Custom Cakes in Brooklyn, NY

1 ByClio Bakery

4.9 Superb 322 Reviews

400 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Ordered a custom birthday cake and it is so divine! Beautiful, delicious, and even yummy for breakfast the next day. Would absolutely order again, looking forward to stopping by the bakery in real life, but I highly recommend Clio for any custom cake needs! Impeccable detail and custom options. The whipped cream frosting is so delicious! Couldn’t have asked for a better cake or experience. Thank you!”

2 Baked

4.5 Superb 201 Reviews

359 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Quality products and great customer service!”

3 Saint Michel: Cafe and Art

4.9 Superb 148 Reviews

462 Irving Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I’ve only ever had the strawberry matcha here, as I can never get my hands on any food items because they always sell out. I rock with them heavy though and I love what they stand for. It’s that type of place where you’re happy and excited to give them your money, y’know? I hope they continue to flourish 🌹”

4 JM Cake Boutique

4.7 Superb 63 Reviews

7211 18th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The most creative, beautiful and delicious cakes EVER! You will not be disappointed - I promise! Since discovering JM, I will drive 2 1/2 hours to get a cake for special occasions..I’ve been doing this for 4 years and never disappointed Gorgeous cake designs and exotic fillings - truly appreciated by everyone. Whenever I bring 1 or even 3 cakes (each with a different theme) - the crowd is in awe and the recipients never want to cut it because the cakes are honestly that beautiful and everyone is in awe. Crystal is an absolute gem and sooooo helpful with every order. I simply love her (happy birthday again Crystal) HIGHLY RECOMMEND!”

5 Luckybird Cakes

4.8 Superb 80 Reviews

163 Montrose Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had a 10/10 experience getting our cake from here. The communication was excellent and efficient, and our cake turned out exactly how we explained to Amy! Thank you Amy for creating and delivering our cake for us, everyone was amazed at how delicious and cute it was. We will certainly come back for future events!”

6 Everybody Eats

4.8 Superb 88 Reviews

294 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Pedro was incredible to work with! The cake was absolutely beautiful and tasted even better than it looked. A week later, we're all still talking about how delicious it was. If you're looking for gluten-free desserts, I can't recommend them highly enough. They made the entire experience so easy, and the final product exceeded our expectations!”

7 Duet Bakery and Restaurant

4.3 Superb 283 Reviews

6181-6183 Strickland Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The Pyramid ! I must say, our anniversary celebration was nothing short of spectacular! The concept, presentation, and flavors were all outstanding, and the luxurious products added a lovely touch. Thank you for making this day so special!🥂🥰”

8 Ladybird Bakery

4.3 Superb 281 Reviews

252 Prospect Park West, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Could this cake be any more beautiful? Ladybird has been my go-to for every birthday and occasion for so many years that I’ve lost count. Their cakes are moist and tender, delicious and flavorful. Really no other bakery in the neighborhood compares.”

9 Sugar Butter Chocolate

4.9 Superb 49 Reviews

1413 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We stopped in here for the first time this past weekend and met Daniel, one of the owners. He was so nice and gave us a full run down of the stores goods and was just one of the friendliest people we ever met. Right before closing, we weren’t expecting life changing desserts or anything, but the chocolate chip cookies were insane. We got the last two of the day, and they still had the perfect chewy, melty texture. I’m already craving more! We also tried their coffee which was delicious, especially because they make their own syrups. Daniel also gave us other local recs. Truly recommend trying this place out!”

10 Blueberry Mexican Grill and Bakery

4.7 Superb 81 Reviews

1849 Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Esta muy rico la comida quesadillas de birria 🙈🙈🙈delicioso”

11 Bread Plus

4.5 Superb 242 Reviews

2841 Harway Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing place, bread is awesome, cakes are great and the service is always top notch. Vinny is a true angel, he made an awesome cake for my son and they even helped me out to the car with it. I highly recommend this place.”

12 Ten Cake Studio

4.6 Superb 100 Reviews

8617 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Overdue review but I ordered 500 macarons from Ten Cake Studio for our wedding favors and it was totally last minute, and they absolutely were able to come through! I loved them, the guests love them and even asked where I got them from. Went with them for the unique Asian flavors and they did not disappoint. They even tossed in some extras which was a plus! 10/10, will def be back!”

