Bagelicious II
91 Washington Ave, North Haven
(203) 535-0632
Customers' Favorites
Ham Egg and Cheese
Nova Lox Bagel
Egg Sandwich
Sandwiches
Fresh Baked
Bagels
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The Bagelicious experience is similar to getting a good pie on Wooster Street, sometimes you have to wait in a long line, but the product is well worth it.
I’ve been a steady walk-in customer twice-a-week since they opened their North Haven location a few years ago.
IMO their bagels are the best in the Greater New Haven area only rivaled by their Cheshire location, Shef’s in Cheshire, and Olmo in New Haven, which is why they have so many...
I’ve been a steady walk-in customer twice-a-week since they opened their North Haven location a few years ago.
IMO their bagels are the best in the Greater New Haven area only rivaled by their Cheshire location, Shef’s in Cheshire, and Olmo in New Haven, which is why they have so many...
Bagels are always fresh and love the cream cheese - the jalapeño cheddar with the jalapeño cream cheese is my go to order.
However as others have said - the wait for both placing your order and the receiving it is just an insane amount of time - both at the drive thru and in the store. How it take so long really boggles the mind.
However as others have said - the wait for both placing your order and the receiving it is just an insane amount of time - both at the drive thru and in the store. How it take so long really boggles the mind.
You May Also Like
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill - 59 Washington Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
Crazy Toast House Restaurant - 117 Washington Ave unit 5
![]()
Burgers, Hot Dogs, Wraps
Tokyo Sushi II - 117 Washington Ave
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Caterers, Vegan, Vegetarian
One thing i did notice is that one of the male workers (i think he was a cook) was grabbing the bagels with his bare hands. They could have been clean or just washed, but i saw...