Stoltzfus BBQ

$$ • Farmers Market, Barbecue, Barbeque

701 N Broad St, Middletown
(302) 285-0866


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Stoltzfus BBQ

THE GOOD The business is run by the Amish community. Such wonderful, kind, smiling, friendly, helpful people. So nice and refreshing to do business with them. The food is plentiful in variety from raw cuts for home cooking, to freshly made fried chicken, ribs, sides, etc. It looks clean. THE BAD The BBQ place here is inside the Country Market in Middletown... fine, but so, so, so, so busy/packed every time I have been (which really takes away the fun of exploring). They're full review
Stopped by on the weekend since they were having a PIG roast. We ordered a couple of the pulled pork sliders. We requested the sauce on the side. Portion sizes of the sliders are a little on the small side, but decent for a snack. Pork is tender and flavorful. I like their BBQ sauce, but it has a heavy hint of mustard so IF you don't like mustard then it might not be to your liking. Prices have gone up. I remember when sliders used to be under $2. Sliders are now double that full review

When visiting my family, I decided to go out here. I loved it! There's a handful of different vendors-- a butcher, dairy, flowers, produce, BBQ. All the food I bought was delicious and fresh. I went on Thursday and it wasn't too busy versus the busy weekend days. With covid going on I felt better going on Thursday. Most of the workers wore masks. I didn't like that some of them weren't wearing them. Made me really uncomfortable.

More Reviews(39)


Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 8:30AM - 6PM
Friday 8:30AM - 7PM
Saturday 8:30AM - 4PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.