50 Best Ice Cream Shops in Brooklyn

“Maravilhoso!“

“Huge selection of board games. Catan, Wingspan, Coup, Heat, Betrayal, Exploding Kittens to name a few of my favorites that I saw. Shout out to Aron for suggesting some new stuff and chatting with me about pokemon he knows his stuff, super friendly! Also alot of tgc being magic and Pokemon alot of the new sets too. Good vibes and energy here.“

“The food was impeccable. The shish barak stood out immediately — brought fully to life by Huda’s deft touch of spice. Among the appetizers, the bandora showcased heirloom tomatoes at their absolute freshest, while the rakkat achieved a rare and graceful balance between sweet and savory. The kibbeh naya is a must-try for anyone who appreciates raw meat.

Service, courtesy of Ismail, was warm without being intrusive, striking exactly the right note. We will be back.“

“Delicious and so happy they have vegan coconut so my whole family can enjoy!“

“I had the the A-La-Mood warm lava cake with 2 scoops of ice cream(Better Pecan & Vanilla) yummy. Be ready to be indecisive because all flavors are delish. You’ll want order a few scoops🍦🍨❤️😋“

“Wow. Brand new, friendly, great business in a great neighborhood, Prospect Lefferts Garden. Would have been great if it was just good, but omg it is honestly the BEST ice cream I’ve had in Brooklyn. Awesome, creative new flavors every week. Yesterday’s was malted ice cream with chopped malted-milk balls. Also mint ice cream made with mint leaves. Another made with honey that also had some chili heat (forgot the name)—all amazing. Go now before you can’t get in.“

“The Best Thai-Food anywhere...#Period“

“The flavors are so yummy. If you are in Red Hook, you should definitely stop here for some dessert 😋“

“We always saw a long line at this ice cream shop, so curiosity won and we joined the crowd. I ordered a tiny scoop of Caffe Bianco Stracciatella. It was light, smooth, refreshing, and not overly sweet, portioned in a perfectly European size. Completely calorie-guilt-free!!
And yes, my mood instantly improved, sponsored by ice-cream.“

“Best tacos de cecina, enchilladas suizas and birria consome around. Oh and great micheladas too. Fun ranchera and banda music on the screens all day, nice vibes and friendly staff. A relaxed and authentic Mexican spot for those in the know. They also used to do karaoke on Friday nights, not sure if thats still a thing..“

“We were in NYC for the weekend and I was told to check this place out. They definitely did not disappoint! Everything was delicious but now I need this in Buffalo….will always be on my list when we visit NYC!“

“Good cakes and very friendly staff.“

“The best ice cream shop in Brooklyn! The atmosphere is wonderful and Kate, the owner, is absolutely amazing. The Screen Door is truly a gem.“

“I recently bought the Earl Grey Tea and Berry Cornbread at my local Kroger store and was blown away! The richness and the flavor profiles were out of this world, especially the latter flavor of the two. It’s dangerous to know the Kroger store is only five minutes from my house. I’ll definitely be trying other flavors.“

“This is the real deal Italian gelato. They imported an authentic gelato machine from Italy and the texture is out if this world.

Flavors are incredible and vary often. Some are more eclectic and grownup (olive oil with breadcrumbs, basil fruit sorbet), others could please kids of all ages (pistachio, coconut stracchiatella). It’s getting good word of mouth traffic right now, but none of the nonsense lines that would happen if any food critic ever decided to hype them up.

Enjoy while it’s still a neighborhood gem!“

“Went for brunch! The food was fantastic..especially the roasted potatoes and banana bread. The staff was so friendly!! Loved it!“

“real old fashioned goodness!“

“Great place for families.“

“Best ice cream and desserts ever!!!“

“We tried several flavors, but the mint and strawberry stood out the most for us. They have a great variety of options to choose from, including some unique and creative combos. We got sundaes topped with whipped cream, pistachio drizzle, and crushed nuts, and everything was fresh and delicious.

