I made the mistake of going to Gatisonella Bakery at 10:45 a.m. on a Saturday morning...they were almost sold out! You see it was my first time there and I had no idea how wonderful these beautifully made and incredibly tasting treats were!! Thank goodness there were a few items left to buy and try for myself, ahem, for my daughter's birthday! The cupcakes were heavenly and worth the price tag. In my opinion, most bakeries make and sell a "cupcake size" cupcake - you know, the size we would make at home - and then add a half cup of frosting to make them look large enough to warrant the price tag. That is not the case at Gatisonella. Tabitha's cupcakes are more of a "muffin size" and she does not drown them in frosting. IMO, it's just enough and it's not sickening sweet. The cake is more on the dense side, which I love, because it holds up to the frosting. I will be back, earlier in the day, for more!
kat 88
Great experience! My boyfriends church was having a gathering and he wanted to bring bannana pudding. It was a last minute thing. The event was on saturday we called them a couple hours before they closed on friday. They were very friendly professional and accommodating. We went down to try their banna pudding and we wete very satisfied. We ordered a pan of it for the event for 40.00. It was well worth it.
Cindi Anastasio
Cupcakes were delicious! Bought for my mother’s birthday- she loved the lemon! Tried many of the flavors- all were incredible!
Kevin Ramirez
Great new place…tried a few cupcakes and gave that tingle in the back of your mouth that satisfies your sweet tooth. Going back for a larger party order next time..love this small business and hope they succeed!!
Rad Deso
We went into our new bakery in our great city of west haven, happy to have a family own bakery, well went in today to get a birthday cake there where like 15 cupcakes in cases a Register and a commercial heating unit in the corner, ask them do you have cakes, sure they do a 6 inch chocolate cake $30, no cakes or cookies or any real bakery stuff not happy,, you will not last in west haven if you guys don’t step up, and this is on a Thursday
Andrew Teshoney
I wish I could share photos of the desserts here but frankly we eat them too fast to remember to take pics! Made fresh with real attention to detail - these are not your regular store bought cupcakes mass produced. These are delicacies made with love and shared with the community. You NEED to try them. And those other comments about the Banana pudding cups? Uh…. Yeah….if I ever go there and don’t bring one home for my wife I would expect divorce papers will await me by the next day. It’s that good.
Terri Johnson
I brought two of everything. And I will be back for more.
Candy Rivera
Everything was beyond delicious perfect sweetness and of course professional. When I went to pick up my treats they made me feel so comfortable as if I was a regular customer although it was only my 1st time but definitely not my last it sucks that I live in Springfield Massachusetts but it will be worth the trip
Nora Proops
Soft, delicious cookie packed with white chocolate and macadamia nuts- wow!!!
lady phenomenal
It was a very nice trip to the bakery and the food is great you must goooooo to the bakery
I had an extremely pleasant experience while visiting Gatisonella Bakery. It was clean, inviting, and nicely placed together. The atmosphere was so welcoming including two little men that greeted us. While disappointed there was no cheesecake, Tabitha the owner encouraged me to come back on a particular day to retrieve it. She was also very attentive to our needs and she even spent time chatting with us about business. I would highly recommend and return to this new establishment.
MercilessMurse
Excellent cupcakes! Great mix of not to fancy with that homemade touch, warm and welcoming staff with the best banana pudding you'll ever experience!!!
Mary-Ann Flynn
Delicious sweets! The brownies are big and fudge-y , banana pudding tastes better than home made and the macarons are as tasty as they are pretty. ( lemon, coconut, Oreo, strawberry).
M Riley
I’m must say the Banana pudding is really good. I also had a strawberry shortcake cupcake which was really good but I forgot to take a picture of it.
Brenda Fenton
I picked up a couple of things to try from Gatisonella Bakery across from West Haven's best dry-cleaner ?. The chocolate brownie was very good (haven't tried the chocolate cupcake yet) but I LOVE the lemon cupcake! The cake is lusciously lemon and the frosting is perfect- not too sweet, great balance in flavor and texture. I'll be back and definitely recommend it to others.
