The hours are really weird for a Panera (especially when it’s across the street from a university?) The kiosks were slow and occasionally just randomly pause. Food was not great, the soup tasted watery, and the chicken sandwich was not cooked properly (the chicken was cold). One of the ladies working in the back was also super rude (African American with the missing tooth).
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Patrick Bateman
I am leaning back in my chair, my fingers steepled. On the screen of my laptop, the Panera Bread website glows, a study in benign, rustic-chic typography. I had a business lunch today, but it was a solitary one. An imperative. I was starving.
Let’s start with the location. The Panera in New Haven is acceptably clean. The floors are a non-threatening, polished hardwood, the lighting is a diffused, inoffensive amber, and the ambient noise is a carefully engineered hum of white noise and soft rock, probably chosen by a demographic consultant in St. Louis. It’s not Dorsia, but it’s not… some ghastly food court atrocity, either. It will do.
I approached the counter. The staff here is a problem. A young woman with a name tag that read “Chloe” greeted me with a smile that showed too many teeth. It was a vacant, practiced smile, the kind you see on flight attendants or kindergarten teachers. “Hi there! How are you doing today?” she asked, her voice a saccharine melody. I was doing… well, I was doing quite well, actually. My suit is a Giorgio Armani, my business cards are bone-colored, Roman-type, and I had just closed the Henderson account. But her question wasn’t a real question. It was a corporate-mandated vocalization, a hollow pleasantry. I find that sort of faux-friendliness deeply irritating. It lacks substance. It lacks truth. Just give me my food. Don’t pretend you care.
I ordered the Tuna Salad Sandwich on Brioche and the French Onion Soup in the Sourdough Bread Bowl. I was very clear. Very precise. She repeated it back with that same cloying enthusiasm. “Excellent choice!” Was it? Or was it just a choice? There’s a difference.
I took a seat by the window, overlooking the New Haven street. I could see my own reflection, pale and serious, a monument of control amidst the pedestrian chaos. When the food arrived, I was prepared to be disappointed. I was prepared to document every failure.
But… I wasn’t.
The Tuna Salad Sandwich was… perfect. The tuna was a consistent, creamy texture, with just the right amount of celery for a structural crunch. No rogue onions. The brioche was soft, yielding, but not soggy. It held its form. It was a coherent, well-engineered product. I ate it with a methodical precision, each bite identical to the last. It satisfied a deep, cellular hunger. I could feel the proteins realigning.
The soup, however, was the main event. The French Onion Soup arrives in a cavernous sourdough bowl, the cheese a single, molten, golden-brown sheet stretched over the top. It’s a presentation that implies structural integrity. I broke through the cheese with my spoon—a satisfying, viscous tear—and excavated a portion of the bread-soaked broth. The flavor was robust, a deep, caramelized umami, the Gruyère providing a salty, fatty counterpoint. The sourdough itself, once penetrated by the soup, became a savory, steaming pudding. It was efficient. It was complete. There was no waste. I consumed every last gram of carbohydrate and protein. I even ate the bowl. The entire, hollowed-out sourdough vessel. It was gone.
I sat there for a long moment, utterly sated. The meal was a flawless execution of its concept. It was better than the one I had at that pretentious bistro on the Upper West Side last week. Far better.
And yet, as I left, “Chloe” chirped, “Have a great day!” with that same empty, surgical cheer. I gave her a tight, lipless smile in return. The food is impeccable. It’s the people that are the problem. If they could just be a little less… enthusiastic, a little more sterile and professional, then the entire experience would be unimpeachable. But for now, I’ll be back. The sandwich is that good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kooi Chan
The kiosk didn’t work properly and I ended up ordering in-person. The young girl was friendly. After paying, I went over to pick up my food. But I need to use the restroom. We had to use a key to open the restrooms. I asked politely and said is this the key to the restroom and the staff just nodded with no smile. She looked miserable working there. After using the restroom, I gave the key to another customer in line. I got my food and was able to eat. Overall the food was good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Manisha Skaria
.I order on app and by the time I reach the place, it is ready.
Dylan Endlich
Really nice staff this morning! We used the kiosk to order but the front-of-house staff went out of their way to make sure our needs were met as we ordered and then hand delivered our breakfast to-go.
I wish I got the ladies name, but her efforts made a really positive impression.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S. A.
