I’m visiting from out of town. I looked up Andy’s Pizza on Google decided to call and place an order and one of the employees. (Allison) answer the phone. I asked her a few questions and she rudely hung up in my face. She didn’t answer the phone anymore. I do not recommend anyone to shop at this place if the customer service is gonna be this horrible.
Service: 1
john bourgeois
I came here with an open mind because I was walking by and just happened to notice this place. Usually I check reviews before I go somewhere. Not that this woulda made a difference. Very disappointed in initial walk in. I had never been her before and the servers? Up front seemed surprised. Wanted a slice of pizza and a beer. Server kinda thought it was funny I missed 2 slices amd and a beer special by 5 min. Not helpful and confusing when I asked if I could still get a slice and a beer. Then it made a difference whether is was to eat in or to go. Said I had to order at the bar in which every seat was full and no space to order. Tired of typing but my first time here sucked and if you are not a local or in a group stay away. And I was thinking of getting an apartment around here. Very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Al K
Got the special 2 slices and a drink for $11. Pizza was delicious and it came with fresh Parmesan and peppers. I craved it later that night too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Evan Moxley
Decent but not a lot of food for the price
Aman Kansagra
Great ny style pizza. I ordered well done and that's how I got it. Half street hefeweizen was too good.
The staff was so helpful and quick, and the pizza we ordered was delivered hot, crispy, and delicious! Wonderful, friendly customer service and the best pizza in DC---would definitely order again. :-)
Susan W.
Hands down, one of the best pizzas in DC. Their pies are massive and a great value, especially for DC and Navy Yard. I normally don't care for pizza crusts, but I ate every last bit of these. Love the casual sports bar vibe too. Great for groups!
Sean Munkel
Feels like they're super proud of their pizza here. I don't often see restaurants advertise their dough fermentation strategy on their menu. Pie came out on a cooling rack stacked on a normal pizza serving pan, probably to keep the crust crispy.The New Haven levels of char aren't my favorite, but this stacks up with any of the pies I've had in that area.
Cameron Sterrett
Phenomenal New York style pizza, can see why it's award winning. Pricey definitely but you get what you pay for.
Cool beer house and pizza joint in Navy Yard. I recommend buying a whole pizza and keep the leftovers..fresh and much better price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mallory Hedquist
The pizza was just okay but the beer was great! Service was awesome.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Tastefully Done
The pizza was mid at best. It's not worth the $59 + 18% gratuity. The wings were gross. They were supposed to be Buffalo wings. They were pale pink, barely done, no Buffalo sauce, and definitely not crispy. I could have gotten sick. I tried calling but could only leave a message, and no one has returned my call. STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE , go to &pizza across the street. I wish I had seen & Pizza first. A waste of my hard earned money!! -1 ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
oldies music
Not worth the $70 + 18%tip. I won't be going back. Wings free bland no Buffalo sauce in sight fries had no salt although I asked for salt. Fries were frozen fries Not good quality. The only thing I liked was the thin crest, but it was soggy.Parking: Non existent
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Anthony R.
Never order to go from here. When ordering to go the food is never ready on time. I don't think they match how busy they are in the bar and it just results in long wait times.
I’m visiting from out of town. I looked up Andy’s Pizza on Google decided to call and place an order and one of the employees. (Allison) answer the phone. I asked her a few questions and she rudely hung up in my face. She didn’t answer the phone anymore. I do not recommend anyone to shop at this place if the customer service is gonna be this horrible.
Service: 1
I came here with an open mind because I was walking by and just happened to notice this place. Usually I check reviews before I go somewhere. Not that this woulda made a difference. Very disappointed in initial walk in. I had never been her before and the servers? Up front seemed surprised. Wanted a slice of pizza and a beer. Server kinda thought it was funny I missed 2 slices amd and a beer special by 5 min. Not helpful and confusing when I asked if I could still get a slice and a beer. Then it made a difference whether is was to eat in or to go. Said I had to order at the bar in which every seat was full and no space to order. Tired of typing but my first time here sucked and if you are not a local or in a group stay away. And I was thinking of getting an apartment around here. Very disappointed.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Got the special 2 slices and a drink for $11. Pizza was delicious and it came with fresh Parmesan and peppers. I craved it later that night too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Decent but not a lot of food for the price
Great ny style pizza. I ordered well done and that's how I got it. Half street hefeweizen was too good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Whole Vegan Margherita Pizza, Mushrooms Pizza
The staff was so helpful and quick, and the pizza we ordered was delivered hot, crispy, and delicious! Wonderful, friendly customer service and the best pizza in DC---would definitely order again. :-)
Hands down, one of the best pizzas in DC. Their pies are massive and a great value, especially for DC and Navy Yard. I normally don't care for pizza crusts, but I ate every last bit of these. Love the casual sports bar vibe too. Great for groups!
Feels like they're super proud of their pizza here. I don't often see restaurants advertise their dough fermentation strategy on their menu. Pie came out on a cooling rack stacked on a normal pizza serving pan, probably to keep the crust crispy.The New Haven levels of char aren't my favorite, but this stacks up with any of the pies I've had in that area.
Phenomenal New York style pizza, can see why it's award winning. Pricey definitely but you get what you pay for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have the slowest service ever omg…
Restaurantji Recommends
Cool beer house and pizza joint in Navy Yard. I recommend buying a whole pizza and keep the leftovers..fresh and much better price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
The pizza was just okay but the beer was great! Service was awesome.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
The pizza was mid at best. It's not worth the $59 + 18% gratuity. The wings were gross. They were supposed to be Buffalo wings. They were pale pink, barely done, no Buffalo sauce, and definitely not crispy. I could have gotten sick. I tried calling but could only leave a message, and no one has returned my call. STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE , go to &pizza across the street. I wish I had seen & Pizza first. A waste of my hard earned money!! -1 ?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Not worth the $70 + 18%tip. I won't be going back. Wings free bland no Buffalo sauce in sight fries had no salt although I asked for salt. Fries were frozen fries Not good quality. The only thing I liked was the thin crest, but it was soggy.Parking: Non existent
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Never order to go from here. When ordering to go the food is never ready on time. I don't think they match how busy they are in the bar and it just results in long wait times.