I made the mistake of going to Gatisonella Bakery at 10:45 a.m. on a Saturday morning...they were almost sold out! You see it was my first time there and I had no idea how wonderful these beautifully made and incredibly tasting treats were!! Thank goodness there were a few items left to buy and try for myself, ahem, for my daughter's birthday! The cupcakes were heavenly and worth the price tag. In my opinion, most bakeries make and sell a "cupcake size" cupcake - you know, the size we would make at home - and then add a half cup of frosting to make them look large enough to warrant the price tag. That is not the case at Gatisonella. Tabitha's cupcakes are more of a "muffin size" and she does not drown them in frosting. IMO, it's just enough and it's not sickening sweet. The cake is more on the dense side, which I love, because it holds up to the frosting. I will be back, earlier in the day, for more!
Great experience! My boyfriends church was having a gathering and he wanted to bring bannana pudding. It was a last minute thing. The event was on saturday we called them a couple hours before they closed on friday. They were very friendly professional and accommodating. We went down to try their banna pudding and we wete very satisfied. We ordered a pan of it for the event for 40.00. It was well worth it.
Cupcakes were delicious! Bought for my mother’s birthday- she loved the lemon! Tried many of the flavors- all were incredible!
Great new place…tried a few cupcakes and gave that tingle in the back of your mouth that satisfies your sweet tooth. Going back for a larger party order next time..love this small business and hope they succeed!!
We went into our new bakery in our great city of west haven, happy to have a family own bakery, well went in today to get a birthday cake there where like 15 cupcakes in cases a Register and a commercial heating unit in the corner, ask them do you have cakes, sure they do a 6 inch chocolate cake $30, no cakes or cookies or any real bakery stuff not happy,, you will not last in west haven if you guys don’t step up, and this is on a Thursday
I wish I could share photos of the desserts here but frankly we eat them too fast to remember to take pics! Made fresh with real attention to detail - these are not your regular store bought cupcakes mass produced. These are delicacies made with love and shared with the community. You NEED to try them. And those other comments about the Banana pudding cups? Uh…. Yeah….if I ever go there and don’t bring one home for my wife I would expect divorce papers will await me by the next day. It’s that good.
I brought two of everything. And I will be back for more.
Everything was beyond delicious perfect sweetness and of course professional. When I went to pick up my treats they made me feel so comfortable as if I was a regular customer although it was only my 1st time but definitely not my last it sucks that I live in Springfield Massachusetts but it will be worth the trip
Soft, delicious cookie packed with white chocolate and macadamia nuts- wow!!!
It was a very nice trip to the bakery and the food is great you must goooooo to the bakery
Restaurantji Recommends
I had an extremely pleasant experience while visiting Gatisonella Bakery. It was clean, inviting, and nicely placed together. The atmosphere was so welcoming including two little men that greeted us. While disappointed there was no cheesecake, Tabitha the owner encouraged me to come back on a particular day to retrieve it. She was also very attentive to our needs and she even spent time chatting with us about business. I would highly recommend and return to this new establishment.
Excellent cupcakes! Great mix of not to fancy with that homemade touch, warm and welcoming staff with the best banana pudding you'll ever experience!!!
Delicious sweets! The brownies are big and fudge-y , banana pudding tastes better than home made and the macarons are as tasty as they are pretty. ( lemon, coconut, Oreo, strawberry).
I’m must say the Banana pudding is really good. I also had a strawberry shortcake cupcake which was really good but I forgot to take a picture of it.
I picked up a couple of things to try from Gatisonella Bakery across from West Haven's best dry-cleaner ?. The chocolate brownie was very good (haven't tried the chocolate cupcake yet) but I LOVE the lemon cupcake! The cake is lusciously lemon and the frosting is perfect- not too sweet, great balance in flavor and texture. I'll be back and definitely recommend it to others.
Loading...