“I don't know why this place has such low ratings because I've fully enjoyed everything I have tried here! I enjoyed it so much that I had to go twice last weekend. The tri color cookies and lemon cheesecake squares are my favorite!“
“I live in Stamford, CT and I ordered cookies for my 3 year old’s Firefighter themed birthday party. First off the response time is amazing. Jodi answered my first inquiry in a flash and all correspondence there after was instantaneous. My cookies were beautiful and delicious. Shipping was on time and everything came in tact. I will certainly be using this shop again!“
“This place is great! It had the "mom and pop" vibes that makes you know a bakery is going to be good. Service was good. Greeted immediately when I came in and she had good recommendations for what to buy to get myself to the credit card minimum. I was in and out in under three minutes. The food here is INCREDIBLE. I had a crumb cake and it was perfect in every way. My sister had a cannoli and said it was the best she's ever had. I felt that the brownies were too thin and dry, but the flavor profile was good.“
“100% the only place I’ll order custom cookies. Not only are they beautiful, but they are amazing! I really wasn’t expecting them to taste so great! I thought they were too pretty to taste so good but I was wrong. Definitely have her on speed dial for any upcoming events.“
“Simply the most beautiful cake in all the land. Made with artistic precision. Delivery was impeccable. The service was over the moon with the strange requests I had. Steve made a once-in-a-lifetime event even more meaningful with his cake. I will be forever grateful for Steve and all he did.“
“Wonderful all around!!! My grandson wanted a gender reveal for his soon to be sibling at his 7th birthday. Amy's orders were: gender reveal, with some chocolate cake AND by the way he wants a Minecraft cake. Amy did not disappoint. Cake was delicious, top layer PINK bottom chocolate. Awesome design. I'd highly recommend Amy Cakes for any occasion. Oh and staff personable and fun!“