50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Atlantis

“I called Atlantis Pizzeria in a panic today because our large catering order (from another restaurant) got mixed up. They were immediately willing to help me out and save the day. No questions asked aside from "what do you need? We got this". I will definitely order from them any time I am in the area. Amazing customer service.“

“My son and I had lunch at Mister and it was extraordinary. We started with the Greta salad: the lettuce was fresh and the cucumbers, olives, and cheese were amazing. the dressing was flavorful and it was light and fresh. The margherita pizza was awesome. The crust was extremely crispy and thin and the cheese was perfect too. The basil and tomato sauce finished off the flavor to make this a positive experience. We had the Nutella Pizza and it was the most amazing treat; nutella and an excellent crust that we have never tasted before! Just awesome; We can't wait to return again to experiment a different pizza! return soon.“

“We have been coming for years for your Pizza Rustica. Our disappointment was short lived (you didn’t have it!) as soon as we had your vegetarian pizza. Another amazing treat from you guys. We travel from Delaware via Ft Lauderdale to come here every time we visit Southern Florida. Thank you for your friendly smiles and one of a kind pizza! Five star pizza and five star smiles!“

“Just love this place! Came here for the first time a few weeks ago with a friend and enjoyed a late lunch again today with my husband. You’re welcomed with open arms from the moment you walk in, just sweet, friendly, warm people! Now the pizza, on a whole different level from pizza we have had, and we have had many. They make it just as requested, and we like thin and well done. Freshest ingredients are used and it shows in the flavor! Will be back and back again! Thank you so much for putting your all into this pizza place!!!“

“First timer trying Windy City Pizza. WOW the wings were so good & the thin style pizza hit the spot. Please don’t miss out on this spot!“

“Just had a fantastic authentic Italian pizza. Delicious flavor with prime ingredients and a crust to die for. You will not find anything like this near delray. Can’t wait to go back and try their sandwiches.“

“The food is great. I love it!!!“

“My Italian food go to place Great food, value and service. Give them a try! You'll be back!“

“Dined there yesterday event with 3 other snowbirds, excellent pizza, great salad. It stand shoulder to shoulder with any other Detroit style pizza.we all agreed as good as it gets. We ate from Detroit. Side note the bathroom I used was all black and stunning.“

“I am a Brooklyn Italian, I am A cook, My Mom was a great Italian Chef for us at home. When i go to the restaurant for dinner, it feels like I am home with my Mom. The owners are the sweetest people, the employees are so friendly and are so attentive to your every need. Oh yeah the food, THE FOOD IS MORE THAN DELICIOUS, IT IS SOMETHING I LOOK FORWARD TO FEASTING ON. Just a great place to enjoy an Italian Meal.“

“A local gem!!
First time ever ordering from this restaurant, and this place did not disappoint! Food is absolutely delicious! The veggie stromboli and buffalo lemon pepper chicken wings were so on point! I will be coming back for sure.“

“This is the best pizza in the Boynton Beach/Lake Worth area BY FAR! The crazy thing is, there’s not even a close second. Do yourself a favor, head over to the restaurant and order some things you’ve never even considered. Somehow, every single one will taste like perfection. The house salad, the meatballs, the specialty pie …..all divine!“

“I had an amazing dinner with my family! The steaks were some of the best we had!!! Heather was super helpful in guiding what gluten free items were safe for me to eat (celiac disease)“

“Renzos is the Best pizza in Delray Beach!!! Best sauce, best cheese, best crust. Brooklyn girls know their pizza!!!! 🍕 I love this place. Great owner - very obliging and accommodating. 😊 This pizza place is the one to try. Oh and btw, ask for a little more sauce. Delish. Jacki from Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island !!! An expert on pizza. 😎“

“The picanha was delicious! Cooked perfectly great cuts and seasoned to perfection. The rice and beans we got as a side was also great. It was our first time there and they gave us a complimentary app of their amazing cheesy bread, kebe, and coshinas. We loved it!!! They also had live entertainment and the guy singing all of the classics was spectacular! The service was also very good. Well will definitely be back often! Thanks guys!“

