15 Best Ice Cream Shops in New Haven

Elena's on Orange Ice Cream Shop • $
831 Orange St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pieces
Chocolate Soft Serve
Cross Cookie Sundae
Toasted PE Cans
Whipped Cream
Chocolate Dip
Brownie Haven
Secret Sauce
Waffle Cone
Hot Fudge

“The best soft serve ice cream I have ever had! I have to go every week!“

4.6 Superb144 Reviews
Ashley's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
280 York St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Black Raspberry
Butter Crunch
Butter Pecan
Coffee Oreo
Nutella
Chip

“I love this ice cream place it is great place for friends and family!!“

4.5 Superb220 Reviews
Arethusa Farm Dairy Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
1020 Chapel St, New Haven

“Arethusa Farm Dairy was a standout stop on our trip. The ice cream was incredibly rich and creamy, and the vanilla in particular was excellent—simple, but done exceptionally well with great flavor.

You can really tell the quality is there, and it lives up to the reputation. Everything tasted fresh and well-made.

Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the area.“

4.2 Good318 Reviews
BILLS CAROUSEL ICE CREAM &YOGURT Ice Cream Shop • $
1185 Whalley Avenue, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Hard Ice Cream - Cup
24 Flavor Soft Serve
Banana Split

“The staff is always friendly and the black cherry soft serve us the best“

4.2 Good197 Reviews
Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $$
159 Temple St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Hot Fudge Sundae
Butter Pecan
Strawberry
Brownie

“Delicious ice cream and milkshakes!“

4.2 Good120 Reviews
Sweets Ice Cream and More Ice Cream Shop •
320 Foxon Blvd, New Haven

“I love this place. There r so many things in the menu u just wouldn't expect and it's all delicious. You also get big portions. The milkshakes are amazing. I always get takeout just because the seating area is small but it's still very nice.“

3 Average2 Reviews
El Rey Azteca Ice Cream Shop •
315 Grand Ave, New Haven

“Good good bueno delicious you have to try“

3.9 Good14 Reviews
The Clay Date Ice Cream • $$
146 Amity Rd, New Haven

“Was tons of fun! Definitely will be going back!“

4.9 Superb162 Reviews
Gioia Cafe and Bar Italian • $$
150 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Ember Roasted Squash Agnolotti
Complimentary Garlic Bread
Complimentary Garlic Knots
Eggplant and Broccolini
While Roasted Branzino
Roasted Acorn Squash
Rigatoni Carbonara
Tiramisu for Two
Pistachio Gelato
White Bean Soup

“Every bite was delicious!“

4.5 Superb350 Reviews
La Fenice Coffee Shops • $
630 Chapel St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

French Toast 3 pcs
Ham \u0026 Turkey
Smoked Salmon
Fresh Spring
Prosciutto
Gelato

“Best cannoli I've ever had. And wonderful pizza, quiche, and pastries. My espresso place every weekend morning.“

4.6 Superb86 Reviews
Libby's Italian Pastry Shop and Italian Ice Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
139 Wooster St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Covered Cannoli
Peanut Butter Cheesecake
Pistachio Ice Cream
Pistachio Canolli
Cannoli Siciliani
Italian Pastries
Nutella Cannoli
Dipped Eclair
Lobster Tail
Cannoli Cake

“I've been going here for years. Best place with the best people. Try it yourself you'll love it.“

3.7 Good286 Reviews
Vivi Bubble Tea Bubble Tea • $
940 Chapel St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Taro Creme Brulee Milk Tea with Flan and Bob's Right Honeydew Milk Tea Eith Basil Seed Left
flaming brown sugar tapioca - cold 火焰黑糖珍珠鮮奶 - cold
Build Your Own Poke Bowl
Bubble Milk Green Tea
Passion Fruit qq Tea
Coffee Jelly
Cream Float
Taro Slush
Fruit Tea

“Their teas are so good and refreshing, you can order your tea custom how you like,they have machine that shakes the drink quite vigorously to mix it well.I tried the Thai milk tea with bubbles and passionfruit green tea with mango popping. Both were very good 👍“

4.3 Superb220 Reviews
Milkcraft New Haven Ice Cream Shop • $
280 Crown St Ste 100, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Salted Caramel in Churro Bubble Cone
Cookie Butter Blue on Waffle Cone
Sea Salted Caramel
Blue Cookie
Red Velvet
Strawberry
Sorbet

“I tell you what, Milkcraft better not EVER come to my town, because I will be 800 pounds. This bubble waffle cone is pure genius. The creativity is alive in this joint, and whoever is coming up with these ice cream ideas needs a raise. I absolutely recommend coming a couple times, just so you can enjoy all the different things they offer.“

3.5 Good246 Reviews
Insomnia Cookies Dessert • $$
240-242 College St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Box of 6 Cookies Chocolate Chunk Cookie Double Chocolate Mint White Chocolate Macadamia
Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Cookie Sandwich
Insomnia Chocolate Cookie Butter
Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Mint Chocolate Chip
Vegan Birthday Cake
Ice Cream Sandwich
Cookie Selection
Oatmeal Raisin
Salted Caramel

“Fresh warm delicious cookies that taste like they literally just got out of the oven. What more could you ask for??? Yummy!“

3.9 Good269 Reviews
Shake Shack New Haven Hamburger • $
986 Chapel St, New Haven

Customers` Favorites

Single and Double Shack Burger with Lemonade
Korean Style Fried Chicken Sandwich
Bacon Cheeseburger with Avocado
Double Shake Shack Burger
Bacon Cheese Fries
Smokeshack Burger
Mushroom Burger
Frozen Custard
Veggie Burger
Chick'n Shack

“Today was our first time in a Shake Shack Restaurant. Ordering was a quick process and our food was ready within a good 10 minutes or so? I ordered the Smoke Shack Double with French Fries and a 50/50 Lemonade/Iced Tea. My fiancé ordered a 6 piece of Chicken Bites….Hot, Juicy and Delicious. The Smoke Shake Double is my added to my personal list of “Favorite Burgers” 1. Five Guys Orange 2. Shake Shack New Haven 3. Prime 16 Orange 4. Prime Burger Ridgefield“

3.4 Good315 Reviews

You May Also Like