11 Best Italian Restaurants near Millsboro

“My wife and I had dinner on Friday night. We did have reservations and glad we did because it was packed. I had the seafood diavolo and my wife had chicken cacciatore. Food was hot, perfectly done, and great presentation. Portions are generous. The past is freshly made and cooked perfectly!! Enjoyed talking with Vincenzo, the owner. We will return.“

“Great food and excellent service.“

“We just stopped in here after a little vacation in Ocean City. Such great prices and we haven’t been treated with such kindness and service at any restaurants like this in years. We will definitely be coming back for family meals!“

“If you haven't tried Serendipity yet, you’re missing out! The atmosphere is truly wonderful—we sat on the deck overlooking the bay, and it was just perfect. The wait staff was equally amazing. Though I didn’t catch our server's name, she worked on Friday night, September 6th, and went above and beyond by helping my husband, who had recently broken his hip, get comfortably seated on the deck and back inside when we were done.

A special shout-out to the kitchen staff for their thoughtful touch—they boxed up our stromboli and even cut a little spot out for the marinara sauce. Speaking of the sauce, it was so thick and delicious that we spooned it onto our stromboli with a fork—without spilling a drop!

And the stromboli? Absolutely incredible. It was so good, I ended up writing a poem about it! It easily serves three people, but trust me, order a whole one for yourself so you can enjoy leftovers. You won’t regret it!

Ode to the Perfect Stromboli

In the oven, warm and bright,
Lies a stromboli, pure delight,
Golden crust with edges curled,
A savory dream, a doughy world.

Inside, cheese melts, gooey bliss,
Pepperoni brings its spicy kiss,
Folded layers, tucked with care,
A feast of flavors, rich and rare.

The steam escapes with a gentle sigh,
As mozzarella strings wave goodbye,
Each bite a burst of dough and spice,
Oh, Stromboli, you're beyond nice.

With every crunch, the soul ignites,
Tomato sauce in perfect bites,
No sandwich, pizza, roll can be
As perfect as this Stromboli.

So raise a slice, and take a cheer,
For this creation, oh so dear,
A meal, a joy, a masterpiece,
This stromboli brings pure peace!“

“Best pizza around! Delicious sauce, fresh toppings, friendly service and they deliver. I love Rocky's!“

“Awesome thick Sicilian pizza! We got delivery door dash and it was finally like my back home pizza (Pittsburgh PA)“

“If you are a lover of fine food, excellent wine and amazing music, I highly recommend this one of a kind experience.“

“Visited the area and was not well-versed in the food scenery in the area. Stumbled upon Pizza Place and it ended up being a really great experience. While it is a little jarring walking in and not knowing what to do, you are greeted by friendly staff and able to seat yourself in any booth/table. The service was really the outstanding factor of this place. Super friendly, attentive, and even servers who didn’t serve you come by and check in. Additionally, they are honest and great at giving recommendations. Aside from their amazing service, the food was quite good for a small pizza place. I thoroughly enjoyed my pizza and the portions are huge!“

“One of our food items was wrong, ordered on line, thinking it got screwed up by the on line system, not the fault of 4 Brothers, but they immediately sent out the correct item. Really good to deal with, food was really good. Thanks!“

“I ordered a meatball Stromboli, garlic bread and 3 pieces of tiramisu....AN HOUR AND A HALF LATER, the driver REDELIVERS a meatball stromboli that they attempted to deliver to a wrong address. The bag kept it warmISH but the cheese had resolidified....the garlic bread didn't share the same fate.... cold and hard, it was inedible...and the 3 pieces of tiramisu are nowhere to be found! Its now been 30 minutes since I called them for the 3rs time..1st to order, 2nd to adk about my order because it had been over an hour and was told that they brought it here and when I told them my address they realized they brought it to the wrong place, and then 30 minutes after then later the Stromboli and garlic bread arrived and I called for the third time to tell them that I was still missing part of my order because the tiramisu didn't arrive.... 35 minutes later the delivery driver returned with three tiramisu.... it took 3 calls and over 2 hours to get my order. I AM SUPER DISAPPOINTED!! I ranted and ranted about how amazing the food was there and ended up with mud on my face....because this is what I got after raving and raving about them. They made me look like an absolute fool when I ordered from there tonight! not to mention there was absolutely no offer of a discount of any kind so I spent $45 for inedible garlic bread a cold stromboli and 2 or the three tiramisu were still frozen solid. SMDH.“

“Take it from a North Jersey guy; the best pizza I've tried in Slower Lower. Specialty pizzas are great too. Try the cheesesteak pie or Grandma pie. Awesome sandwiches also, and the Texas fries are cheesy-bacony goodness.“