12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rehoboth Beach

“Although literally just steps off of Wilmington Avenue, with its entrance on 1st Street, this place is somehow a bit hidden, making it all the more of a gem. A casual and fun environment (I mean the men's room walls are covered in Bruce Lee posters!) with a really lively and inviting staff, is complemented by some truly amazing Italian cuisine. Everyone raves about their pizzas, but there's also meatball, soup, a pair of salads and a pair of pastas that isn't to be missed. The Cacio e Pepe may be the best in class, and I've sampled plenty. I'll definitely be adding this to my "must eat at" list when in Rehoboth!“

“Great service great pizza“

“Great cheesesteak subs! Cash only. Very small seating area with a couple of pinballs and arcade games.“

“We enjoyed our pizza as an evening treat. Great staff and great food!“

“Finally got a chance to try the pizza here and was not disappointed. Easy to order online. Pizza was ready when they said it would be. Quick and easy pickup. We had the meatball pizza and added onions. It was the perfect size for two people. Pizza was thin with a good crust (think Neapolitan style) with just the right amount of toppings. Right amount of flop when picking up a slice. I would definitely order from them again.“

“So good we had to come back a second night for another slice! Fresh and crispy with good ingredients! Next time I need to try a grinder! Keep up the good work!“

“Lots of great, covered outdoor seating here, which was perfect for our dog, who was also given a bowl of water. There were things to keep our children occupied as well, like chalk and magnetic drawing boards, and the beer and food from the pizza and wing food truck was great. Very cyclist friendly too! Off the beaten path just a bit, but a great spot!“

“Grotto Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers! The moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a great meal. Their signature swirl pizza is not only unique but incredibly delicious, with a perfect blend of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and a crispy crust that hits all the right notes. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic favorites to creative specialty pizzas, ensuring there's something for everyone.

The staff at Grotto Pizza are friendly and efficient, making the dining experience even better. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or ordering for delivery, the quality is consistently top-notch. It’s a great spot for families, friends, or anyone craving a satisfying, flavorful pizza. Five stars!“

“Grotto’s Pizza is the best! We ate here every time we went to the beach when I was growing up and we still eat here a bunch of times every summer. I’ll never get tired of their pizza. They also have good pasta and salads. Servers are always very sweet and friendly.

Kid-friendliness: Pretty kid friendly - always see families eating here, and they provide kids menus with crayons.“

“Everything delicious. Chocolate chip cookies best ever. Tiramisu and cheesecake so good. Nice staff. Can’t wait to come back here!“

“We decided to stop by Dogfish Head for lunch after leaving Ocean City, Maryland, and it turned out to be a fantastic choice! I ordered the "Old Man and the Sea," a delicious and creative take on a white pizza with a delightful Delaware/Maryland crab twist. My husband went for the Fried Chicken Sandwich, which was huge and packed with flavor. We sat at the bar, where the service was quick and friendly. The entire menu looked amazing, and all the dishes coming out of the kitchen were tempting. Highly recommend this spot—we’ll definitely be back next time we're in the area!“