & Chocolate Cake
Pilaf Uzbek Style
Pumpkin Dumplings
Bakery
Plov

“My opinion is 9.3/10. This is a plov, my first one. Wow was it good the meat was soooo tender. The flavors mixed together so well. Only downside is the rice could be left out making it a little chewy but the meat reintroduced moisture into the rice and was sooooo worth it. Check out my in depth video reviews on any of the platforms below. TikTok: TheUrbanLegend4 Instagram: UrbanLegend4 Facebook: Panayoti Kokalis YouTube: Urban Legend“

4.3 Superb47 Reviews
La Gran Via Bakery Bakery • $
4516 5th Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Tres Leche Cake with Pineapple and Strawberry Filling
Birthday Cake Dominican Style Vanilla Custard
Chocolate Dreams Tres Leches
Pastelillo Guava Y Queso
Halloween Birthday Cake
Caramel Tres Leche Cake
Game of Thrones Cake
Gender Reveal Cake
Flan Cheesecake
Cuban Sandwich

“EVERYTHING……they are very professional and an expert in their field of work. I’ve been going to LGVB for years and they have NEVER disappointed me or my family. Anything you want they got it and make sure your vision is reflected thru whatever product you purchase. Betsy and Roy are the best along with their entire staff.“

4.4 Superb104 Reviews
Cuccio's Bakery Bakery • $$
320 Avenue X, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Marble Cheesecake
Cookies with Cherry
Plane Cheesecake
Oreo Cheesecake
Chocolate Cake
Cream Doughnut
Brownie
Buns

“5 stars hands down just for service. Delicious cake was simply a Bonus.The lovely lady that helped me while the owner was out Monday went out of her way to find a replacement cake as they sold out of my first choice. To top it off she included a bonus bag I found at home with several free donuts. Very pleasant experience.“

4.4 Superb60 Reviews
Bread Plus Bakery • $
2841 Harway Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Raspberry Danish
Birthday Cake
Cookies
Cannoli
Donuts

“What a wonderful bakery, best in Brooklyn by far. When you walk in it’s like being swept away to Italy. The owners are nice as well (the youngest son is BY FAR the best looking one too, it’s not even close). If I stop in Brooklyn I always stop here for a cookie tray, you can’t find this quality anymore.“

4.4 Superb54 Reviews
Ladybird Bakery Bakery • $$
1112 8th Ave, Brooklyn

Customers` Favorites

Carrot Bar and Chocolate Cupcake
Blackout Chocolate Mousse Cake 4
Brooklyn Blackout Cake
Cake with Chocolate
Red Velvet Cake
Blueberry Scone
Chocolate Cake
Birthday Cake
Various Tarts
Carrot Cake

“The Brooklyn Blackout cupcake was to die for!! It was soo rich, gooey, moist, chocolatey and fudgey. I was looking through the display and deciding what I wanted and another customer said "Their Brooklyn Blackout cupcake is literally the best" and boy was she right. Every bite felt like a heavenly delight! I saved some for the next day and it was still so moist. How do they get their desserts to be so moist?!“

4.3 Superb88 Reviews
Izzy’s Sweets Boutique Homemade Desserts & Treats Bakery •
1460 Granville Payne Ave, Brooklyn

“I ordered blue velvet cupcakes for my birthday a few days ago for my birthday. I mentioned that I wanted a Street Fighter theme and she did not disappoint at all. She had them spot on they were absolutely amazing. I’d recommend them to anyone who want anime/ pop culture references on your cakes/desserts. She hit a home run with these.“

4.6 Superb11 Reviews
Loading...
map Map