20 Best Italian Restaurants near Selbyville

“We absolutely love this place! After moving here, it took us a while to find an Italian place we really enjoyed. We found Mio’s and have been thrilled ever since. The food and service are always great, even on hectic nights the servers and expeditors are always friendly and accommodating. Happy hour and lunch offer amazing deals and we enjoy the live music during happy hours (Bob Elliot has been a favorite!). And I promise, it’s totally worth it to get extra bread!!“

“Great place to have a private gathering. The upstairs venue is set with a stage and side booths. Mio's food is excellent for both buffet or sit down service. The staff are efficient, professional and fun! As a local patron, I feel blessed to have them service our community.“

“Pizza is great. Sussex county doesn’t know how to make pizza generally if you’re used to others. Other places are over rated. Only reason I did 4 stars not 5 is because their prices on specials don’t reflect the prices in the shop. Worker charged us more than what was on their website so double check your bill.“

“Our server, Madison, took on our large party of 14 for a special occasion. From start to finish she made sure the details were seen to despite a full restaurant and a hiccup in seating. She carefully orchestrated each person's meal down to last minute changes and boxed desserts to go. She turned what could've been a disastrous evening into a wonderful and smooth dinner party. Many of our party had never tried Carrabba's and left excited to visit again. Thank you Madison and staff!“

“So glad we decided to try Munchies Grill. We will definitely be back and spreading the word. Delicious food! Classic Cheesesteak was the best Philly Steak down this way...with that Cheese Whiz! Fair prices and fast, friendly delivery!“

“My experience at Sello’s from start to finish was top notch! The ambiance is very inviting with soft lighting & a classy interior design. I dined at the bar where Flip and Megan made our whole experience very enjoyable with their warm and attentive service. They recommended the wood-fired pizza, the Vespa, and a classic glass of Italian red wine. Simply delicious! My brother had the Linguine Fra Diavlo with succulent lobster tail and shrimp. It was outstanding. We finished out the evening with a velvety Tiramisu, and the Bianca Espresso Martini. Julian, the manager, stopped over to chat with us and made us feel like family.“

“Every year when we come to ocean city for vacation, this is the first place we get food from. The chicken wings are my favorite, and the pizza is good too. I hate having to wait a whole year to be able to get their wings again😅“

“Absolutely THE BEST Italian food in the Bethany area. The owner is delightful to talk with, and the place has a cool history as a gas station - of all things. Don't miss this place if you are in the area.

Update: Many years after the review above, Perucci's is in a new location, but the food and service are still the best. Love this place!“

“I had a truly wonderful experience dining here, and I cannot say enough good things about the service, food, and especially our waitress, Anja. From the moment we were seated, she made us feel welcome with her warm personality and genuine smile. Anja was attentive without ever being overbearing, always anticipating our needs and making excellent recommendations from the menu. The food itself was outstanding—beautifully presented, full of flavor, and clearly prepared with care. Every course exceeded expectations, from appetizers to dessert. What really made the evening special, though, was Anja’s professionalism and kindness. She went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. I would highly recommend this restaurant and hope to be served by Anja again.“

“Pizza was OK, nothing spectacular. I ordered the "Jumbo Wings" 7f for $18.00. Before ordering I asked the waitress if they were actually jumbo at $2.57 each. She said yes, so I ordered them. Out of the 7 wings 4 were the size of a pigeon wings and the other 3 were standard size chicken wings. I showed the waitress the small wings and asked her if she thought they were " jumbo". she shrugged me off. The wings were a joke!!!!! Never again!!“

“Great food, great atmosphere and wonderful staff. Check this place out! Order the wings, trust me.“

“A few weeks ago we wanted pizza but the Palace was closed, Sunday. Ordered 2 pies from Papa John's. Very disappointing. Last night I ordered from the Palace. It was excellent as usual. We will never go to Papa John's again“

“We just found Serendipity on a drive around the neighborhood. We love, love, loved it!!! The decor was fabulous and I could not stop finding new things to look at. We did not eat outside because of the weather, but they have two beautiful patios, both with views of the water. We booth ordered chicken Marsala and it was delicious! I highly recommend this restaurant!! ❤️“

“We like to eat here after our daughters Jui Jitsu class on Wednesday nights :-)“

“Just to begin the staff there are extremely friendly. Always show off the orders to me before I take it out to ensure it’s right. The owners are incredible. Super friendly and always going the extra mile to ensure that their regular local customers are taken well care of. I would not doubt for a second that they provide the same service to tourists who visit for vacation during the summer. They are just those kind of people and I hope for the to have continued success!“

“I stayed at the Americana since Sunday and its Thursday Sept 30th and my only regret so far is not having dinner sooner at Flavors of Italy. The Chicken Parmigiana was ambrosial and my waitress was happy and beautiful and I had a perfect "last night of vacation" Dinner! Anyone who complains about Flavors of Italy probably complains about everything.“

“Stopped by to grab lunch with friends on our way to OC Saturday. Food and service were both great!“

“We stopped by Ledo Pizza and left seriously impressed! The pizza was exactly what we were craving—crispy, rectangular slices with that signature sweet sauce and just the right amount of cheese.

We also tried the cheesesteak, and it was just as satisfying. The steak was tender, the roll was fresh, and everything was perfectly seasoned. It was packed with flavor and generously portioned, definitely worth ordering again

The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the service was quick and easy.“

“One of our food items was wrong, ordered on line, thinking it got screwed up by the on line system, not the fault of 4 Brothers, but they immediately sent out the correct item. Really good to deal with, food was really good. Thanks!“

“Best pizza around! Delicious sauce, fresh toppings, friendly service and they deliver. I love Rocky's!“