13 Moco Choco

4.8 Superb 28 Reviews

7711 15th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“good very Delicious love it”

14 Butterly Bakeshop

4.5 Superb 142 Reviews

263 Prospect Park West, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Have been meaning to try this place out and it was great. Tried four different cupcakes, mini carrot loaf and two cookies. My family loved it all. So pretty too. Can’t wait to go back.”

15 Doughgirl Cupcakes - Bedstuy

4.6 Superb 97 Reviews

316 Stuyvesant Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“Lovely staff Beautiful and tasty cupcakes oh and can’t forget the banana pudding”

16 L'esti's Desserts

4.5 Superb 108 Reviews

180 27th Street, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“Pinhas from Lestis was the best. He took personally my order on the phone, directed me, gave advice on my choices. He worked with me and cooperated in a way that I felt confident. I ordered many mini pastries. Some were customized, Lestis did a wonderful job! They were tasty and definitely wow factor at my daughter’s engagement party. Thank you!”

17 La Gran Via Bakery

4.4 Superb 234 Reviews

4516 5th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“EVERYTHING……they are very professional and an expert in their field of work. I’ve been going to LGVB for years and they have NEVER disappointed me or my family. Anything you want they got it and make sure your vision is reflected thru whatever product you purchase. Betsy and Roy are the best along with their entire staff.”

18 Cuccio's Bakery

4.4 Superb 225 Reviews

320 Avenue X, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I ordered my wedding cake from this lovely place. It was a delicious experience to say the least. The staff is friendly and the pastry wizard is just that. I gave her a picture that I wish I could up load and not only did she replicate the exact design but the cake itself literally melted on our mouths. It was so light and fluffy my "husband" couldn't wait a year to eat the top. If you live anywhere in Brooklyn and have need of a baker this place is worth the drive. Trust you won't be disappointed💃🏿”

19 Dolce Italian Bakery

4.8 Superb 28 Reviews

680 5th Avenue, Brooklyn

“Their cannolis are delicious, their Italian rainbow cookies are delicious and so are their raspberry thumbprints! I’m so glad I stumbled upon this local bakery. The girl working behind the counter was the sweetest and took the time to explain all different cookies they had. Next time I’m buying way more! 😋”

20 Carvel

4.4 Superb 118 Reviews

4702 Avenue North, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“As a dog mom, I normally avoid taking my dog inside restaurants or places serving food out of respect for others. Usually, I leave him by the door or quickly put my head inside to place my order. What happened here completely changed my experience. Your staff immediately came to the front, welcomed both of us with kindness, and explained that everything was covered and that my dog was absolutely welcome inside. The amount of love and warmth they showed him honestly meant more than I can explain. In a world where small acts of kindness can make such a big difference, this was one of those moments I’ll always remember. Thank you for making me feel welcomed, comfortable, and appreciated. Because of how your staff treated us, this has officially become my go-to ice cream shop. The ice cream was great, but the kindness is what will keep me coming back ❤”

21 Isabella's Creations

4.7 Superb 26 Reviews

6602 13th Avenue, Lower Level, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“Her cakes are 😀 the best cakes we ever had”

22 Ice Cream House Borough Park

4.3 Superb 315 Reviews

2 Church Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“todo muy rico. las pastas . Los helados .todo”

23 Izzy’s Sweets Boutique Homemade Desserts & Treats

4.7 Superb 14 Reviews

1460 Granville Payne Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Looking for some good desserts in the Brooklyn area of New York City this is the right place to check out”

24 Carvel Ice Cream

4.3 Superb 108 Reviews

7111 18th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Love the Staff here. Courteous funny and young. COOLBEANS”

25 Delicacy Passion Patisserie

4.3 Superb 73 Reviews

2379 86th Street, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My boyfriend bought me a cake from here and I loved it. Cake is not too sweet and has a sponge-like texture that is not dry. I can’t wait to purchase more cakes from here ❤️”

26 Pastry World Bakery

4.4 Superb 26 Reviews

2872 Coney Island Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“I ordered cakes from Pastry world bakery several times and they never disappointed. Recently i had ordered the cake for my son’s first birthday, and everyone, including myself, loved this beautiful and delicious cake. Will order again for sure. Thank you”

