Geraldi's
1954 Beach Rd, Englewood
(941) 473-7933
Customers' Favorites
Pizza by the Slice
Margherita Pizza
Pesto Spaghetti
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Pesto Veggie
Roast Beef
Meatball
Lasagna
Sausage
Menu
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I am a Jersey girl born and raised. This guy was SO PLEASANT and took me back home for a minute being about an hour away from where I lived. The pizza smell WONDERFUL!! The dough? Soft and the crust as well which I like!! I just got extra cheese 14 inch pizza, my brother got an 18 inch pepperoni. When I took my first bite?..... it was good, with an after taste that would NOT GO AWAY!! I I brushed my teeth AT LEAST 4 times and mouth washed 3 times AND STILL couldn't get that...
We’ve had their pizza a million times—it's always a hit and one of our go-to favorites. But today we grabbed a couple of their lunch meat sandwiches on the way to the beach, and WOW. Total game-changer. Super fresh, great quality ingredients, and packed just right. You can taste the love and attention in every bite. Perfect beach fuel! Whether it's pizza night or a quick lunch stop, they never miss. Highly recommend!
Closest to NY slice in all of englewood. Good sauce. Huge flop to slices. Too much cheese making grease. Crust airy and not too chewy. No crisp.
Sauce 2
Cheese 1.3
Undercarriage 1 large flop
Crisp/chewy ratio 1.2 no crisp, not too chewy
Crust 1.5 airy not too chewy
Overall 7.0. Best ny slice you are going to find in englewood.
Sauce 2
Cheese 1.3
Undercarriage 1 large flop
Crisp/chewy ratio 1.2 no crisp, not too chewy
Crust 1.5 airy not too chewy
Overall 7.0. Best ny slice you are going to find in englewood.
You May Also Like
SandBar Tiki & Grille - 1975 Beach Rd
![]()
American, Seafood, Tiki Bar, Pet Friendly
Beachcomber Trading Post - 1927 Beach Rd
![]()
Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly, American
Lock 'N Key Restaurant - 2045 N Beach Rd
![]()
Seafood, Pubs, American, Pet Friendly