Bagel Poppy

$ • Bagels

Menu Order Online

About Bagel Poppy

Bagel Poppy is described as the best bagels in Connecticut. Everything about this establishment is first class. Staff is friendly and kind, and the food is delicious. The bagels and coffee are delicious, with the bagels always fresh and menu combinations top-tier. The jalapeños bagels are a favorite. The fetti lattes were spectacular, some of the best specialty coffee. The Club Pop and a Pistachio Cloud Coffee are a go-to order, and the Club Pop on an everything bagel is highly recommended. Workers greet customers each time, with incredible staff and incredible service. The owner was unbelievably helpful, even buying a dozen gluten free bagels from another shop and giving them for free. The pup waiting outside was offered some cheese and water. Bagel Poppy is a wonderful bakery.

Customers' Favorites

Club Pop

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Bagel Poppy Reviews

4.8

76 ratings

91%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Bagel Poppy

Write a review

Best Bagels in Connecticut. Hands-down.
Everything about this establishment is first class.
Anytime I am in the area. I will definitely be back there for a bagel. Period.

September 2026

I love Bagel Poppy! Staff is friendly, food is delicious! The jalapeños bagels are my favorite:) They even offered my pup waiting outside some cheese and water! So sweet, we love it here and will definitely be back soon!

September 2026

I could talk endlessly about how delicious the bagels and coffee are here. But instead, I’ll talk about the workers. I come in here once every 2-3 weeks or so. Mainly when I’m up early and want to treat myself to some good breakfast and coffee. Despite this, every single worker knows my name and greets me each time. Even though I’ve only been here 10-12 times total over the past 6 months. Incredible staff. Incredible service. 10/10

September 2026

Read All Reviews(75)