Custom Cakes near Wallingford, CT

“Amazing cakes and pastries! I absolutely love the chocolate chip cannoli. I think it’s my favorite dessert. My husband loves the chocolate mousse pastries and the Italian rum birthday cake. They have a small number of indoor tables and a few outdoor tables. We’ve never had a problem finding a seat if we want to eat there though. The gelato is also very good. There is a $10 minimum for credit card purchases but two desserts will typically put the bill just over $10.“

“Sweet Seidner's is one of my best discoveries. I'd driven past this bakeshop every week, thinking they just sold pre-ordered items. One morning I decided to stop in, and I've been visiting them almost every week ever since. Cookies, brownies, hamantaschen, cakes, bars--all equally delicious and taste authentically homemade. They are kind people, happy to bake special requests and appreciative of their customers. 5++ stars!“

“Super easy to work with, tasty treats and reasonable pricing! Our puppy cupcakes came out amazing!“

“I want to thank Amy for doing a wonderful job on my daughters wedding cake. She did an awesome job. The cake was so good.“

“Had the best Italian cream pie for Easter! So good!!“

“I got a cake from here 2 years and it was exactly what I wanted (the heart cake). My husband loved the taste and kept mentioning it when it got closer to his birthday this year so I, of course, had to get another one. It was AMAZING! Everyone loved it and a few said it was the best cake they’d ever had. Yellow cake with cheesecake filling and buttercream- highly recommend. Steve was also great with communicating and working through my indecisiveness about the design.“

“Mmm mmm mmm!!! I got the strawberry blonde, my husband got the founders favorite, both were absolutely delicious. Fun to watch them mix the ice cream on the cold stone and the flavor combos were great! Definitely want to come back to try another signature creation!“