Home
NJ
Cape May
Pizza Restaurants

10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cape May

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Pizza Restaurants in Cape May.

Showing 10 of 10 restaurants

Pizza · $
1 Blue Moon Pizza

4.3 Superb 388 Reviews

425 Beach Avenue Suite 25, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Chicken Parm Pizza
- Chicken Tenders
- Grilled Chicken
“the calzones are fantastic!!”
Menu Order
Bar & Grill · $
2 C-View Inn

4.4 Superb 2,142 Reviews

1380 Washington Street, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Garlic Honey Hot Wings on Left and Garlic Parm on Right
- Manhattan Clam Chowder
- Cheesesteak Sandwich
- C View Steak Sandwich
“Always a fun time at CView! Great, casual atmosphere with good food. Brianna is a fantastic bartender!”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
3 Mario's Pizza And Italian Eatery

4.3 Superb 275 Reviews

315 Ocean Street Unit 7, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Neapolitan Margherita Pizza
- 14 Nonnas Focaccia 8 Slices
- Large Plain Cheese Pizza
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
“I ordered a veggie burger & sweet potato fries, pretty much my go-to at a pizza place. It was tasty but better than anywhere else because of the experience. I saw you give away food to someone in need, I saw you show compassion & kindness. I will support this business in the future! “On the way to Cape May” ❤️”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
4 Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.9 Good 185 Reviews

1216 NJ-109, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cheese Pizza by the Slice
- Plain Cheese Pizza
- Meat Lovers Pizza
- French Fries
“First time customers and could not be happier. Wow, just Wow...... this will be a go to place going forward when we are down the shore”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
5 Jojo Pizza

3.7 Good 157 Reviews

507 Washington Street, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Margherita White Pizza
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Plain Pizza Slice
- Verde White Pizza
“The pizza here was very good! These are huge slices! My wife and I got the meat, and the spinach pizza slices! The fellas tossed them in the oven for us and cooked them up to perfection! If you’re craving a slice like I was on the Washington Mall! Make sure to stop by and get a slice here! Oh yeah, we also got a lemonade to share! It was prepped to perfection as well! Equally portioned and not sugary like you can get at other places! All in all! 5/5 here!”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
6 Panico's Bistro

4.1 Good 948 Reviews

422 Broadway, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Bruschetta and Burrata Appetizers
- Spicy Broccoli Rabe and Sausage
- Tortellini and Italian Sausage
- Fig and Goat Cheese Salad
“My husband and I come to Cape May every year for our anniversary we have our favorite places that we love to visit this was our first visit to Pacino's bistro and we went back the night after to pick up again!!! The food was phenomenal and the wait staff were very hard working and friendly!!! I am server myself and this not an easy job but they were excellent. The ambiance in restaurant made the experience that much better. Cannot say enough good things about this establishment!”
Menu Order
Deli · $
7 Erma Deli & Pizzeria

4.0 Good 269 Reviews

635 Breakwater Road, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Slice of Plain Pizza
- Breakfast Sandwiches
- Chicken Tenders
- Cheese Steak
“We love Erma’s. We’ve had breakfast, lunch, and dinner meals there. The food has always been very good. And the Staff is very friendly.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
8 North Cape May Shopping Center

4.0 Good 105 Reviews

3860 Bayshore Road, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“New air conditioning makes this laundry mat much eiser to handle in the summer. Just got 2 new over sized washers to do extra large quilts or your animals bedding. Cheaper then any other laundry mats in area and staff is even friendlier then other laundry mats. I hate going to laundry mat but staff makes it more pleasant.”
Menu
Grills · $
9 Snack Shack

3.3 Good 24 Reviews

100 Beach Avenue, Cape May
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“We visited today first day of the 2025 season. The atmosphere is awesome beach sand with tables and umbrellas, Large fire pits and a large outdoor bar. The weather was 65 and partly cloudy . The host was friendly and welcoming made us feel right at home. Our waiter Jamie was friendly, accommodating and couldn’t do enough for us. He made us laugh and we never felt rushed his personality is on par! We had fried shrimp with sauces, and fried Mac and cheese balls with remoulade sauce and some cocktails. Everything was delicious. Can’t wait to come back later in the summer!”
Menu
Family · $$
10 Boiler Room at Congress Hall

3.8 Good 173 Reviews

200 Congress Place, Cape May
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Arugula and Prosciutto Large Pizza
- Truffle Parmesan Fries
- Meatball Appetizer
- 7 Margarita Pizza
“If you’re looking for Cape May’s hottest subterranean hotspot, look no further than The Boiler Room. This place has everything: wood-fired pizza, Caesar salads that slap, neon lights, exposed brick, and a sound system that’ll knock your Birkenstocks off. And the staff? Honey. First, let’s talk about Matt, the food and beverage manager. He’s like the Wizard of Oz behind the curtain, pulling levers of flavor and hospitality. Ever had a martini that made you cry from joy? You will. Now add Johnny and Kyle behind the bar—Cape May’s dynamic duo. They pour, they shake, they stir, and they SERVE. Watching them in action is like seeing a choreographed dance, except everyone gets a drink at the end. Now let’s get into the pizza. This pizza? This pizza is like if Naples and Brooklyn had a baby that went to culinary school in Rome. It’s crispy, chewy, saucy perfection. And don’t even get me started on the Caesar salad—it’s crunchy, briny, creamy, and anchovy-whispered. I’d write it a love letter and send it first class. But that’s not all. When the sun goes down, this place transforms. The Boiler Room becomes an underground concert hall of dreams. The live bands? They funk, boogie, and rock ‘n’ roll like it’s their job (because it is). Think Parliament meets Tom Petty in a dance-off judged by Prince. They groove party anthems and timeless classics that’ll have you screaming, “This is MY SONG!” while you dance like it’s 1999. The Boiler Room has everything: brick oven dreams, Caesar epiphanies, killer cocktails, craft beers, sultry lighting, beautiful people, bar legends, and music that hits like a vintage disco ball to the soul. So if you’re in Cape May and you’re not at the Boiler Room, what are you even doing with your life? Sent from my iPhone”
Menu