27 Custom cakes and cookies - Everything Cakes

4.5 Superb 8 Reviews

7002 Ridge Boulevard, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love sweets and can tell good cake from an OK cake. Any time I want to be treated with something special I ask for a dessert from Everything Cakes and I never get disappointed. Be it honey cake, red velvet or anything in between, every little detail will be implemented with the highest quality of both presentation and taste. Be warned however, you will be asked to be specific with respect to what it is that you (your taste buds) want. To the chef your total and complete gratification (within the culinary boundaries) is a matter of personal pride.”

28 A Cake Baked In Brooklyn

5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

630 Flushing Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“What an incredible experience! They made our wedding cake this past March and it was DELICIOUS. Not only that the real flowers and detail on the cake was absolutely beautiful! Can’t wait to order from them again! Thank you!!!! ♥️”

29 Davey's Ice Cream

4.2 Good 187 Reviews

74 Meserole Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“A great addition to the “Burg” & David, remember my name Irwin Friedman & Son Inc. For all your plumbing needs, I’m located around the corner from you on Banker St. Been serving the area for 100 years! We are Williamsburg’s #1 Grateful Plumbers (718) 782-7150”

30 SHLOIMY'S BAKERY

4.2 Good 100 Reviews

430 Avenue P, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I highly recommend this bakery! I’ve purchased their ready-made desserts before, and they were absolutely delicious. Recently, I ordered two cakes, and they were kosher, beautifully made, and, most importantly, delicious! Thank you so much! Everyone loved them! ❤”

31 BKLYN Cake

4.2 Good 67 Reviews

427 7th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“OMG The cupcakes are to die for. The frosting is amazing as it is not too sweet. The cupcakes are a perfect size, moist and have the delicious fresh homemade taste. I had the vegan chocolate cupcake and it had a delicious chocolate taste and was not that sweet at all. My daughter said it was the best cupcake she had. It was worth every penny and I can not recommend BKLYN Cake Studio enough for its delicious cupcakes. I definitely want to try the chocolate chip cookies with sea salt next.”

32 Carvel

4.1 Good 48 Reviews

5803 5th Ave, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Bro they have so many deals everyday. The best part is that they honor it, along with some bombass ice cream. Staff are nice and fast at service. Definitely recommend. Do not let they're small store fool you, they're definitely better tasting then most ice cream”

33 Totopan

3.8 Good 10 Reviews

4509 5th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“New spot on 5av The place is very cozy and aesthetically pleasing. Staff has been attentive and friendly. The cakes and breads look amazing! And so delicious! I ordered a Doblada de pollo. 2 come in the order and was told “made fresh each order” and it tasted amazing! It was so fluffy and filling and also plated beautifully. I look forward to coming back and trying more of their food.”

34 Ines Bakery

3.9 Good 166 Reviews

948 4th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I ordered a tres leche cake everyone loved it even though the name in cake was spelled incorrectly I said Barbara I got BAVARA. My sis still loved it so I was happy. . The only thing I must say the girls that were there are nice but they take a long time to service the customers. I went at 6:15am and had to wait 10 minutes just to get serviced. If they can work on that part great place to go. It smells amazing in there with all the pastries.”

35 Carvel

4.0 Good 48 Reviews

48 5th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great choices. Ice cream lady is very friendly , nice shop and will definitely go back. Looking for specials which some locations have daily This one has Wednesdays bogo free sundae. Unfortunately I was there Friday!!! Ifv5here was a special i might have considered. But I got my usual .”

36 Scotto's Bakery

3.8 Good 21 Reviews

6210 9th Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“Bought a box of their hamantashin at South Jersey Walmart. They make a good product. Actually went back and picked up 6 boxes for other family members. The Scottos cookies that came in for Easter at Walmart looked good great too. $10 for a big box of cookies.”

37 E's Cake Shop

4.0 Good 118 Reviews

1508 86th Street, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Wonderful and flavorful cakes that are perfect for celebration! Came here for our birthday cake for our daughter and they always came out perfectly! Their cupcakes were also decorated very beautifully, and the taste is amazing as well. Their service is always on point and they're friendly and on-time with your order! Highly recommend them!”