“Have been there in the past. Food is good but too crowded. They make no accommodations. We walked out 3 times this week. Won't try again. They had many empty tables but said they were reserved for later.“

“Great Pizza. we are here about 3 times per week. no exaggeration.“

“Pizza is fresh and great taste!! If you don’t know bout this place you’re missing out on some good pizza! Would recommend this place to all my family and friends“

“ABSOLUTELY EXCELLENT PIZZA 🍕 WITH AWESOME CUSTOMER SERVICE TO GO ALONG WITH IT !!!!! A DEFINITE MUST TRY IF YOU LIKE ITALIAN FOOD ‼️‼️‼️ BEST PIZZA 🍕 IN TOWN FOR SURE ‼️‼️‼️💪🏻🦾💪🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻😁😋“

“Best pizza in lake worth area.“

“Lunch 'specials' are good, fast and a great value. Our "Take Out" Pizza is consistently excellent. A very convenient neighborhood restaurant with good food, a friendly environment and very reasonable prices.“

“The best in Florida!!! since 1973“

“Just had the Stromboli. It was excellent. It was so good I even called them to let them know how happy I was. Love this little place❤❤❤“

“Their Pasta Fagiolo soup is delicious. You get that with a salad for $7 and it fills you up. What a deal!“

“Always a 5 star! I’m Italian from Brooklyn. This is the best you’re gonna get here in Florida. Everything on the menu is great!“

“Had a great meal as usual. Food is superb. Service by John was outstanding. Our favorite restaurant“

“Very good pizza and good prices!“

“Pizza was amazing….I love the service it’s nice to have local teenagers work there and given the opportunity to learn what it is to work! Service was great food was great. I recommend 100%.“

“Stumbled upon this awesome place. Just had Italian the day before, but the pizza by the slice looked amazing, so I stayed. So glad I did. Delicious pizza, delicious salads, amazing lasagna and incredible garlic knots. Relaxed vibe, family friendly and outdoor seating, with folks that take excellent care of you and take pride in their restaurant. I wish I lived in the area, but I’ll be back. Come hungry, you won’t regret it!“

“Big John’s is a very special place! Small but mighty. Warm and welcoming service and food to DIE for! Every plate that came out looked better than the next. We wanted to grab our forks and go to each table to sample all the food! Can’t wait till we are back in West Palm Beach again to hit up big John’s.“

“Try the margarita!! Love it!!🥰“

“Excellent steak and cheese subs here. Been going here for these subs for over 30 years. Tell them you want your steak and cheese sub Tennessee wet style. They know me by that term and what it means is the juices that form while they cook the meat get spread across the sub. By the time you get to the last bite the bread is soaked in the juices, and it is the best part of the sub. Makes my mouth water thinking about it while I'm sitting here in the comfort of my home here in beautiful Tennessee.“

“This place is the best!!!Arrive early after your order so you get the pie home piping hot. NY Pizza heaven! !! I don’t know how they do it. The box is super heavy duty vented maybe but I just can’t get away from just a large cheese pie and a garden salad with house dressing. Extra cheese seems to be they way they do it ,sauce not sweet nor bitter just perfectly delicious and the thin crispy crust! I grew up on Long Island and know really good pizza.!If you call ahead and eat it there right out of the oven it’s almost a religious experience! It took a little while when I moved down to find you but Thankyou for saving my pizza life!“

“Visited from out of town and ran across this great pizza next to our hotel — this place delivered! I’m usually more of a thin-crust fan, but their thick-crust pizza was fresh, flavorful, and really good. The staff greeted me warmly as soon as I walked in. The pizza came out fast, hot, and loaded with fresh, plentiful toppings (Meat Lover's Pizza). So glad I stumbled upon this spot.“

“I had a long day and a hungry toddler so I saw the pizza sign and we went in for a slice. It was rush hour, soo busy and the owners were so friendly and happy. My son felt right at home chatting it up with them! They instinctively asked before putting in the oven not too hot right (right!), cut the slice into two to make it easier for him and each table had napkins lol so this Mom is grateful. My 3 year old didn’t move out of that seat, just enjoyed himself that whole slice. We’ll be back 🍕“

