8 Best Italian Restaurants in Cape May

Tisha's Fine Dining American • $$
322 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Cape May Scallops with Risotto
New England Clam Chowder
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Cajun Fried Oysters
Mushroom Risotto
Filet Au Poivre
Crab Cake Tacos
Seafood Risotto
Scallop Risotto
Halibut Special

“I really don't leave reviews very often, but this was one of the best meals I have ever had, and I don’t say that lightly. Every single thing we had was incredible; the calamari was the best I’ve ever had, and the seafood risotto and homemade key lime pie was to die for. I would come here every single time I come to Cape May from now on. Our server, Dajan, was excellent as well and was extremely professional. My girlfriend and I couldn’t celebrate together for Valentine’s Day because I had covid, so today was the day we could finally celebrate together down at the shore and it was perfect. 10/10 would recommend.“

4.5 Superb750 Reviews
Mario's Pizza And Italian Eatery Pizza • $
315 Ocean St Unit # 7, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheesesteak

“The food was exceptionally good. Or the ingredients of the pizza were. But the crust was like a cracker and I have had gluten free pizza at 5 placesI like that it was "gluten free" . But it was not really. True Gluten free for Celiacs has pizza or whatever in a dedicated oven.It was not. The pizza itself was Gluten free. But it was made with Glutinous pizza. My husband is Celiac and broke out. Because it was not made in a dedicated pizza oven.The parking was not free like they advertised.It was 8.00 and there was no bathroom. You had to go across the parking lot not close. But it was close to the ferry. For some reason I am not able to post pictures.“

4.3 Superb68 Reviews
North Cape May Shopping Center Italian • $
3860 Bayshore Rd, Cape May

“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.“

4.3 Superb22 Reviews
Panico's Bistro Italian • $$
422 Broadway, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Bruschetta and Burrata Appetizers
Tortellini and Italian Sausage
Fig and Goat Cheese Salad
Bourbon Toffee Cake
Three Cheese Chicken
Chicken Parm Strips
Prosciutto Pizza
Battered Jersey
Eggplant Pesto
Pork Osso Buco

“Food was very good overall. I had Mediterranean Salmon Special. Wife had FriedVeal Cutlet Special which she felt had too much breading on it but veal itself was very good. Service was excellent as usual. We were surprised at the menu prices. The online menu prices in many cases were not at all like the actual restaurant menu. Not sure how old the online prices were but suggest that the new menu be added to the online and scrap the old one. Overall we did enjoy and will be back.“

4 Good476 Reviews
Andrea Trattoria Italiana Italian • $$$
412 Bank St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Alla Carte Menu
Caesar Salad
Risotto
Burrata
Salads

“We were a walk-in. Hostess was super friendly and welcoming. Our server, Edgar, was excellent. He offered us the specials right away and was very attentive. amazing service! you don’t get that just anywhere anymore. I commend him and the rest of the staff. Food was delicious. Ambiance was beautifully decorated. This restaurant was a Breath of fresh air.(From Toms River,NJ)“

4 Good64 Reviews
Cappy's Seaside Pizza & Steaks Pizza • $
1432 Texas Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Cheesesteak
Italian Wrap
Wings
Cappy

“This is our preferred Local "Pizza Parlor" as we say in South Jersey. Quality Pizzas with a wide variety of Toppings, tasty Appetizers and some of the best Salads you can get in a Pizzaria... but they keep where they buy their Lettuce a secret! The friendly Staff know like Family since we get Take-out there so regularly.“

4 Good23 Reviews
Jojo Pizza Pizza • $
507 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Margherita White Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Plain Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Fries
Pizza Steak
House Salad
Onion Rings

“Ordered food here on Christmas Eve! First thank you for being open and very friendly. Ordered a bunch of stuff White Pizza, asked for no garlic. I can't tell you how many times other places have screwed this up. These guys got it RIGHT!!! And the pizza was delicious. Chicken cutlet sandwich was awesome, my sons chicken fingers were great. Caesar salad was fine, I know the croutons weren't homemade but they were addictive. Overall great experience, and they were very nice. Thank you!“

3.8 Good40 Reviews
Blue Moon Pizza Pizza • $
425 Beach Ave #25, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Parm Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Blue Moon Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Antipasto Salad
Spinach Pizza
Pizza Slice
Cheesesteak
Greek Salad

“This place stands out amongst any pizza sandwich shops anywhere in cae may period. The pizza's are hot fresh and the way you want them. I asked for a thin crust Florence pizza that's a white pie with spinach and mozzarella and ricotta cheeses and got such fulfillment in every bite from the crispy crust to the toppingsthe spinach and plenty of ricitta and mozzarella cheeses. ..Where can you get that without saying extra cheese?? Thre service was a very humbled experience. Atmosphere was very good the staff is attentive to what you wanted and without fail ..it was a great experience I will return again soon. They aim to please here open everyday till 10pm you can't beat that anywhere. Blue moon is the best pizza anywhere ..order a hot pie and enjoy it from your first till your last bite my guest and I enjoyed the time spent , and yes they have hot drinks image that??? Yes the ocoffee & tea are hot ? .kiddos Blue moon you made a believer in me as well as my quest. We will be back sooner than you think.Don't take me word just try them out the staff will make you believe there's a better place and it's in Cape May City. 425 Beach ave....Vegetarian options: The menu don't say enough about what you can see or want in PiersonDietary restrictions: Ask them about any dietary restriction they will cater to your needs of at all possible.“

3.8 Good53 Reviews
Loading...

Taste More Cuisines In Cape May

map Map