Papa Johns Pizza

181 E Main St, Newark
(302) 738-1777

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kevin Osorio

Worst pizza ever

aisha hadeli

this place is just straight up hell, i mean you can tell by the reviews, the management is horrible too i don’t know what curse this place has

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

J Johnson

Manager is horrible. Can barely understand her and this store is run horribly

R_e_dux

Ordered a late pizza through DoorDash, and some cruel sod cut my two pizzas into 1/9 cubic pieces??? I didn’t even know that was possible, but apparently it is. Ruined my night and squandered a potential customer. Hope whoever cut my pizza felt good about that and I also hope they get fired.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

jeffery houser

Fast service placed my order for later pick up it was ready an hot.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

KC G

Don't believe the hype they close early they're not open till 3:00 went there two times were closed early were closed at 2:00 a.m. what's the point of advertising that you're closed at 3:00 when you're actually closed at 2:00 just be honest don't be a dummy

Nick H

I don't think I've had worse pizza or worse service at a pizza place. The entire bottom of the pizza was charcoal. Never will return here.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nikita Lee

💔🤬😡

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dzzy Way

Papa John’s on E Main used to be one of my favorite pizza places. The last three times I’ve ordered from them, it has been a complete nightmare. At first it was the customer service but since my pizza was good, I shrugged it off. The most recent order was sent out even though the pizza collapsed out of the oven. It arrived completely inedible. The cheese was separated from the crust and there were no toppings as were ordered. Completely unacceptable.

Parker Dunson

The people working lied to my face about a menu change to cover up an input mistake. Terrible service

Parag Gokhale

Top notch service! Small store!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diego Hernandez

Truly unbelievable how the staff is. I understand working food service on a college campus must be a nightmare but the register workers is terrible. She makes it so clear how much she hates the customers and her job. And they’re out of half the ingredients 90% of the time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Jorge Vidal

I recently placed a large order from Papa John’s, expecting the usual quality, but was seriously disappointed. I ordered an XL All-Meat Pizza, an XL Fiery Buffalo Chicken, and two Large BBQ Chicken & Bacon pizzas.

The BBQ Chicken & Bacon pizzas were a letdown—the chicken looked like breaded bits instead of real chicken, and the bacon was practically nonexistent. Then, for the XL Fiery Buffalo Chicken, they ran out of chicken and they called me to ask for a sub and they said that they can replace it with beef but didn't mentioned that was ground beef.

To top it all off, none of the pizzas came with the signature garlic butter sauce or pepperoncini—which is part of what makes Papa John’s stand out.

Look at the pictures and be the judge.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nikhil Maroli

The worst place in the main street, ordered two pizza with multiple toppings. Chicken was missing as one of the topping and i dont get taste of any other cheeze or toppings other than tomato, msuhroom and olives. When i enter the store, none of them bother to greet or look at us, there was two indians at the counter, they dont even care or bother about customer. when i asked for my order they were like "WHAT", . may be store manageer need to teach them how to greet customer or replce. I writing this because this is such a frustrating moment as i order the pizza for the party.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

JJ F

used to be a lot better .. had really gotten bad the past couple months

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...