Horrible coffee. They dont have an expresso machine, it's all drip and it tastes like it has oil in it. Very strange.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Heather Quirk
3/5 times I have ordered from here my order has been more than 45 minutes late. Do not do delivery from here. The employees are not helpful and act bothered when you call for help.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Merry Kroeger
This place must have gone out of business- they were closed.
lach vieja
Bad treatment to customers especially the person where we picked up our order. I was the one who ordered food in the cashier but my husband was the one who went to take the food. He asked the person in the pick order if that was our order since the small buzzer was not working, the staff was so irritable to answer and said just take what you ordered! Thankfully the cashier went to clarify things. It’s not a busy day, less customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Chelsea
Me and the girls at my job ordered here today and the soup was awful, watery and cured, I ended up having to throw it in the trash and I'm so upset because I've been looking forward to having the cheddar broccoli soup but because of this I will probably never order or go to this location ever again in my life! Somebody NEEDS to correct this because this health hazard location won't be open much longer if the soup keeps being made this way! I'm sorry but this ruined my day unfortunately 😔
If you like Panera Bread, this is a great location
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jeremy Edmunds
Panera Bread in New Haven offers a familiar fast-casual dining experience. The menu features a range of pastries and breads that are generally unremarkable but consistent with what you'd expect from the national chain. Salads, priced around $14, come with extra cold chicken and are on par with other locations. The coffee selection is adequate, neither exceptional nor distinctively disappointing.
The restaurant provides plenty of seating for customers, making it suitable for both quick meals and longer stays. The self-service system allows patrons to order and dine at their own pace without feeling rushed. Amenities are standard for a chain restaurant of this type.
Overall, this Panera Bread location delivers a predictable experience that aligns with the brand's middling reputation. It's a reliable option for those seeking a quick meal or a place to work or study, though it will not stand out in terms of culinary offerings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
james rowlette
Clean and welcoming. Looks small from the street, but is actually large.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Green Systems
Nasty place in downtown New Haven, if you ask them bathroom access they scream at you and give these dirty keys
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Swetha Rakhecha
Panera Bread at this location was the first place I ordered from in the USA, and the experience couldn’t have been better. As someone new to the country, I needed help with the payment process, and the person taking my order was incredibly helpful and patient. Their kindness and support made me feel at ease and really improved my initial experience in the US. The food was delicious, and the service was exceptional. I’m grateful for the warm welcome and would highly recommend this place!
The hours are really weird for a Panera (especially when it’s across the street from a university?) The kiosks were slow and occasionally just randomly pause. Food was not great, the soup tasted watery, and the chicken sandwich was not cooked properly (the chicken was cold). One of the ladies working in the back was also super rude (African American with the missing tooth).
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I am leaning back in my chair, my fingers steepled. On the screen of my laptop, the Panera Bread website glows, a study in benign, rustic-chic typography. I had a business lunch today, but it was a solitary one. An imperative. I was starving.
Let’s start with the location. The Panera in New Haven is acceptably clean. The floors are a non-threatening, polished hardwood, the lighting is a diffused, inoffensive amber, and the ambient noise is a carefully engineered hum of white noise and soft rock, probably chosen by a demographic consultant in St. Louis. It’s not Dorsia, but it’s not… some ghastly food court atrocity, either. It will do.
I approached the counter. The staff here is a problem. A young woman with a name tag that read “Chloe” greeted me with a smile that showed too many teeth. It was a vacant, practiced smile, the kind you see on flight attendants or kindergarten teachers. “Hi there! How are you doing today?” she asked, her voice a saccharine melody. I was doing… well, I was doing quite well, actually. My suit is a Giorgio Armani, my business cards are bone-colored, Roman-type, and I had just closed the Henderson account. But her question wasn’t a real question. It was a corporate-mandated vocalization, a hollow pleasantry. I find that sort of faux-friendliness deeply irritating. It lacks substance. It lacks truth. Just give me my food. Don’t pretend you care.
I ordered the Tuna Salad Sandwich on Brioche and the French Onion Soup in the Sourdough Bread Bowl. I was very clear. Very precise. She repeated it back with that same cloying enthusiasm. “Excellent choice!” Was it? Or was it just a choice? There’s a difference.
I took a seat by the window, overlooking the New Haven street. I could see my own reflection, pale and serious, a monument of control amidst the pedestrian chaos. When the food arrived, I was prepared to be disappointed. I was prepared to document every failure.
But… I wasn’t.