38 Carvel

3.7 Good 32 Reviews

374 Tompkins Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We have been coming to this Carvel for a long time. The service here is always amazing, warm, and incredibly friendly. ​What really sets this location apart is how they treat their customers. They actually remember my kids every time we walk through the door, greeting them and treating them with so much kindness and respect. It makes our ice cream runs feel so special!”

39 Caribbean Jerkee's Delight Restaurant

3.2 Average 18 Reviews

117 Rockaway Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“Simply the best Jerk Chicken I've ever tasted finger licking good!”

40 City Line Bakery

3.8 Good 69 Reviews

1047 Liberty Avenue, Brooklyn

• Delivery

“This bakery has Dominican cakes available in slices or the whole cake. They do custom orders or you can ask them to decorate one of the cakes they have ready on display if you're short on time. I'm Dominican and I'm very picky about Dominican cake and they did a great job. I also tried the dulce de leche cortado and it was so delicious. The prices are very reasonable.”

41 Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe

3.8 Good 133 Reviews

5922 New Utrecht Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The bakery is located in the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn. They prepare primarily Italian baked goods. Cakes 🎂, pies 🥧, cookies 🍪, croissants, tarts, danishes, muffins, breads 🍞, gelato, spumoni, tortoni, tartufo and beverages ☕ are available. I ordered a cannoli, cheesecake and napoleon. The food was very good and well-prepared. Friendly and helpful staff.”

42 Cold Stone Creamery

3.7 Good 93 Reviews

2123 Ralph Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Cold Stone Creamery never disappoints! The ice cream is rich, creamy, and perfectly customizable. Whether you’re in the mood for something fruity, chocolaty, or totally over-the-top, they have endless mix-ins to satisfy your cravings. Every bite feels like a treat made just for you. Beyond the delicious ice cream, the cleanliness of the store really stood out to me. The counters, floors, and prep areas were spotless, and everything was well-organized and inviting. You can tell they take hygiene seriously, which makes the whole experience even better. What truly made my visit special, though, was the staff. The employees were so friendly and welcoming—greeting me with big smiles and offering great recommendations. They made sure everything was just right, and you could tell they genuinely cared about providing great service. It felt like they went the extra mile to make sure I had a great experience. Highly recommend stopping by your local Cold Stone if you’re craving a sweet treat and excellent service in a clean, upbeat environment!”

43 Carvel

3.6 Good 78 Reviews

1652 86th Street, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Some of these entitled customers come into Carvel expecting white-glove service. Venchi or Amorino is the place for that. This isn’t the place for you if you want to be greeted like a celebrity. You’ll find quick, reasonably priced ice cream cakes and cupcakes here. However, if you want a perfectly crafted artisan cake packaged with a beautiful smile, be prepared to spend $100. Let’s be real, Karens. This is also my go to for my last minute emergency runs and large family gatherings. Cute cake designs and nostalgic tastes like this cute snowman cake!”

44 Caribbean Jerkee's Delight Restaurant

3.6 Good 83 Reviews

932 Utica Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Simply the best Jerk Chicken I've ever tasted finger licking good!”

45 Mi Estrella Bakery

3.6 Good 115 Reviews

268 Wyckoff Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Los mejores pasteles 🎂 💯 garantizados”

46 Cold Stone Creamery

3.6 Good 144 Reviews

139 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Was around the area after lunch. Googling up a ice cream shop since i was in the mood for some ice cream. so i came across this on google. Went in. Ordered 2 flavors vanilla and dark chocolate combination with resses peanut butter cups as a topping. It was decent ice cream. My biggest regret was getting their largest size. I should have went with a medium size. As large was too much to consume but i ate it all up anyway.”

47 Carvel

3.4 Good 77 Reviews

2166 Bath Avenue, Brooklyn

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This is hands down the best Carvel abs best ice cream store I've ever been in. It's super clean, well stocked with everything they offer, the serving sizes are generous, the people that work there are super friendly and accommodating, and most importantly, they don't skimp on anything! I've spoken with the owner and complimented her on the store, I like it that much.”