They’re also very transparent about allergens, with clear signage and QR codes for detailed info on each flavor, which I appreciated. The staff are attentive and happy to help if you have questions or special requests. Overall a great spot for ice cream if you’re in the area, and definitely worth stopping by for a sweet treat.“

“Best ice cream in Brooklyn. Both the boozy variety and the family friendly options.“

“Friendly staff and great service. Delicious! Definitely going back again.“

“This was the most delicious bowl of Bun rice vermicelli salad I've ever had. Perfect balance of noodles, herbs (mint AND basil, not or!), sprouts, cukes, and delicious pan seared beef. All in abundance, topped with a generous helping of crispy fried shallots. Highly recommend.“

“il vero gelato italiano, il migliore gelato in assoluto! Un'eccellenza!“

“mmmmmm. carrot halva delicious!“

“Fond memories, we go every Wednesday. But the female Mamma passed away and now my brother passed away. He went faithfully every Wednesday with his grandson. But now it's a Carvel Wednesday tradition. In their honor. Very friendly and loving place in Coney Island.“

“I am in love with a yogurt

I got the small original w key lime topping and it was 10/10 no notes, the yogurt was so smooth and the key lime was beautifully zesty. It is pricey but it’s the best froyo I’ve had so it balances out“

“One of the best Coconut ice creams. They also have a large selection of other flavors & the person behind the counter is very likeable and engaging. Definitely recommend....

Sorry I don't have a pic of my ice cream because i'm a hog and ate it right away 🤣“

“Great Gelato shop in Brooklyn! The flavors were classic, and we tried a couple of flavors before landing on the Dulce de leche and the Pistachio. This was a good combination. Nice aesthetics inside with comfortable seating. Service was okay, and the price was a bit steep. $9 for a cup with 2 flavors.“

“very great ice cream I recommend“

“I recently bought the Earl Grey Tea and Berry Cornbread at my local Kroger store and was blown away! The richness and the flavor profiles were out of this world, especially the latter flavor of the two. It’s dangerous to know the Kroger store is only five minutes from my house. I’ll definitely be trying other flavors.“

“Peanut butter mala icecream😍 it’s super creamy with a deep flavor and little kick of heat from the mala. They also have several dairy free flavors, including some sorbets and a rocky road made with coconut milk. It’s a little bit on the pricier side (a small is $6.50) but theyre generous with the serving and the prices are typical for the area. Definitely worth it. A small lets you get one scoop, a medium is two, and a large is three“

“Absolutely the best ice cream I've had in Brooklyn. So far, we've tried grape nut, guava, and Irish moss. All amazing. Are the staff going to gush over you? Maybe not, but they will give you excellent homemade ice cream at a very reasonable price and in a decent size. The guava tastes like fresh guava, and the Irish moss tastes like Christmas: so good.“

“The Italian Ices are amazing, so good lots of different flavors and even sell pints, great value, wonderful people can’t wait to get them again.“

“I just left 'haagen dazs' and I’m still floating on a waffle‑cone cloud! 🍦. The dulce de leche is the stuff of legends, the service is warm and super speedy, and the mint chip makes every lick feel like a mini‑vacation. If you’re hunting for the ultimate ice‑cream spot in the city, this is it—no doubt, five stars all the way! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Want to see more of my experience? Check out my Instagram @lawyer.traveler.dreamer! 🍦🔥 Ample Hills Creamery – A Chocolate Lover’s Dream! 🔥🍦 I stopped by Ample Hills Creamery in NYC, and their Death by Chocolate Hot Chocolate is a must-try! 🍫✨ Here’s why it’s amazing: 🍦 Served in a crispy, edible chocolate-dipped cup with nuts or spearmints. ☕️ Filled with rich hot chocolate and flavored syrup. 🍡 Topped with toasted marshmallow whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and edible gold—delicious! 🤩 We also tried their ice cream and loved it! 🍨 Here’s what we got: 💜 Egg Carton Sampler – 6 flavors to taste it all! 🍦 Waffle bowl with 3 scoops – All for just $52! Our favorite flavors: 🍪 Cookie au Lait – Creamy and full of cookie goodness. 🥭 Underneath the Mango Tree – Sweet and tropical. 🍫 Death by Chocolate – Rich and perfect for chocoholics. 🍌 Banana Pudding – Smooth, creamy, and dreamy. If you’re looking for the best ice cream in NYC, head to Ample Hills Creamery!“