The Tuna Salad Sandwich was… perfect. The tuna was a consistent, creamy texture, with just the right amount of celery for a structural crunch. No rogue onions. The brioche was soft, yielding, but not soggy. It held its form. It was a coherent, well-engineered product. I ate it with a methodical precision, each bite identical to the last. It satisfied a deep, cellular hunger. I could feel the proteins realigning.
The soup, however, was the main event. The French Onion Soup arrives in a cavernous sourdough bowl, the cheese a single, molten, golden-brown sheet stretched over the top. It’s a presentation that implies structural integrity. I broke through the cheese with my spoon—a satisfying, viscous tear—and excavated a portion of the bread-soaked broth. The flavor was robust, a deep, caramelized umami, the Gruyère providing a salty, fatty counterpoint. The sourdough itself, once penetrated by the soup, became a savory, steaming pudding. It was efficient. It was complete. There was no waste. I consumed every last gram of carbohydrate and protein. I even ate the bowl. The entire, hollowed-out sourdough vessel. It was gone.
I sat there for a long moment, utterly sated. The meal was a flawless execution of its concept. It was better than the one I had at that pretentious bistro on the Upper West Side last week. Far better.
And yet, as I left, “Chloe” chirped, “Have a great day!” with that same empty, surgical cheer. I gave her a tight, lipless smile in return. The food is impeccable. It’s the people that are the problem. If they could just be a little less… enthusiastic, a little more sterile and professional, then the entire experience would be unimpeachable. But for now, I’ll be back. The sandwich is that good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The kiosk didn’t work properly and I ended up ordering in-person. The young girl was friendly. After paying, I went over to pick up my food. But I need to use the restroom. We had to use a key to open the restrooms. I asked politely and said is this the key to the restroom and the staff just nodded with no smile. She looked miserable working there. After using the restroom, I gave the key to another customer in line.
I got my food and was able to eat. Overall the food was good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
.I order on app and by the time I reach the place, it is ready.
Really nice staff this morning! We used the kiosk to order but the front-of-house staff went out of their way to make sure our needs were met as we ordered and then hand delivered our breakfast to-go.
I wish I got the ladies name, but her efforts made a really positive impression.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible coffee. They dont have an expresso machine, it's all drip and it tastes like it has oil in it. Very strange.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
3/5 times I have ordered from here my order has been more than 45 minutes late. Do not do delivery from here. The employees are not helpful and act bothered when you call for help.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
This place must have gone out of business- they were closed.
Bad treatment to customers especially the person where we picked up our order. I was the one who ordered food in the cashier but my husband was the one who went to take the food. He asked the person in the pick order if that was our order since the small buzzer was not working, the staff was so irritable to answer and said just take what you ordered! Thankfully the cashier went to clarify things. It’s not a busy day, less customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Me and the girls at my job ordered here today and the soup was awful, watery and cured, I ended up having to throw it in the trash and I'm so upset because I've been looking forward to having the cheddar broccoli soup but because of this I will probably never order or go to this location ever again in my life! Somebody NEEDS to correct this because this health hazard location won't be open much longer if the soup keeps being made this way! I'm sorry but this ruined my day unfortunately 😔
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
If you like Panera Bread, this is a great location
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Panera Bread in New Haven offers a familiar fast-casual dining experience. The menu features a range of pastries and breads that are generally unremarkable but consistent with what you'd expect from the national chain. Salads, priced around $14, come with extra cold chicken and are on par with other locations. The coffee selection is adequate, neither exceptional nor distinctively disappointing.
The restaurant provides plenty of seating for customers, making it suitable for both quick meals and longer stays. The self-service system allows patrons to order and dine at their own pace without feeling rushed. Amenities are standard for a chain restaurant of this type.
Overall, this Panera Bread location delivers a predictable experience that aligns with the brand's middling reputation. It's a reliable option for those seeking a quick meal or a place to work or study, though it will not stand out in terms of culinary offerings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Clean and welcoming. Looks small from the street, but is actually large.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nasty place in downtown New Haven, if you ask them bathroom access they scream at you and give these dirty keys
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Panera Bread at this location was the first place I ordered from in the USA, and the experience couldn’t have been better. As someone new to the country, I needed help with the payment process, and the person taking my order was incredibly helpful and patient. Their kindness and support made me feel at ease and really improved my initial experience in the US. The food was delicious, and the service was exceptional. I’m grateful for the warm welcome and would highly recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Cheese
Loading...