Lucibello's Italian Pastry Shop
935 Grand Ave, New Haven
(203) 562-4083
Customers' Favorites
Pastries Cookies Cookie Trays Cakes Pies
Whipped Cream Vanilla Cake with Filling
Vanilla Cream Chocolate Eclair
Napoleon Cannoli Siciliani
Neapolitan Birthday Cake
Apricot Almond Cake
1 lb Loose Assorted
Assorted Pastries
Sicilian Cannoli
Full Sheet Cake
Menu
Photos
+69 photos
+68 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Tried Lucibello’s for the first time on my birthday and wasn’t disappointed! We filled up a box of goodies to have with cake, and everything was great! My Italian grandfather proclaimed them the real deal as well. Reasonable prices for great quality, and everyone was friendly at the shop. Just a no frills, traditional Italian bakery. We will definitely stop by again when we’re in the area!
This place was absolutely top notch. We had our wedding cake made here this past April (2026) and they accommodated every single request. The tasting was also convenient. You can do it there or bring it home. Highly recommend for taste, reliability and great customer service!
I went here on a Sunday afternoon.
Staff was super nice, but everything we got was extremely stale and dry. We got cannoli, cupcakes, and cookies. I think the problem was going late in the day before closing. Will definitely try again maybe go earlier in the morning.
Staff was super nice, but everything we got was extremely stale and dry. We got cannoli, cupcakes, and cookies. I think the problem was going late in the day before closing. Will definitely try again maybe go earlier in the morning.
You May Also Like
Sunday Dinner Everyday - 940 Grand Ave
![]()
Jamaican, Barbeque, Chicken Wings
Kumo Sushi Hibachi - 7 Elm St
![]()
Sushi, Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegan
Icaru Peruvian Restaurant - 39 Elm St
![]()
Peruvian, Chicken Shop, Seafood