“I have been wanting to try this cash-only vegan ice cream parlor and restaurant for a while now, and it did not disappoint. Scoops offers a wide selection of entirely plant-based ice cream flavors, including pistachio, cherry vanilla, cookies and cream, strawberry, and more when I visited this week. The ice cream tasted fresh, delicious, and healthier than the processed store-bought ice creams. I will be back for more ice cream, and to try their vegan dinner options!“

“Great flavors and options. Large scoop size!“

“Delicious � Lots of options and the staff is friendly .“

“As a dog mom, I normally avoid taking my dog inside restaurants or places serving food out of respect for others. Usually, I leave him by the door or quickly put my head inside to place my order.

What happened here completely changed my experience.

Your staff immediately came to the front, welcomed both of us with kindness, and explained that everything was covered and that my dog was absolutely welcome inside. The amount of love and warmth they showed him honestly meant more than I can explain.

In a world where small acts of kindness can make such a big difference, this was one of those moments I’ll always remember.

Thank you for making me feel welcomed, comfortable, and appreciated. Because of how your staff treated us, this has officially become my go-to ice cream shop. The ice cream was great, but the kindness is what will keep me coming back ❤“

“If you want a place to make your ice cream dreams come true. I says that is the place no matter what season you’ll find it.“

“This is by far the best juice bar in this side of Brooklyn! They have really good smoothies, I love their island roots signature smoothie it has a really smooth texture and it tastes really good.
Marcia is always very friendly and welcoming. I definitely recommend visiting this juice bar.“

“Very nice,friendly. Tasty flavors and many choices to choose from.“

“Raffaella Gelateria-Caffetteria is a true slice of Italy in the heart of Williamsburg. From the moment you walk in, you can tell this place is all about authenticity and quality. Everything feels genuinely Italian—no shortcuts, no compromises. The gelato is outstanding, crafted in true Sicilian style: rich, creamy, and full of real flavor. Their dessert selection is incredible, especially the tiramisù, cannoli, and cassata siciliana, all of which taste like they were made in a traditional Italian pasticceria. Each bite feels fresh, balanced, and perfectly executed. If you’re in the mood for something savory, the arancini are a must—crispy on the outside, comforting and flavorful on the inside, just like in Sicily. And of course, the Italian espresso is excellent: strong, smooth, and exactly what you’d expect from a proper Italian caffè. Raffaella isn’t just a gelateria or a café—it’s an experience. A place where Italians feel at home and everyone else gets to discover what real Italian food and coffee are supposed to taste like. Absolutely worth a visit, whether for a quick espresso, a sweet treat, or a full Italian-style break.“

“todo muy rico. las pastas . Los helados .todo“

“Love this place it’s so convenient, but the baristas are not consistent! Idol is the best at making coffee when he is there and definitely worth stopping by, but the other baristas tend to make some really bitter and burnt drinks so keep an eye out!“

“All I can say is…AMAZING! Absolute BEST ice cream place around, hands down. Definitely going back again and again.“

“todo muy rico. las pastas . Los helados .todo“

“The ice cream is excellent, but they need to bring back bread and roses. ;)“

“This ice cream BLEW MY MIND!!! Wow. What a local gem. I got the caramel-fried pecan peach cornbread flavor and the blueberry cobbler lemon flavor — HIGHLY recommend both!!! Finished them before I could remember to take a photo! Probably the best ice cream I've ever had. Wow. I can't wait to come back as many times as possible this summer!“