Papa Johns Pizza

$ • Pizza

386 E Main St, Middletown
(302) 449-2188


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Papa John's

Believe it or not the football pizza comes uncut!? On top of that the driver achieved some g force while driving here, so pizza looked very discombobulated. This caused us to use our hand like animals!??. Overall good experience but would not recommend.

This place is a solid 4.. possibly 4.5 stars.The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars was because the girl couldn't figure out how to put the order in... so I ended up doing it myself online. Still she was very friendly.The crew here look like they work together very well. They're fast and efficient.Oh.. lastly, my pie came out a bit thin. I've had Papa Johns in the past, and I've never gotten a pizza that was close to paper thin. Too thin to eat without folding it.. full review
I didn't order pizza, which explains why my order was not wrong, but I ordered pizza a couple days ago at around 2:30... I do have some complaints, however:1.) When I first ordered for delivery, for about 45 minutes, it showed up as "ESTIMATED DELIVERY TIME: NOT AVAILABLE", so I tried calling but apparently they were "closed" despite the delivery time being between the time I ordered.2.) After 45 minutes of waiting for the delivery time to show up, it showed as 36 minutes full review

More Reviews(69)


Monday 11AM - 11PM
Tuesday 11AM - 11PM
Wednesday 11AM - 11PM
Thursday 11AM - 11PM
Friday 11AM - 12AM
Saturday 11AM - 12AM
Sunday 11AM - 10PM