Arethusa Farm Dairy
$ • Ice CreamAbout Arethusa Farm Dairy
Arethusa Farm Dairy Reviews
344 ratings
Share your opinion about Arethusa Farm Dairy
the service was very nice here. i asked him for just one scoop in my small cup and he was surprised lol. but it was just enough! i sometimes can't finish my ice cream so its good to have a smaller portion. its soooooooooooo fresh! smooth and creamy! omg so so good! i just wish they had more tables to sit because this stupid family took up the whole sitting area. this is the best ice cream i ever had! i think about it all the time lol.
My new favorite ice cream place! I was visiting the area and this csme highly recommended, I miss it everyday!! Got the raspberry ice cream and the double chocolate with chips ones!
I lived in New Haven CT 2 years and been here once and BY the Goddess 😍 I'm in love there ice cream 🍨🍦 so 🤤 yum and fresh I know I'm going again for my birthday 🎂🎈 treat my self
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 12 - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 9PM |
| Friday | 12 - 9:30PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 9:30PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9:30PM |
Arethusa Farm Dairy offers exceptional ice cream with a perfect texture, thickness, and complexity. The best 3-scoop combination is Maple Walnut, Strawberry, and Rum Raisin. High-quality ice cream is also available in seasonal flavors like hazelnut with chocolate espresso beans, pumpkin, and sweet cream. Customers can ask for one scoop split into two flavors. The ice cream shop features a friendly staff, black-and-white tile flooring, and cow-themed decor. The shop has a cool atmosphere, blending a classic look with a modern, clean design. Although the prices are on the higher side, with a regular cup costing about $8 before adding a waffle cone, many believe the high-quality ingredients justify the cost. The shop is open during winter months, allowing visitors to enjoy late-night cravings for delectable ice cream. The ice cream is creamy and loaded with toppings, with customers often choosing flavors like coconut with dark chocolate chips or pumpkin, which has a strong ginger molasses taste resembling a ginger snap. The shop offers a small but great selection of flavors, and customers appreciate the friendly service. While some find the prices a bit steep, most agree the ice cream's rich, indulgent quality makes it worth trying. Customers can also ask for one scoop split into two flavors and enjoy a variety of seasonal and classic options.