“My dad is a huge “thick crust” type of person and the rest of the fam well that’s not our thing so I ordered a Special XL Pizza (no anchovies) - it was perfection!!! Everyone - even my dad was delighted with the pizza and the BBQ wings! Absolutely recommended both dishes, fast service - ready in 20 mins so I ordered and picked it up quickly and friendly staff.“

“We have been hunting good pizza since we moved to Florida 2 years ago, and all we find is New York style. We found a good one here. Detriot style pan pizza, that reminds me of the old Noble Romens. Fresh ingredients are properly cooked. No frills dining, but the pizza is fantastic.“

“Went here for the first time today and the service and food was amazing! I highly recommend Little Italy Pizza!“

“Slow service but great food“

“Ordered delivery on Doordash and was pleasantly surprised! Great price for a combo meal (10 wings and a large pizza), the food came very fast and was absolutely delicious! The wings reminded me of my fiance's hometown in Buffalo, NY, very crispy but not dry - 10/10. Pizza was also very good NY style. We will definitely be ordering again!“

“This are the best Cuban pizzas in town, a very quick service is a plus. Nice people from my hometown Santa Clara, Cuba. Keep up the good work guys.“

“I am addicted. We just moved nearby a few months ago and have been looking for a go to pizza place. We were a bit skeptical at first, seeing Romeo's is part of a gas station, but wow. Pizza is hot and fresh, the cheese and toppings are delicious and the sauce is perfect, not too sweet and not too acidic. Even the crust is good! The staff are pleasant and kind every time I've gone in. Try the zeppole!! I haven't tried their other entrees yet but hope to in the near future.

Parking: Parking may be limited depending on how busy the gas station is but I haven't had a problem grabbing a spot for take out.“

“My wife says the Eggplant parm is 'last meal' worthy. Thin cut fried .. very tasty. Pizzas/ sauce top notch. Good service and was dog friendly outside. Been several times, never had a bad meal. Bigger salad was enormous but probably should do dressing on side or ask for 1/2 the normal.“

“The food is absolutely delicious. Reminds me of food from up home. Been in Florida for 13 years and we finally have a place that makes food like home. Definitely recommend you give them a try. I know I will be back“

“We are from NJ and cannot find good Italian food. Jays pizza is wonderful!!!“

“Haley was our waitress tonight . She was fabulous. She stopped by to check on us several times with a smile on her face.' Love this place❤️“

“My wife Margaret and I pretty much have always enjoyed Anthony's, even though we have to bring our own Oregano, LOL and have visited many of your restaurants. Your wellington location is now the only one we actually visit. The second or third time we visited your Wellington location. we were greeted at the door by a sweet young lady named Estee. When we sat down to dine, to our delight, we met the most delightful server named Abbey. She was simply the greatest when it came to customer attentiveness. On our next visit we asked Estee if the server with the British accent was working, telling her how much we loved that person. To our surprise Estee happily told us that the server's name is Abby and that Abbey was her mom. We try to make it there at least three or four times each month. Yes, your food is great but I'm sure that you realize that there are many great places to get great pizza in our area. Some are much closer to us than your Wellington location. But even though we can get Oregano at the other places, for us, they are missing one key ingredient, and that is ABBEY. We enjoy watching her with other customers too. She has a way of making people enjoy their dining experience. Honestly, if Abbey in not working, we actually go to the restaurants closer to our home. The evening of April 8th I was there with a friend from NYC and left my ATM card. Abbey texted me that “Liz” has it in the office. T retrieved it the following day. I was able to thank her this evening. Listen, I know that people are quick to gripe and slow to compliment, so please thank Abbey for my wife and me. We much appreciate what she adds to our dining experience.“

“Food was fantastic Oberon Ale. 🍺🍺 Great owner and staff“

“delicious sourdough pizza. we ordered 2 pizzas (og pep and a special with mushroom & thyme) but 1 was enough for 2 people. we felt extremely light afterwards, it didn’t even feel like dough. more like a warm hug with delicious pepperoni. and the mushroom & thyme was like a pasta pizza? amazing! thanks for existing in our neighborhood, aioli fam<3 we truly appreciate you!!“