20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Milton

“If you’re anywhere near Milton, Delaware, do yourself a favor and head straight to Miltonian Pizzeria & Wing House – this place is an absolute standout! We’ve been going for the last few months and it never disappoints. The menu is expansive and has something for everyone: from classic and specialty pizzas to strombolis, calzones, subs, pastas, burgers, salads, and more. It’s the kind of spot where you can satisfy any craving without ever getting bored. But let’s talk about what really sets them apart – their incredible variety of wing sauces! These aren’t your standard buffalo or BBQ; they’ve got unique, house-made options crafted by a classically trained chef, like the fiery Kamikaze, the bold Killer, sweet Honey BBQ, Bee Sting, and so many others. Every sauce is packed with flavor, perfectly coating juicy, crispy wings that are always cooked to perfection. I could eat these wings every day and never tire of trying new combinations – they’re that addictive! The pizzas are no slouch either. The plain cheese pizza is pure comfort food bliss: fresh dough, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese in perfect harmony. And the white pizza? Wow – creamy ricotta, garlic, and mozzarella that melts in your mouth. Both were absolutely amazing on my last visit, with generous portions and that homemade touch that beats any chain hands down. On top of the fantastic food, the staff is always so friendly and nice. They make you feel like family from the moment you walk in – attentive service, quick takeout, and a welcoming vibe that keeps me coming back. Miltonian is hands-down one of the best spots in Sussex County. Highly recommend – you won’t be disappointed!“

“Stumbled upon this place when I was looking for something to eat. So glad we ordered from here the pizza was awesome, the wings were great and flavorful, the onion rings were amazing. Will be back for sure when I'm back down this way“

“Best quality food in town! (and Im very picky). Good selection of craft beers, too. The owner is friendly and fun, and takes the time to chat if you have any questions.“

“honestly it's my favorite pizza place probably ever 🤣 the bougie cheese is to DIE for! also the antipasto salad is absolute perfection ❤️ I never leave reviews but I had to do this one because everyone needs to try this place! ❣️“

“I’ve been going to them for years super nice people. Food is always quality and tasty and hot before I move down here. My parents were here in elderly and I used to call them in a pizza every once in a while from Philly and they were all super nice and made sure that they got the food“

“Always great food never have had anything I was not beyond happy with“

“Always love pizza hut, definitely the best bang for your buck..only thing I ask is to cook the pizza an Xtra minute or two you need that pan crust to be golden brown and crusty good...keep up the good work and I will always order from you!“

“We're new to this area and tried them for the first time yesterday. We picked up a very nice pizza. They were jammed but it was prepared well and on time. A little pricy though. It was $28 and a similar pizza where we lived before would have been $22.“

“The Veggie pizza was not only amazing, but the freakin crust was as well!!! Also got 3 burgers, wow, great!! Even the Maryland crab soup was done right, great tasting!! And this was all carry out, you know inside dining must be incredible...
this place blows the others away,“

“Great food. Big portions. Great prices. Staff is great. Delicious!!!!!“

“Pat's is really great! The staff there is always friendly and they've got delicious pizza, pasta, and subs. Prices are reasonable. A really solid spot!“

“Take it from a North Jersey guy; the best pizza I've tried in Slower Lower. Specialty pizzas are great too. Try the cheesesteak pie or Grandma pie. Awesome sandwiches also, and the Texas fries are cheesy-bacony goodness.“

“Wonderful people. Every one of them!! Food is great and always on point.“

“best food and drinks . child friendly . fast delivery . clean atmosphere . best palace .“

“I ordered a meatball Stromboli, garlic bread and 3 pieces of tiramisu....AN HOUR AND A HALF LATER, the driver REDELIVERS a meatball stromboli that they attempted to deliver to a wrong address. The bag kept it warmISH but the cheese had resolidified....the garlic bread didn't share the same fate.... cold and hard, it was inedible...and the 3 pieces of tiramisu are nowhere to be found! Its now been 30 minutes since I called them for the 3rs time..1st to order, 2nd to adk about my order because it had been over an hour and was told that they brought it here and when I told them my address they realized they brought it to the wrong place, and then 30 minutes after then later the Stromboli and garlic bread arrived and I called for the third time to tell them that I was still missing part of my order because the tiramisu didn't arrive.... 35 minutes later the delivery driver returned with three tiramisu.... it took 3 calls and over 2 hours to get my order. I AM SUPER DISAPPOINTED!! I ranted and ranted about how amazing the food was there and ended up with mud on my face....because this is what I got after raving and raving about them. They made me look like an absolute fool when I ordered from there tonight! not to mention there was absolutely no offer of a discount of any kind so I spent $45 for inedible garlic bread a cold stromboli and 2 or the three tiramisu were still frozen solid. SMDH.“

“If you are a lover of fine food, excellent wine and amazing music, I highly recommend this one of a kind experience.“

“My bother ordered a pizza and I went to pickup for him since he just had knee surgery. It smelled delicious so I decided to get a pizza too. Very good pizza!“

“These guys are fantastic. I called them last minute for a church event. They were accommodating, fast, professional, courteous and cost effective. The manager was a gem, the lady at the counter was amazing. There isn't enough room or adjectives for me to edify these folks enough, I don't know if all little Caesars are like this one, but this one is the only one I need. We'll done folks.“

“Tonight, my husband and I tried a new place—Pizza King—completely on a whim. We had no idea it even existed until we walked out of Walmart, got in the car, and I happened to glance across the shopping center. I saw the sign and said, “Let’s give that place a shot!”

From the outside, it’s easy to miss, but once we walked in, I was pleasantly surprised. The decor matched the vibe: super relaxed, a little cozy, and clearly a place where people come to unwind. Patrons were chatting with each other across tables—it had that small-town, family-friendly energy that I love.

There was a seat yourself sign up front, though a waitress moved it as we walked in. I wasn’t sure what that meant anymore, so I asked and she let us know that we could sit at any table, just not the booths (totally fine!). She even brought over a high chair for our little one right away, though we quickly found out it was broken—thankfully, there was another nearby that worked.

The menu is surprisingly affordable, especially considering how good the food was. I ordered the Crabby Flatbread—basically a crab dip spread over flatbread with Chesapeake seasoning—for only $10.99. It was so good. I also got a $2.50 side salad, which came in a teeny tiny bowl—so small that there was no way to add dressing without it overflowing. I ended up dumping it into my food basket to make it work. (They meant “side salad” in the most literal way. 😂👌🏼)

The kids’ menu was great too—tons of options, and the first place I’ve seen that actually offers Goldfish crackers as a side. Genius.

Now for the only downside: service was slow. There were only two servers working the entire (pretty packed) restaurant, and it definitely showed. That said, our waitress was sweet, bubbly, and kept a great attitude the whole time. She really made the experience better just by being kind and checking in with us when she could. We had to wait a while for the check and box at the end, and our 16-month-old was definitely done by that point (cue the screeches), but we made it through.

Heads up: you pay at the register, not at your table.

All in all, it was a really chill spot with better food than expected and a kind staff doing their best under pressure. I’d go back—maybe just not when the place is slammed.“

“Great food and excellent service.“